In Chapter 5, Guignon uses the story of Tolstoy's Ivan Ilych to illustrate how one's perspective of success changes depending on life circumstances. For instance, Ivan Ilych had thought he was happy with his life until he became terminally ill. At that point, as he reflected upon his life, he realized that what he had classified as happy and successful was really empty and relatively meaningless in the scheme of things. He came to understand that he had been at his happiest when he was a child. "It is the nature of grown-up life that we are forced to put on masks and play out little games in order to measure up to the demands of the world. But in gaining the world, we lose our souls" (86). To put circumstances in my own life in perspective, I usually ask myself if "it" will matter to me (or others) when I am 100; this often helps me to weigh the importance of my plans and set my priorities.
Childhood, for many of us, is often remembered as a time of innocence, purity, and happiness. "Whatever the origin of the idea of childhood may be, it is now commonly assumed that the child represents human nature in its purest, most essential form. The condition of childhood is the primal source from which all else arises and unfolds" (84). But childhood, for some, can be where abuse and victimization starts.
Think of the recent news story of an Oklahoma mother of seven who allegedly kept one of her children, a boy, locked in a closet for four and one half years. The boy, who escaped, alleges that he was regularly beaten with chains, starved, and tortured by the mother and her boyfriend. As it turns out, his mother served time briefly many years earlier for killing another one of her children. Now, I have no idea if this woman beat and tortured her other surviving children, but this boy wasn't even allowed to go to school, let alone live in a clean, safe, and loving environment; it appears that this woman was picking and choosing the victims of her unbridled abuse. Clearly this young man has not had an ideal childhood.
Freud explored the "…capacity for cruelty and destructiveness in humans… " (100), saying that "Man 'is a savage beast to whom consideration towards his own kind is something alien'" (100). It is this capacity to behave horribly to others that can be manifested, according to Freud, in everything from nasty remarks to "…the atrocities of dictators…and in the actions, reported in the newspapers on a daily basis, of 'ordinary folks' who starve and beat and shame their children" (101).
The last few weeks, I have been reading about the kidnapping of Jaycee Dugard, the torture of the Oklahoma boy, and also a lengthy article about children who are sold (usually by their parents) into the Cambodian sex trade at the age of 4 or 5. It is with these unspeakably evil happenings in mind that I have filtered this week's readings. And at first, I thought Richard Rorty's positive outlook on social constructionism made sense. But then I tried to filter it through the lense of the boy who was tortured by his own mother or the children who were sold as sex slaves. "…all our possibilities of self-understanding are drawn from the pool of possibilities laid out by our historical culture, and once we see that all these possibilities are contingent, non-binding, we will see that we are free to cobble together whatever personal identity works for us" (116). So, does that mean that these children, whose historical cultures have been one of torture and betrayal by the people who should have loved them unconditionally is limited to that which they know? Or is it more like Foucault, who focused more on "…the way that modern ideas produce forms of power that dominate and oppress us, forcing us into molds that keep society functioning but do little to improve our lives" (117).
What happens to the "self " of people like those I have just mentioned? Guignon writes that, "To be a self is to be buoyed up and carried along by social forces one can never objectify and master, but it is also to be a respondent, capable of saying 'No' to some of those forces in deciding one's own life course" (122). But for some people, saying "No" might not do a thing except to bring on more torture. As Guignon notes, the postmodern self can be extremely fragile.
Finally, I would like to say that for my own "self," I like this quote: "Maturity means accepting the bad with the good" (90).
***
Childhood, for many of us, is often remembered as a time of innocence, purity, and happiness. "Whatever the origin of the idea of childhood may be, it is now commonly assumed that the child represents human nature in its purest, most essential form. The condition of childhood is the primal source from which all else arises and unfolds" (84). But childhood, for some, can be where abuse and victimization starts.
Think of the recent news story of an Oklahoma mother of seven who allegedly kept one of her children, a boy, locked in a closet for four and one half years. The boy, who escaped, alleges that he was regularly beaten with chains, starved, and tortured by the mother and her boyfriend. As it turns out, his mother served time briefly many years earlier for killing another one of her children. Now, I have no idea if this woman beat and tortured her other surviving children, but this boy wasn't even allowed to go to school, let alone live in a clean, safe, and loving environment; it appears that this woman was picking and choosing the victims of her unbridled abuse. Clearly this young man has not had an ideal childhood.
Freud explored the "…capacity for cruelty and destructiveness in humans… " (100), saying that "Man 'is a savage beast to whom consideration towards his own kind is something alien'" (100). It is this capacity to behave horribly to others that can be manifested, according to Freud, in everything from nasty remarks to "…the atrocities of dictators…and in the actions, reported in the newspapers on a daily basis, of 'ordinary folks' who starve and beat and shame their children" (101).
The last few weeks, I have been reading about the kidnapping of Jaycee Dugard, the torture of the Oklahoma boy, and also a lengthy article about children who are sold (usually by their parents) into the Cambodian sex trade at the age of 4 or 5. It is with these unspeakably evil happenings in mind that I have filtered this week's readings. And at first, I thought Richard Rorty's positive outlook on social constructionism made sense. But then I tried to filter it through the lense of the boy who was tortured by his own mother or the children who were sold as sex slaves. "…all our possibilities of self-understanding are drawn from the pool of possibilities laid out by our historical culture, and once we see that all these possibilities are contingent, non-binding, we will see that we are free to cobble together whatever personal identity works for us" (116). So, does that mean that these children, whose historical cultures have been one of torture and betrayal by the people who should have loved them unconditionally is limited to that which they know? Or is it more like Foucault, who focused more on "…the way that modern ideas produce forms of power that dominate and oppress us, forcing us into molds that keep society functioning but do little to improve our lives" (117).
What happens to the "self " of people like those I have just mentioned? Guignon writes that, "To be a self is to be buoyed up and carried along by social forces one can never objectify and master, but it is also to be a respondent, capable of saying 'No' to some of those forces in deciding one's own life course" (122). But for some people, saying "No" might not do a thing except to bring on more torture. As Guignon notes, the postmodern self can be extremely fragile.
Finally, I would like to say that for my own "self," I like this quote: "Maturity means accepting the bad with the good" (90).
***
Julia asked if we can "… illustrate ways in which your own identity has in any way been shifted/morphed/altered through any aspect of the interactions that you have had with others through service-learning?" I don’t think my service learning with MarinLink has changed me at all. I am doing some of the same sorts of things that I do for work, so any changes would have come long ago. On more personal volunteer projects, I have felt an illumination to my outlook—an articulation of deep feelings and a greater appreciation for life. For instance, last Christmas my family decided not to give gifts to each other but to sponsor needy families instead. My daughter and I "adopted" a family where the parents do not speak English, the father works as a laborer, and the mother was recently diagnosed with cancer. Lindsey and I spent far more than we ever would have spent on our normal gift exchanges, but the experience of providing food, clothing, household supplies, and gifts to people we would never meet was heartwarming—and it also helped me to appreciate my own circumstances more. From my point of view, I appreciated the anonymity of the family—to preserve their dignity—and for us as well, because I think it is better to act without self-interest, do our duty not to seek the benefits, and not manipulate others for own interests (thank you, Mr. Kant). Okay, so now I suppose I've screwed it all up by writing about it here! That really wasn't my intent when we joined Adopt a Family Marin.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.