Thursday, April 29, 2010

From Marty

Connectivity!

Today I was filling out the “Student Final Self-Evaluation” form for my service learning, answering the question of, “In what way were you served by your community partner and the people/communities they serve?” I stated that the experience has expanded my awareness of the struggles of many people who live very near to me, in my own community. The extent of the needs that these people have is enormous and I was surprised by the fact that they are essentially discarded by society as a whole. Butler asks us to ask the question, “Who counts as a human? Whose lives counts as lives? What makes for a grievable life?” (20). It seems there are large sections of our population whose lives do not count and are left by the way side and never grieved for.

Julia, in your prompt you use the quote, “Let’s face it, we’re undone by each other. And if we’re not, we’re missing something” (23). We are missing something when we are not undone by our connection to the suffering of others. We are not undone when we segment our population, when we insulate ourselves from our fellow man and the issues they face and thusly feel no empathy for those who suffer. I finished my service learning several weeks ago, but not a day goes by that I don’t think about the people I interacted with at Vinnie’s. I have been undone by my short relationship to this community. I will go back to it, but my bigger question is how do I get other people to see and feel what I have felt? Can I pass along this “undoneness?” When I try to tell friends and colleagues about my experiences at Vinnie’s there are not many people, outside of my wife, who really care to listen. I have always felt that when people are fat and happy they will never get off their ass and do anything. It is this feeling of uneasiness, this undone instability that forces people to act. While Vinnie’s is doing an incredible service for these people in need, in a strange way, it to is segmenting these people out from the rest of the population. If these folks were allowed to be helped in restaurants that most people frequent, I believe more people would me “undone” by their plight. Can you imagine how people would react? On page 5, Butler states, “Isolating the individuals involved absolves us of the necessity of coming up with a broader explanation for the events.” Now Butler is speaking in regards to 9-11 and Al Qaeda but it is the same basic principal of isolation, blame, make excuses, rashly generalize and move on with our own agendas. Vinnie’s is doing everything it can to help those who have fallen below the poverty line and also continues to keep others from falling victim to the same fate, but the root causes need to be discovered and addressed to truly fix the situation.

Julia’s final quote also made me come undone. “We do not need to ground ourselves in a single model of communication, a single model of reason, a single notion of the subject before we are able to act” (48). Well I am the first to admit I was not grounded in any way shape or form with regards to Vinnie’s. I hate to say it, but if it had not been for Julia’s class, I never would have gone there to volunteer and expose myself to this community. The fact is that I just went there. I did not plan anything or worry about how I was going to fit in or how I was going to relate or communicate with the people there; I just went; I just acted. Hopefully I helped them in a small way and they certainly helped me. Can we force others to volunteer? Can we make everyone take Julia’s class? We can not gain from loss as Butler theorizes, unless we feel the loss first hand.

1 comment:

  1. Marty, you rocked this reading in connection to your service. . . you show so beautifully how the service can really help illuminate and uncover complex textual meanings. You do a wonderful job at not being a "literalist" meaning, you can take the ideas beyond the context that Butler uses--and that is what she and any philosopher wants the reader/thinker to do. 911 is her "service" in a sense, it is the experience that she is using to develop her understanding and pose an interpretation that has wider applications. Thanks, Marty, for going where few dare to tread.

    ReplyDelete

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.