Monday, April 5, 2010

Stories, Words, and Perspectives (Whistleblowers)

The choice of the author to look at support groups as a means to attempting to understand whistleblowers is a great idea. However, I believe that the author lacks the basic necessary background of support group purposes, aims, and purposes to truly be able to use his resources to full potential. As a person that has spent many years working with alcoholics and addicts, I find the idea that any support group charge an entry price of a person's story to be ridiculous. Also, to then discount the entire purpose of a given support group, once it becomes clear it is not the same purpose of the author's, is very close to being insulting to the group - and its members.
For any given 12-step group (which this whistleblower group is NOT), there is no requirement for membership. The idea that a person's story must be told devalues the fact that it is considered to be a privilege to be asked. Most groups seek out fellow members that they believe will carry a message that will help in the recovery of the group's members.
However, even a cursory glance at a support group for whistleblowers - a place where such persons can feel safe to let their feelings of hurt actually show, and discuss their bafflement at life along with those few people that will actually understand - that won't place them on a pedestal, nor look upon them with mistrust - has a completely different reason for existence. There is no need for any sort of "recovery." Instead, there is simply the need to be a part of an "organization" that understands. After all, is this not what they were under the impression that they belonged to in the first place?
For the author to attempt to compare such groups, and purposes, and determine that they are the same leaves me with serious doubts about the author's analysis.

However, the author goes on to discuss the style and verbiage of different members. He discovers themes among the various narratives. This I found to be worth pondering on. It led me into an interesting area: the manner in which different people attempt to communicate.

The duality of each of us leads to some of us to refer to themselves, or even a collective "we" as "you." As in "you must ..." which is really saying "I must ...," "We must ...," or even "I have, you could ..." However, it often appears (at least, according to the author) that this duality is has become submerged in the whistleblowers. They have ceased to think in duality - to see themselves as separate from themselves in some way (or they see themselves as completely separate and are unable to reconnect - they have become the archetype in their own mind). This leads to a style of communication that removes the words "you" and "we" and replaces them all with "I." However, this individualism allows for communication that has the ability to impart knowledge in a way that few other ways can. After all, if I am listening to your story, I can take parts and make them my own - those parts that I identify with.

Also worthy of note: It is always to be remembered that one is only paranoid when one is wrong - otherwise it is intuition.
While some of the stories that the author used for his examples definitely fall into the category of being paranoid, some of the of the thoughts express I believe have merit - and so does the author. For example, not being able to talk about the issue that needs to be discussed could be called paranoid, but it is not when this is actually occurring.

I look forward to discussing this further, and learning more about the struggles that come after making such a great sacrifice.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.