Our last reading assignment included the final four chapters of Kwame Anthony Appiah’s Cosmopolitanism: Ethics in a World of Strangers as well as an article by In-Suk Cha titled “Toward a Transcultural Ethics in a Multicultural World.” Both pieces of writing take an in-depth look at the global interaction of cultures. As a result, the main topics of In-Suk Cha’s article can be easily supported with Appiah’s writings.
One of Cha’s first points is that, although conflict does break out, various groups of people manage to coexist with each other most of the time. He partly attributes this to his belief that societies have much in common with each other as a result of cultural exchange (4-5). Appiah tackles the same topic in his seventh chapter, where he discusses the homogeneity and “contamination” of cultures. One exemplar he presents is a comparison between Kumasi, the capital of Asante, and villages around twenty miles out from the capital. Although the villages have much less diversity than Asante, they still feel the external influences from things such as “…the World Cup in soccer, Muhammad Ali, Mike Tyson, and hip-hop” (102).
Another major discussion of Cha’s is in regards to global ethics leading towards peace. Cha suggests that progress is already being made in this direction, but that to this end it is important for people to understand the cultural impact of interaction between societies (6). Appiah talks about a similar concept in his eighth chapter, although his discussion consists of specific ethnic issues in regards to the ownership of cultural objects. Toward the beginning of the chapter, for example, Appiah tells the story of how the Djenné-Jeno terra-cottas were dug up and exported despite specific laws in Mali to help prevent such occurrences (117). Appiah goes on to argue that the issue should not be so much about keeping high quality Mali art in the country as making sure Mali has a diverse collection of high quality art from around the world (124).
Cha’s concluding main topic is that although human interaction can be oppositional, there is no such thing as humanity without it (11). This can be comparably seen with Appiah’s concluding chapter, where he attempts to analyze the morality of enduring a cost to help strangers. He brings up the specific scenario of donating money to charity organizations such as UNICEF, and then contrasts philosophical principles that would relate to such a situation (159). Appiah ends by explaining that helping less fortunate strangers is a “demand of simple morality” (173).
- Christopher Galbick
No comments:
Post a Comment
Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.