Thursday, April 29, 2010

Failure at walking a very narrow line

Given that I am a former United States Marine, and served during the time when the primary focus of the United States military was in Iraq, which was one of the responses to the attack that occurred on September 11th, 2001, I do not feel that it is appropriate for me to respond to the subject matter discussed in this particular reading. However, I did find much of the questions posed, within the framework of the subject matter to be deeply interesting and worthy of reflection. As such, I will give my thoughts on a few of the questions asked in the text.


"Our fear of understanding a point of view belies a deeper fear that we shall be taken up by it, find it is contagious, become inflected in a morally perilous way by the thinking of the presumed enemy. But why do we assume this?" -- Precarious Life, p. 8

This is a basic fear of the unknown, of challenge to our own deeply held beliefs - ones that we may not actually feel to be on solid ground. We are afraid of the grey that exists in almost all situations - of the full story - as it may force us to adjust and find a complex answer to a question that we thought was simple. Worse, it may force us to examine our actual beliefs, and they may not hold up to support the person we thought that we were. And even more horrifying, we may find that contemplation of this sort will set us adrift - we will no longer have the certainty that we crave for the feeling of safety and self-righteousness that we depend on and that gives us such inner pleasure (that feeling of superiority).
We assume that they are wrong and we are right because to examine the unknown usually leads to understanding - the worst enemy of hate and superiority (or inferiority). The process of examination sends us, for a time, into uncertain waters ... waters that we fear may swallow us up and lead to our destruction. And it does - the destruction of our hate. What replaces this ignorance and these simple ideas is understanding and acceptance that the world is a much more complicated place, one that does not, in fact, much of the time, make much sense to us. This is partly due to the fact that we almost never have enough of the information necessary to truly make an informed decision. Not having all of the information can be maddening - to admit, even to ourselves, that we do not have all the pieces can lead to a feeling of being "out-of-the-loop" and that we are not as important as we like to sometimes think we are. It also can lead to a place of mistrust - which truly can be alarming.
Nevertheless, it is essential that we question ourselves and be willing to seek for other perspectives. There are always more than two. Open-mindedness is a critical tool towards avoiding violence and harm (both of others and ourselves). However, even violence requires an open mind - after all, if we are truly willing to look at different perspectives (especially those that we disagree with), then violence must sometimes be considered. David Webber once wrote that violence is a diplomatic even - it occurs if and when diplomats fail. I agree with this statement fully. I also believe that it is not the military that advocates war - after all, the military is the organization that will suffer the most in the event of such action. No, it is usually the politicians, special interest groups, and even the public that advocates such actions. But, if I am truly open-minded, I must be willing to look at the possibility that perhaps there are other forces (including the military) that encourages war.
All in all, though, it seems to me that the greatest reason for violence, lack of agreement, unity, and aggression, is not failure of diplomacy or anger - it is close-mindedness and willful ignorance.

1 comment:

  1. Hi Ken, Could you have used the prompt that I gave you which is not framed or constrained by the issues that you don't want to address. I totally understand that you don't want to, but I am not sure that it would be inappropriate as many present and former members of military have participated in dialogues about these issues. But, of course that is your choice! But the purpose of the prompt was to try to get you to think about the philosophical propositions in relation to your service. At the same time, what you have here is a beautiful and important statement and exploration of some core ideas that Butler presents.

    ReplyDelete

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.