Thursday, April 15, 2010

Theory and Practical Application

"The narcissist wants to be whole, good, pure, and perfect. There are two ways to
do this. Either one lowers one's standards of wholeness, goodness, purity, and
perfection until they correspond to one's miserable self. Or one raises one's miserable
self as high as one possibly can so that one comes a little closer to these ideal standards."
- C. Fred Alford, Whistleblowers. p. 63

"... we go back and forth between moral psychology and moral theory, using one
to illuminate the other." - C. Fred Alford, Whistleblowers. p. 83

"... it is not the job of moral theory to talk with moral actors."
- C. Fred Alford, Whistleblowers. p. 83

"Morality stems from empathy, in which we are deeply affected by the sufferings of others."
- C. Fred Alford, Whistleblowers. p. 95
When we first began this class, an orientation was given. It was made clear that the purpose
of this class was to connect theory of the classroom with practical experience. It was to take on
the application of morality in the real world - to work to fight injustice in a very real and
experiential sense. It was to connect the theoretical with the actual.
Is that not what the whistleblowers have seem to have done? To have internalized
the espoused values that they have been taught to the point of actualizing what was intended
to simply be a best-case scenario theory?
According to the first quote above, wouldn't the vast majority of people then be narcissistic?
After all, most people seek to improve themselves in some way. Either that, or they learn to
adapt themselves to their current situation. This sounds very close to meeting the threshold
articulated. Where is the distinction?

The analogy of the baseball player and the physicist is an intriguing one - as far as the use
of different language and terms go. The idea that the physicist would be able to explain the
motion of the ball traveling through the air, while the pitcher simply does it and offers different
verbiage seems to be sound. However, the question that I would ask is this: Would the
physicist have the desire to learn to throw the ball in a curve? If so, would the ego of the
physicist allow him to learn from the pitcher? And, vice versa, would the pitcher be interested
in learning the mathematical model behind what he does? Would he be willing to learn new
terminology in order to understand, and take further advantage of that knowledge to make
the ball do even more challenging flights?

Morality and empathy are not necessarily the same thing - and should (and do) not always require one
to know the "other" that is being helped. In my own case, I have taken to calling various business
owners that are close to defaulting on their business licenses in order to save them the grief of
having to pay a late registration fee. Sometimes it turns out that they have gone out of business
and have simply forgotten to inform the city. Other times, they have been too caught up in other
things to find the time. The end result of this is that it saves both them and the city money
and time. This is not an act of morality or empathy - this is simply a way to be kind in such a way
as to save others trouble. I don't do it out of a sense of obligation, and I certainly don't do it
out of a need to see myself as better than I actually am. I do it because it makes me happy to
be kind.

Now, I know that I am not a whistleblower, but could there be alternative reasons that have
not yet been explored behind the actions that these individuals take and why they feel there is
no choice left for them? Could it be that they feel that they have been placed in a catch-22? They
are damned-if-they-do-and-damned-if-they-don't? Wouldn't such a situation give a remarkable
amount of freedom to do what one wants and feels is the best moral choice? Having been placed
into that situation, wouldn't it seem to cease to be a choice? For example, if one was told to lie
to the Feds about the company's practices (which are illegal), wouldn't there be the catch-22
scenario? If the Feds find out, one goes to jail - no matter how long has passed potentially. As such,
would this case result in being free to tell the truth as it could be seen that the job is lost no matter
what? Better to tell the truth and simply loose the job than to lie, be caught, go to jail, and still loose
job anyway.
I have a hard time believing that being placed in such a position makes one narcissistic. However,
I also have a hard time believing that this would lead to a person being caught in the past. So,
maybe, in the end, I have no idea what I am talking about.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.