Wednesday, November 4, 2009

Reflections on "Outcasts"

Wow! This was a fascinating piece. The narrative was quite absorbing, and now I wish we'd read the whole thing. I just may need to check it out of the library so I can get the entire story.

Although I found it all interesting, I think my "aha" moments came while reading Chapters 19-24. One thing that really struck me was about how we often perceive things. For instance, some people in Clarkston focused solely on the past—and how the newcomers didn't fit into their comfortable view of Old Clarkston. But some others, even though their original intentions may have been motivated by self-interests, viewed the newcomers differently. The face of Clarkston changed from mostly native-born white Christians to a multicultural stew. The pastor of the local Baptist church said, "I tell people, 'America is changing,'…'Get over it'" (177). And although there are many challenges to integrating these vast numbers of immigrants, there are benefits to those who recognize them: "…while self-interest – economic, spiritual, emotional – might have been a motivating factor, …what was most interesting was what happened once the connecting kicked in. Bill Mehlinger …was so busy going to weddings of his current and former employees. William Perrin…looking forward to his church's potluck dinners because he so enjoyed the exotic meals… The police chief of Clarkston came to identify with the refugees…when it dawned on him that as a black man…he could have been singled out by Clarkston cops" (183-184).

Something else I found interesting was the change in perspective when looking at common denominators. If one only focuses on the differences, i.e., race, religion, traditions, it is hard to see any common ground between individuals of hugely different backgrounds. But, if one instead focuses on all the commonalities, i.e., "A Liberian refugee might be a woman, a Christian, a worker, a single mother concerned about neighborhood crime and the safety of her children…" (184), this "…renders any single category less meaningful" (185).

The final thing that struck me was that ignoring the differences between cultures was more successful than focusing on or even celebrating the differences. "As diversity becomes the norm … people cease to focus on it. Diversity becomes 'no big deal.' The key to making super-diversity work … may have less to do with embracing it than ignoring it" (185).

These readings certainly tie into my service learning, since I am doing work for an organization that tries to help the homeless, Warm Wishes. I have never been homeless, so I do not have that in common; however, as Outcasts pointed out, I have many, many more things in common with the population served by Warm Wishes than our differences. I also think that by ceasing to focus on the differences, one just might help to preserve the dignity of those one is trying to help, because I think that would help to reduce patronizing attitudes.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.