Thursday, October 29, 2009

Once again I will be unable to apply this to my service but did ponder how my thoughts might relate to service in general. While reflecting on what it means to have an identity with integrity, personally and socially, I felt Calhoun explained things very well. In reading Guignon first I was annoyed and confused by Franklin's idea of wantons along with the use of the example of addicts as "lacking the kind of will necessary to being a person" (138). I initially understood it to mean these folks were to be thought of as non-human and found this profoundly wrong on many levels. I began to wonder about my classmates who work in the needle exchange program and how they perceived this statement. Guignon continues that wantons contrast to persons as a human agent because persons care about the desires that motivate them (138) a wanton knows but does not care about their motivations. This part may be true but to characterize such individuals as non humans is socially irresponsible. Who is to say what another honestly cares about or if a weak will or a genetic issue is the cause.If one defines a person as a self it is true that addictive behavior interferes greatly with authenticity and colors the ability to know ones true self. The addict however is still a human person who struggles differently than most who undoubtably has cares and desires. Calhoun cleared things up for me by explaining Franklin's wanton in a different way using terms like passive, desires and actions that are not his (236). I still think such individuals have a self as opposed to Franklin who believes they do not. The issue of integrity is another matter as this may be continually compromised by addictive desires. Calhoun continues that wantonness can effect second-order desires causing a disconnect in who they want to be and falling in with a group, not thinking on ones own and questioning if these are right values and hence not ones own values (237). This makes sense. Where does this leave us with those who make informed choices that are in opinions of others not personally or socially responsible? I am not sure. I do agree with the authors of our reading that authenticity and integrity are personal and social. Each is very individual deeply interwoven and not extractable from the other (260). Just as the world seems to be a huge puzzle and the pieces probably fit together in ways we cannot begin to imagin. This is the truly facinating part of being a human person as we interact with each other. The constant evaluation of new experiences and ideas or perspectives of others, yes even the others that may not appear to have the same idea of self and authenticity as I do can help me be more authentic and contribute with integrity. These two readings were the most illuminating and interesting since Freire. Calhoun is right on about integrity being a social virtue and out that comes service.

1 comment:

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.