Thursday, November 12, 2009

Moral relativism is can be very difficult depending on th context and the issue at hand. Reading these articles gives me cause to examine how I might interpret a number of situations. I find myself a bit all over the place depending on the issue. Lukes speaks of switching roles between descriptive and normative as being possible but not easy (26-27). Every sort of human rights issue comes to mind.

Lukes says, " ...the relativity of morals does not mean the absence of universal acceptance, but rather denial of universal applicability" (28). I cannot help but think there are many issues that are universally applicable from a human rights stand point but not universally accepted. When each side weighs in and is at opposite ends where does that leave things personally, politically, globally? I am thinking this is why we have war. Where might the world be if the United States agreed to let Afgahnistan turn Bin Laden over to a Muslim country? Our leaders saw this action as to great a compromise...was it? Does it make since to let a particular population deal with their own extremeists? Possibly the problems are better understood by those that fully under stand the fundamentals such extremes are based on and can hold up the mirror in a more "relative" way?

I have no answers. I do know that these readings give me cause to reflect upon and examine how and why I shape my morals now and in the future, how to shape them with diversity without compromising my values in the process.


No comments:

Post a Comment

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.