Tuesday, November 30, 2010

Human Culture

I grew up in Minneapolis, attending inner city public schools where I was constantly surrounded by all sorts of different cultures. I spent much of my childhood as the “white girl.” I would wish many things: I wished I could find some magical lotion that would erase my freckles and darken my skin, I wished my hair would turn curly and darken and that I could have fuller lips and a less pointy nose. I thought all of these things would make my life so much easier and maybe they would have. But I am thankful I was able to be the different looking girl that still fit in, in her own strange way. From that experience I now know what it’s like to be different than others, but I also learned that even in our differences I was similar to everyone I went to school with. In Cosmopolitanism, Appiah says, “We do not need, have never needed, settled community, a homogeneous system of values, in order to have a home” (113). In many ways this is how I feel about my upbringing. I was surrounded by many value systems, and this in many ways was better.

When people hear my last name ‘McMurchie’ and meet my family full of blue eyed, freckled, blonde and red headed people, they immediately assume I am Northern European. Of course this assumption is in part correct, but I’m so much more than that. The first true beauty in life is that we are all different: yes my family eats lefse and celebrates St. Lucia day, but my dad also cooks Ethiopian food, because our Ethiopian neighbors introduced us to it. The second true beauty in life is that though we are different, we are also the same. We have a “shared ethics,” and there are common human universals, which I learned first hand from my experiences growing up.

Appiah says: “Talk of cultural patrimony ends up embracing the sort of hyper-stringent doctrine of property rights that we normally associate with international capital” (130). We can’t patent our cultures: they overlap, like my traditional culture overlaps with “American” culture and the culture of those I went to school with. I think if I were to choose, I would identify myself as a member of the human culture. I have been too “culturally contaminated” (as have most of us) to identify with one particular something. Appiah says there is no cultural purity and it is an oxymoron. I’m happy about that, because I would not want to be eating lefse all the time.

Peace, War and Contamination

Since the beginning of human time, peoples of the world have been at war with each other. There has never been a point where there was complete peace and harmony in the world; many religions state that this will never happen until the end of time when judgment day comes. This constant human strife has been blamed on various aspects that govern humanity. However, in "Towards Transcultural Ethic in a Multicultural World" In Suk Cha states that violence is not caused by fear of the other since "we humans share too much in common with each other in our societies"(5) One could say that all humans are basically brothers. In order to find peace in the world we must acknowledge the fact that we need live with and in companionship with others. In his book Cosmopolitanism Kwame Anthony Appiah brings up the opposing force to cosmopolitans. Neofundamentalists or counter-cosmopolitans think that there is a universal truth and ethic that does not identify with any religion or culture. That is, except for theirs. They believe that everyone should agree with their view of how the world should be. If they don’t, violence follows. There exists a saying that goes "if you don’t want to be my brother, I will smash your skull in"(145). This is considers a malign or damaging form of universalism. In theory universalism should be the best thing for human kinds. It should create a utopia where we all respect the same universal ethic that keeps us at peace with one another. That type, and other non radical forms of universalism, can be considered benign, and striving for the genuine good of the world. The reason, it seems to me, that it is so difficult to achieve this universal ethic is that we are all so different; which brings us back to cosmopolitanism.

The other thing that Appiah discusses in these chapters is the concept of cultural contamination. In my mind I see it more as cultural evolution. The "contamination" part exists when one culture is influenced by another and adopts some new customs and makes changes to old ones. To me this sounds like the natural process that evolves cultures to change with the times. The advantage that comes from a culture that enriches itself with others is that you most likely already live a cosmopolitan life "enriched by literature, art, and film that comes from many places, and that contains influences from many more"(113).

Thankfully I cannot relate the violence that can sometimes result from opposing universalism to my service learning. However I can see cultural contamination in my daily life. In the end, I do live in America. The United States is considered a melting pot of cultures, traditions, and values. We have shaped our nation in response to the different influences that have affected us. If you ask any American what they are their answer will most likely go something like a list of various nationalities that span across the globe. The fact that we are so diverse gives us a leg up in the quest to being cosmopolitans that understand and accept all cultures and strive to live civilly and socially with all.


-Ilaria Guerra

Moving Together

Appiah simply states, "Above all, relationships are changing" (Appiah 103). Appiah recognizes the sometimes negative aspects of this truth, but, more importantly, he acknowledges that relationships must be open to change to encourage cosmopolitanism and the shaping of new lives. It is an impossibility to actively attempt to keep members of a particular culture locked into that tradition. People must be allowed alternatives, and cultures should be left to shift as change naturally comes, not meticulously preserved. Suk Cha believes that all societies have come into some sort of cultural exchange with one another. Appiah says, "The point is that people in each place make their own uses even of the most famous global commodities" (113). There are certain aspects of society that are nearly universal in their existence, but individual cultures remain through the specific treatment of these universal aspects. Cosmopolitanism and a kind of homogeneity can exist smoothly along side cultural exchange.
Appiah calls for an awareness of the suffering of others and the need for a moral obligation to all neighbors (no matter how distant), but also recognizes this as a tricky subject. Why should I care what happens to a complete stranger? Why should I sacrifice what I have to better someone else's life? Though these sound like shallow questions, they are more than viable. Appiah suggests, "Cosmopolitanism is about intelligence and curiosity as well as engagement...It involves seeing not just a suffering body but a wasted human life" (168). Using more than purely moral emotion, cosmopolitans must realize their cross-cultural obligations through reasoning and knowledge of the effects, risks, and outcomes.
The 211 phone service Nick and I have been helping these past months is a true example of Appiah's point. Of course, the United Way is not responsible for these strangers who are in need of help, but they have realized through intelligent thinking that it would be beneficial for the whole of our society to aid them in their struggle.

