As I think about this week's readings, I keep coming back to an image that has been popping into my mind: a gyroscope. A gyroscope, as you undoubtedly know, is a spinning wheel whose central shaft is free to take any orientation. It can spin up and down, forward and back, side to side. And like the movements of a gyroscope, authenticity does not seem to be a finite, totally definable quality, but rather one that has numerous definitions as well as an ability to change shape depending on external and internal variables. "But it also has a circular structure insofar as there is a constant back-and-forth between the meaningful possibilities of action opened by the past and the range of goals that open up the future" (129).
In addition to the various definitions and histories that Guignon has shared with us over the course of his book, I still wonder if this – authenticity - is one big ball of yarn that has no end. After all, there are so many unknowns. We know now that we on earth aren't the center of the universe, but we as individuals might often think that we are. "It's my world and you just live in it," are words that have been thrown at me by a certain angst-ridden teenager. So we are and we aren't. "…we are always embedded in and dependent on a wider, shared context of meanings we do not create ourselves" (127). And like that angst-ridden teenager, it would seem that authenticity has a singularly personal definition and yet that definition is filtered through a societal lense. It is both singular and plural. "…what is crucial about authenticity is not just the intensity of the commitment and fervor of the expression it carries with it, but the nature of the content of the commitment as well. …for a commitment to count as authentic, it is not enough that someone feels strongly about the commitment or firmly believes that undertaking it is worthwhile. For the stance to count as authentic, there must be a way for us to see how a person might have reasons to think that such an undertaking really is worthwhile at some level" (158).
What if we – the earth – are just some other-world kid's science experiment. A giant ant farm, perhaps. Would that change our perception of authenticity? Does it really matter what the external "truth" is—all those things that we cannot know? Do our lives have any less meaning if we are just "ants" to some greater mind in some other universe? I don't think so. We all have minds and the ability to think. Our thoughts, though colored by external events, are nevertheless "ours." And to have something that is "ours" or "mine" is, I believe, a form of authenticity.
I think authenticity is the "skull beneath the skin"—the very foundation or substructure that allows us to be human. "To be authentic, on this account, is to take a wholehearted stand on what is of crucial importance for you, to understand yourself as defined by the unconditional commitments you undertake, and, as much as possible, to steadfastly express those commitments in your actions throughout the course of your life" (139).
No comments:
Post a Comment
Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.