Thursday, April 29, 2010

Responding to the prompt: "The rise of anti-intellectualism--what does Butler mean by this/how does she illustrate this phenomenon/what are the implications?": On page 2 Butler wrote: "Although we have heard, lately, about the abusive treatment of prisoners, and war "mistakes" have been publicly exposed, it seems that neither the justification nor the cause of the war have been the focus of public intellectual attention." No, well of course not. Despite much public outcry at the time the Bush administration decided ousting Saddam Husein in Iraq was the right way to address preventing further acts of terror of the likes of 9/11, people were forced to shut up under the premise that to keep on arguing and protesting how misdirected the operation seemed (did we forget that Osama bin Laden was behind the twin towers attack?!!), it suddenly became politically incorrect to risk and offending the troops and their families that we just sent off to the war on terror in Iraq. All of a sudden, it was unpatriotic to object, no matter how insane the misdirected attack seemed to so many people. The repeated refrain "if you're not with us, you're against us" made any grey area in public discourse politically dangerous. Peoples right to privacy was being scaled back to the point even our library checkout activities became subject to review, and rules of spying loosened to increase law enforcement's advantages at potentially apprehending terrorists before they act. This is one way in which our intellectual instincts were beaten back.

The discussion of Prince Alwaleed bin Talal's remaks on October 11 in New was a great example of how criticial discourse got completely lambasted during that time as well.

Regarding "Who counts as human?" The discussion of loss of Palestinian liberties and lives compared to Isreali lives in that ongoing conflict, hits home for me. I know many people who are afraid to voice their opinions too openly (like me right now--I admit to being apprehensive) that the Israeli methods of cracking down has gotten out of hand. There is great fear of offending those in powerful positions who put more emphasis and deem Israeli lives more important and worth defending than they do Palestinians lives. Both cultures are human and deserving of basic human dignities and both have a history in and claim on the area. Neither of them will win this fight to control or rid themselves of each other without continuing to incur such sever suffering themselves that the whole effort becomes pointless. It will never create peace or security. But the point Butler seems to be making is that people are afraid to speak their minds, due to the First Worldish "might makes right" attitude. I think this is also might be one of the factors of anti-intellectualism. People are made to be afraid of talking about things in a circumspect manner, because of fear of offending the powerful.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.