Ok, so as you guys know this blog thing is totally new to me. I think I finally figured it out though.... J
The whole time I was reading Charles Guignon’s book, On being Authentic I had the notion that we would reach one finite conclusion on what it means to be authentic. However, this was not entirely the case. Guignon’s aim I believe was to show us different and conflicting ideas of authenticity and as he states, “I am trying to call attention to the dangerous one-sidedness built into the concentration on authenticity that can arise in the self help movement. What is problematic is not the idea of authenticity, but a narrow and obsessive concern with that ideal at the expense of other valuable ideals and orientations open to us in life.” (p.167)
What a relief.
However, besides my own breath of fresh air for a criticism towards the self-help movement what is important here in a larger picture I think is the idea of one-sidedness. In the final chapters Guignon purposes that authenticity should be thought of as a social virtue and not just a personal virtue.
Calhoun raises the idea that integrity should be seen as a personal and social virtue as well and Guignon purposes that integrity is linked with authenticity which we now know is both a social and personal virtue.
It is obvious how authenticity/integrity can be identified as a personal virtue especially with correlation to the self help- movement but how is it a social virtue? Guignon summarizes Bernard Williams philosophical view, “It is only through our social interactions that we become selves whose inner episodes are given enough steadiness and cohesiveness so that our relations to others can be built on cooperation and trust.” (p.155)
This rings especially true with working with the Marin Aids Project. If the patients don’t trust their staff members, doctors etc. how can they be expected to have hope and feel safe? How can anyone be expected to help themselves or others without relating to other people and the world around them? If there are so many stigma’s and so much ignorance placed on those with HIV, AIDS Hep C or just the disease in general how can one be expected to be able to educate society and possibly help prevent the spread of this rampant disease?
We must know ourselves. We must know ourselves in relation to others. We must know others in order for they’re to be any kind of authenticity and possibility for change. We must let go of stigma’s and we must let go of our one sided minds.
“Instead of being encouraged to master every situation, it envisions a way of letting go of our own personal agendas and experiencing ourselves as participants in a shared event that is greater than ourselves. In this orientation to life, we focus not on what we can get out of a situation, but rather on what we can contribute to the situation.” (p. 166) It has been and will continue to be an honor to work with the Marin AIDS project.
Authenticity then is not a means to an end of finding the true/inner self which is so prominent in the self-help movement but rather a life process or “story” that blends self with others.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.