Thursday, December 10, 2009

It is interesting reading the end of Cosmopolitanism”. It certainly strikes me as an accurate description of how the world works most of the time. I was especially interested in how culture meaning and specific parameters can be defined differently within and without any culture.

Who gets to choose the definition ... The participants, in a democratic way? The observers in a clinical way? And especially how is a culture allowed to be dynamic if it is expected to retain it’s “authenticity”. The world is turning! I think the world is going the way it’s going to go and people will always find a way to circumvent ill intent.


I liked the quote on page 113 “If you are right, I’ll do what you do. If you are wrong. I’ll set you straight.” This reminds me of my son and my conversations with him about his travels and interests. This quote was very similar to what he told me. He has spent several weeks in India and in South Africa. He has been to Egypt and Istanbul. His work in the EU keeps him working with all different cultures and ethics. He maintains his respect for those who behave honorably and tries to speak up only when someone seems wrong. His first cultural outsider’s experience was going to school in Alabama, which is in many ways was very different from the Southern California environment he was raised in. In a way similar to the city/country homogeneous areas Appiah describes in the Global Villages section. One day when he was home for Thanksgiving, college football was on television. The commentator noted that one team was saying a prayer in the huddle. From the kitchen I made a flip remark about how god couldn’t possibly care who won whatever Bowl Game it was. Of course, I have never forgotten that then my son said. “No Mom. I met some of the team. They pray that no players are injured in the game.” How could that never have occurred to me. that lesson has helped me listen and learn about my own suppositions and how I judge. In reality, if I were to pray before a football game, that would be exactly what I would pray for! It was interesting to me that I assumed that “they” would pray for something else.


In my service with Marin Literacy Project my learner is from Mexico. She has a family here and is learning English with intensity. She insists that she is here in the US to stay. She is very eager to master the English language and works very hard. Sometimes though she speaks longingly of the beauty of the area she grew up in. It is one of her main goals to be able to tell her sons exactly, and in English, about their cultural heritage in the place she left behind. By the act of deciding that they will hear her story in English, she is making decisions about, and actually modifying this cultural heritage. As an immigrant, she has affected the static story of her Mexican culture. So, in our lessons, I try to make sure that I don’t make assumptions about which “culture” she aspires to. I like to listen to her enthusiasm about whatever it is she is trying to communicate before I correct her language. Sometimes she refers to her life in Mexico, sometimes there is an aspect of US culture that she is enthusiastic about. I don’t allow cultural value judgement to enter into our discussion. I’m sure it would be easy to misrepresent my culture or to slight hers which I know little about.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.