There are several issues I had with the context of narcissism as Alford describes it. I do not want to belabor the terminology and all its nuances, however, he is overly simplistic in his insistence on whistleblowers being narcissists. I agree that they are struggling with an inner dialogue that required them to act in "choiceless-choice." But he only is drawing from the stories of a few whistleblowers who I agree are narcissistic, but they do not in any way seem to be representative of a majority. I do agree that there is a commonality of inability to "double." It was exactly that aspect in my own experience that drove me to speak out. I was intent on being true to my authentic self. Holding onto integrity. Does this make me narcissistic? I don't believe so. I also felt that I did not have much of a choice (if I was going to continue to stay with the organization). But it was a group of people I was associated with, that were also being affected by the perpetrator that made the choice seem more important. I thought I was one of the few who could take the risk of saying something, when others lived in fear of losing their paycheck or their health benefits. I had been the victim before and did not speak up because I was more isolated, and it was me against the world (so to speak). Now the issues I was faced with seem more systemic and less worthy of a fight. Perhaps this is the futility that the whistleblowers in the book seem to get stuck on.
I think that Alford fails to review in correct context that there are whistleblowers who do not get stuck. Many won't, and therefore do not partake in the whistleblowers support groups like the one frequented by Alford. So with this in mind, it does not surprise me that he found that such a majority had the symptomatic narrative that he describes. Most whistleblower stories are the untold story. They speak up tell their story to someone, they are retaliated against to silence or discredit their story, and so the whistleblower moves on and does not necessarily retell his/her story. The successfully silenced story, but no less a whistleblower story than the ones rehashed in the support groups Alford describes. Would these same whistleblower narratives possess the same qualities that he theorizes about? I am not so sure. I think that what Alford is proving is the narrative of a group of individuals that share in a commonality that happens to be in a whistleblower setting, but does not truly speak of either whistleblowers in general or the public at large. Instead what is presented is a theme of how individuals respond to conditions of tyranny, or put in lighter terms, in situations in which their freedoms are illusionary.
I think Alford states the dilemma beautifully on page 68, "The double meaning of 'belonging to' says it all: they are part of and possessed by the group." That statement brings to mind a comment that someone made to me when I was working with the Phoenix Project. This man came up to me and asked me, "Who do you belong to?" At the time I saw it as a rather sexist remark that I had to be possessed by a man or something. In the greater context, however, I see that many of these young men struggle with a sense of "belonging." Isn't that the whole reason that gangs form? They fill the void left by a lack of association in the culture at large or even within family units? Reading that statement has given me a greater appreciation for the double meaning of the word belong.
To belong implies a linking together, but usually a voluntary submission in exchange for meeting a need. In the case Alford puts forth it is the need to provide for our families and pay a mortgage that spurs the need to belong to an organization that we work for. And it is the loyalty or integrity to this type of organization that the whistleblower is intent on keeping intact. But as Alford stated in the previous chapters, the organization serves as an enemy of individual morality. This is what the whistleblowers he uses as examples cannot seem to come to terms with. Because they cannot live in duplicity they are forced to make a choice.
That need to live a duplicitous life I would suspect is what leads to other moral ills. Is it not the source of extramarital affairs? This ability to lead a double life. Neither of the two selves created in these examples is whole or true, and therefore loses meaning to me. Like Arendt mentioned before, you have to be able to live with yourself. Can you live with a person that can ignore morality for the sake of making money? For that is the choice presented to whistleblowers who are asked to do immoral acts, or who witness immoral acts and have to decide whether to follow orders and say nothing or speak out.
Alford gives an example of how morality is twisted in definition on page 72, "What is right in the corporation is not what is right in a man's home or in his church. What is right in the corporation is what the guy above you wants from you. That's what morality is in the corporation." I think perhaps this is the stream of conscience that allows people within organizations to check their individual morality at the door and continue in their duplicity. By believing such a statement can absolve any internal conflict of moral objection to actions taken by an organization (or its representatives). Yet another example of the good ol' "just following orders" approach that permits all kinds of suffering.
Overall, I can agree with Alford with his statement on page 93, regarding narcissism moralized being, "the goodness of the self is the highest value." We do need to question how people can live in a culture where "goodness of the self" and respect for others are not a valued quality. But it almost seems that the whistleblower has to volunteer for the role as scapegoat (even though unaware of this potential outcome), and I do not see how that can be viewed as narcissism in any context. In reflection of events as they are recounted later can be taken in their narrative as acts of narcissism. But this is because the whistleblower has to come to terms with what has happened, and to have a self-important review of the facts gives the events greater meaning than perhaps they did in reality as they occurred. All this to dissuade both themselves and others that their efforts were all in vain.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.