Looking back at the notes I scribbled in the margins of this week's reading assignment, I see words like identity, traditions, culture, hypocrisy, and the like. To find an umbrella phrase that can contain these words or ideas, I think it comes down to this: what does it mean to be human? And I suppose that could be interpolated into: what does it mean to be authentic?
If to be human, to be authentic, is to follow a path not of one's own making but one that has been made by one's parents or ancestors, then is that authentic? No, I don't see how it possibly can be. The only reason to do it, that I can see, particularly if one isn't interested in living that particular life, is to appease the ancestors. Well, who then gets to choose what path to take? Apparently the ancestors (distant or recent). Is this saying that what has happened in the past--a way of life, a way of worshipping, a way of dressing, a way of behaving--is important simply because it represents what has been the status quo for a long time? For some, that may be just fine. But, as Appiah notes when writing about the westernization of dress in Vietnam, "Shouldn't the choice be theirs" (105) and not the choice of their parents or ancestors or government?
When thinking of traditions, and following one's own cultural path, it is important to remember that those traditions, those ways of life, were undoubtedly new at some point. And if that is so, that means that those traditions were introduced or discovered or stolen or created; therefore, those "traditions" have only been traditional for a finite period of time--not something that was written as the world was created. Appiah notes that even the traditional kente cloth of Ghana was not solely a Ghanian creation. First of all, it was created--so that means at some point it was brand new and may have been cause for tremendous upheaval in that society until it eventually became part of the fabric (couldn't resist!) of their lives. "And so with our kente cloth: the silk was always imported, traded by Europeans, produced in Asia. This tradition was once an innovation. Should we reject it for that reason as untraditional? How far back must one go?" (107).
Appiah writes of the popularity of American soap operas in other countries, and how some people garner different "lessons" from these shows. This reminds me of something that happened within the last few years in my own family. My daughter, Lindsey, was living in Austria, in Graz - the second largest city in Austria (which isn't really very large at all), in the southeast corner of the country near the Slovenian and Hungarian borders. When she was living there, she was playing professional volleyball, and all her teammates were Austrian--most from tiny Alpine towns or the villages around Graz, with one from Vienna, so Lindsey was considered quite exotic. At that time, the television show, "The OC" was popular in Austria, although it was called "OC California." One time, some of her teammates overheard Lindsey on the phone with me. At the end of the conversation, she said, "I love you," and I said the same thing to her. When she hung up, one of the girls, Waltraute, said, "You sound just like the OC California" (said just the way you've heard Arnold say the name of our state). This prompted a long conversation into the differences between Austrian mothers and daughters and American mothers and daughters. Apparently some of the characters on The OC were pretty free-wheeling with the I love yous. Waltraute said that she would never think of telling her mother that she loved her--why should she?--it was just silly. When Lindsey and I discussed this, I mentioned that maybe that was a cultural thing, but now that I reexamine it, it seems more likely that it is a personal choice. As a child, I don't remember my parents telling me they loved me, and I don't remember telling them I loved them--so I don’t think my "I love yous" are a cultural thing. For some reason, as an adult, I developed my own custom of telling the people whom I love that I loved them and not keeping the sentiment locked away in my mind. So, like the Zulu guy who took what lessons he needed from "Days of our Lives," (110), so I have perpetuated my own, though certainly not original or unique, custom--and it is one that my daughter also perpetuates: we end our phone conversations with "I love you." Why? Who knows? I don't remember an instance that spurred it. But I don't think it can be a bad thing to share such a powerful and elemental emotional bond.
This, I think, ties in with the contamination that Appiah discusses. And really, isn't almost every culture--at least now--contaminated in some way by other cultures? So we aren't a bunch of islands connected only by the fact that we are all humans. There are bits of this culture and bits of that culture woven throughout the world, kind of like a big patchwork quilt. But the quilt's variations differ depending on the culture of origin because what has been gleaned by one culture might not be thought of as particularly significant by another. Sort of like what lesson can be garnered from watching a soap opera. And then, if one tries to start sorting out what culture "owns" which ideal or custom or work of art, it underscores the mishmash that makes up our global society. "It is that, in simplest terms, cultural property be regarded as the property of its culture. If you belong to that culture, such work is, in the suggestive shorthand, your cultural patrimony. If not, not" (118). Interesting. But this doesn't take into account the artist's point of view. Does this mean that an artist's work isn't original but is derived from his/her country/society/culture? That's rather insulting to the artist. Or is it a point of pride for a country/society/culture to say, "See? See what somebody from here can do? And if s/he can do it, then the rest of us are pretty special too." Appiah does a good job arguing against this perspective. "When Nigerians claim a Nok sculpture as part of their patrimony, they are claiming for a nation whose boundaries are less that a century old, the works of a civilization more than two millennia ago, created by a people that no longer exists, and whose descendants we know nothing about" (119).
Cultural patrimony, seems to me, is often a synthetic, artificial, and arbitrary decision made not by the creator of the product, but by a far-removed bureaucracy. This also makes me wonder about artifacts of a people who were annihilated by conquerors--and perhaps those conquerors are the very people/society/culture now claiming those artifacts as part of their own heritage. Seems pretty hypocritical. Also, as Appiah points out, there is contamination in the art world, where ideas have been borrowed, gleaned, copied from people from other cultures. And then there are those artists who have traveled far from home to practice their art. Think of all the American artists who called Paris home. Is their library of work French or American? Does a work of art belong to any land? And if so, is it the land of creation or the land of the artist's birth? And when tracing Viking relics, how sure can one be that those relics are truly Scandinavian when the Vikings traveled (and plundered) far and wide? By decreeing that Michelangelo's artwork is the property and product of the people of Italy and the Vatican, is, I think, robbing Michelangelo of his due and allowing these other people and governing bodies the opportunity to claim ownership of his glorious talent.
So, I think if I have to label myself--which is something I prefer to resist because I think it stymies my individuality--I would have to say that as far as cultural property, I agree more with the cosmopolitan point of view that the connection to the art and artifacts of our collective past is, "…not through identity but despite difference. We can respond to art that is not ours; indeed, we can fully respond to 'our' art only if we move beyond thinking of it as ours and start to respond to it as art. But equally important is the human connection. My people - human beings - made the Great Wall of China, the Chrysler Building, the Sistine Chapel: these things were made by creatures like me, through the exercise of skill and imagination. …that potential is also within me" (135).
No comments:
Post a Comment
Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.