Friday, April 16, 2010
Alford has several statements that I feel are sign posts when looking for the root cause of why people do or do not commit awful acts to others. This is something we should look long and hard at when trying to discern the underlying issues. On page 75 he states “…we should consider what kind of world we live in when nobody feels shame for anything. This seems to be how it works, the capacity to feel shame for one’s own acts inextricably interwoven with the capacity to feel shame for others.” On page 67 he talks of Hannah Arendt and how she suspects that the ground of all ethics is the ability to take others into account. Finally on page 95 Alford says “Morality stems from empathy, in which we are deeply affected by the sufferings of others.” If we feel no shame in anything we do then we do not worry about the consequences and more importantly we do not feel for the people to whom these consequences affect. More and more it seems that the consequences to our actions are becoming less and less. What do I mean by that? In our celebrity based/obsessed society, not only are we prompted to watch and comment and be fascinated by all these terrible, selfish acts committed by these “famous” people, but they never seem to pay the full price for their indiscretions. See Tiger Woods, cheats on his wife with 20 plus other women then is cheered on by thousands at the Masters. Now Alford’s contentions are that the whistleblowers do not necessarily have empathy for others but are motivated by moral narcissism. But if morality stems from empathy, then these whistleblowers are thinking of others and not just themselves and they are taking others into account. I am just happy that no matter the reason they blow the whistle the most important fact is that they DO blow the whistle. I think the people committing these selfish, atrocious acts are the narcissistic ones. If the narcissism has led people to do what is right is it something we should promote in a good way?
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment
Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.