I'm having lots to trouble identifying any of the concepts raised in Whistleblowers with my community service work. However, I have lots of things to identify with as an employee of various companies and organizations for my entire work life, which spans 31 years--and if (big if) I had anything to say about my current employer I certainly would not feel comfortable posting it online--I care more about my family well being than my own "moral purity" and since I'm not aware that anyone was at risk of losing their life from anything my current or former employers ever or worked on, I really don't know if I'm of the kind of moral fiber to become a hero in the way whistleblowers do. I just haven't been in a position to know how I'd react.
This is somewhat of a frustrating assignment because I believe my blog post is going to fail to meet the professor's expectations. Having said that, I'll do what I can to make a fit for my experience with my community partner and the current reading assignment. On the final prompt, Prof. van der Ryn wrote: "Basically, I am hoping you will think about your own resources for ethical action, and/or what motivates those you serve with, and how you or someone you serve with bridges the gap between nice idea and lived reality. . . "
Okay, let's try this on for size: Warm Wishes', founder, after trying to run the non-profit that provides warm clothing and "Streetpacks" to the homeless from his home, had to pull back and ask for some help running the non-profit. One time, because he used his home address and phone number, he was contacted very early in the morning by a woman who had just lost her housing and was on the streets with her kids. There comes a time when you feel too exposed, and not wanting to get in the business of actual homeless sheltering, he decided it was time to de-personalize the project and get a business address, phone number and the like. While this man has a huge heart and wants to help, he also has boundaries between his wish to do good deeds for others and his willingness to allow it to affect his personal life too up close and personal. Does this mean he is good at "doubling" --the concept brought up repeatedly by Alford in the chapters we read this week? I'm not sure it's a good fit by that's all I can come up with relating to my CP.
On the text:
One of the pieces that really stood out for me in the readings is on page 78, where the idea of "thumos" is discussed "the human spirit that feels indignation at baseness and corruption. Above all, thumos rebels at anything that would bring shame upon the self. The trick is to educate thumos so that it gets shamed by the right things . . . " Then, on the same page the discussion of soldier who reported on the My Lai massacre relates how "the brass corrupted his buddies' innocence. Suddenly he was in a whole new world, a world in which he would have to act to purify himself of knowledge he had gained but never wanted. That too made him furious. While he felt genuine compassion for the victims at My Lai, their suffering was not, it seems, the deepest source of his anger. That was reserved for those who would corrupted his, and his buddies', innocence. [next paragraph] The narcissistic rage of the whistleblower is in some ways his least attractive aspect. It is , in an sense, utterly selfish: a sense of "Look what you have done to my moral purity! What distinguishes the whistleblower's narcissism from that of the ordinary narcissist is that the whistleblower's narcissism is wounded by the right thing: . . . [next paragraph] Not too many things will make a man or woman give up everything for his or her beliefs, but wounded narcissism is one. Some people will go to the ends of the earth to salve their wounded narcissism, devoting their lives to moral purification. It is, I believe, the source of the lives of the saints and the lives of not a few sinners and fanatics too." (78-9).
So, for those of us who are not of the moral fiber to be saints, martyrs, etc. but who still feel outrage at what we experience and have an urge to act, but feel like doing so is too dangerous, we do other things, often destructive--self medication is one, and one in which many Vietnam vets fell into the practice of during those troubling times. I know numerous Vietnam vets, some of them still on drugs, others that were able to overcome the psychological trauma some how, drug free, and still live relatively normal and successful lives. Perhaps the latter group are more adept at "doubling."
I'm curious if others in the class have thoughts about this. Are those who can double somehow less morally correct than those who cannot? Can they be more effective in life and society by staying "in" (not getting themselves scapegoated)? Are there ways to remain operative without wounding your morality when incidents expose one's organization's activities don't sit well with them from a moral standpoint?
No comments:
Post a Comment
Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.