Thursday, October 8, 2009

More thoughts

The selection we read from Roy Porter's Flesh in the Age of Reason is refreshingly lucid in its discussion of "knowing yourself." Porter runs through the ages, noting examples of how and when some members of various societies started to question who they were and why they were. His integrated approach not only touches on the reflections of philosophers, but it brings the greater context into focus by including religion, art, writings, and major turning points in history, like the Reformation.

Now, I'm not sure I can articulate what it is I want to say, and that is why I did not include it in my earlier post, but here goes: I think Porter (and Guignon and Taylor too, although I didn't find them as comprehensible) really spells out how the more "we" think one way, the more likely it is to be eventually disavowed; in some cases, whatever had been disavowed, sometimes comes back into favor. I wonder if because we are human and therefore imperfect, if our thinking is imperfect too, and if this explains how ideas appear to gain or re-gain popularity throughout the ages—or is it all a series of power plays?

"Stoic philosophers like Seneca valued suicide as the only permitted expression of freedom and autonomy" (4), and later, the Catholic Church taught that "…self denial was the supreme good…" (5), and it "… squared with the medieval feudal principle that everyone had a preordained position…" (5). This would seem to me to be the power of a ruling entity (government, church) laying down the law as an absolute—and why?—because it threatened their way of life and/or their power? The ancient Greeks, too, when "Socrates and other philosophers began to give expression to the ideals of inner goodness, truth and sacred conscience…" (4) were so threatened by "…such new convictions that …advanced Athenians forced Socrates to drink the hemlock" (4).

With the Reformation, came more of a focus on the self in art and thought. And yet the pilgrims—good protestants who came to this land a couple hundred years later—were both free-thinking and terribly rigid in their thinking. That is, they wanted the freedom to pursue and practice their religion, but their religion and society were inflexible and uncompromising—and that seems to be reminiscent of many of the other societies we have learned about.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.