Monday, November 29, 2010

Dirt & Disaster

We think of the word "contamination" and immediately think of something dirty, something foul, something unwanted. Pollution. Appiah provides a new spin a this word and casts it in a different light that I found to be quite profound. "People who complain about the homogeneity produced by globalization often fail to notice that globalization is, equally, a threat to homogeneity" (101). As humans, we have a tendency to see things from one perspective, one point of view, and one ideal. Are we caught in a cycle of achievement and relapse?

Since we all like to think of ourselves, and more broadly, our communities and various related units as unique, do we have a fear of homogeneity? I think that it's safe to say that yes, yes we do. The fact that Appiah sees this phenomenon in the flip side was quite interesting to me, and he worded it in a way that I never really thought of before. Globalization is a threat to cultural homogeneity. Our increasingly more accessible and user-friendly global network is playing a part in not just bringing us together as an international and multiracial and diverse community, it is also playing a part in dividing and separating already somewhat homogenized groups, such as tribal communities, tight-knit families, culturally accepted norms, etc.

But within this division, there is infinite space for beauty and growth. Within these "threatened" communities, "whatever loss of difference there has been, they are constantly inventing new forms of difference" (103). Things are constantly changing. We can "sympathize" with cultures that are perhaps losing their pre-globalization-boom roots, "but we cannot force their children to stay in the name of protecting their authentic culture; and we cannot afford to subsidize indefinitely thousands of distinct islands of homogeneity that no longer make economic sense" (104).

So can we deem today's generation, my generation, as being "inauthentic," simply because the values and practices of communities around the world today may not exactly mirror those of their respective ancestors so many years ago? If we take Appiah's theory (and the general consensus) that things are in constant motion and change, then we cannot blame this generation's differences from previous ones. We adapt. We shift. And we practice and preserve as our present sees fit.

With this global community now taking precedence above our more local communities, the issues of morality and loyalties come into question, and Appiah poses the question to us: What are we doing to actually help the world today? Are there universals binding us together morally? I particularly enjoyed Appiah's discussions around the drowning child and giving to the needy. When are our actions not enough? Where do we draw the line between selfishness and selflessness? "... Cosmopolitan moral judgment requires us to feel about everyone in the world what we feel about our literal neighbors (a strength of feeling that is perhaps exaggerated by the suggestion that for them, at least, we would risk our lives)" (157-8).

"So how much do we really owe to strangers?" (158). I personally would certainly show any stranger the respect, kindness, and love I would like to receive in return (there's that twisted Golden Rule again...), and then some. But to universalize my own ideals would be un-cosmopolitan of me. So to address a few of Appiah's questions regarding how I would react in a certain situation... I honestly don't feel compelled to donate all of my money following a natural disaster. I would rather occasionally dish out what I could afford to give (as a starving artist and student) unconditionally. I would rather give frequently to charities that I stand behind and believe in (I give generously to the SPCA when I can). I would rather save the drowning child than stand there and do nothing (I should thank my overbearing guilty conscious for that one too...) - who wouldn't?

In my Service-Learning, I don't necessarily see myself as doing some "kindness to strangers" as much as I am doing something good for myself and because my students have shown a desire and interest in learning what they are here to learn. It is one thing to provide a service to a willing student, and another to talk to a brick wall. In the classroom, as we learned from Freire's Pedagogy of Freedom, it is all about give, give, give, and take. I am not saving anyone, and I am not providing a charitable service (be it voluntary or not). I am doing something for someone because I believe in the cause, and because someone has a passion and desire to better themselves on their own accord. Natural disaster not required.


Phillipa Armes

Another Cosmopolitan Please

In Suk Cha:
"One of the reasons why modern humanity cannot claim vestiges of primordial fear of difference as viable cause for violence and conflict is that we humans share too much in common with each other in our societies. It is difficult to find any group or society that has not entered into some sort of cultural exchange with another." (5)

In discussing the possessing cultural objects, Appiah brings up this point in the title of the chapter, “Whose Culture is It, Anyways?” and uses multiple examples of both difficulties in defining national ownership as well as the idea of “cultural authenticity.” For example, the looted Aban treasure “was, in fact, splendidly cosmopolitan” gathered over centuries of looting done by Kamasi in the same way the British museum contains an incredible cross section of works from colonization and seizures, as well as, it should be noted, purchases and loan agreements (133). Further, Appiah takes the idea of no single ownership to connect all human beings together as preserving a diverse human cultural record assessable to all, owned by none, and cared for by citizens and organizations which understand the possession as a responsibility to others rather than a right to exclusive access. “Framing the problem that way-as an issue for all mankind-should make it plain that it is the value of cultural property to people and not to peoples that matters” thus making it so that “if UNESCO has spent as much effort to make it possible for great art to get into Mali as it has done to stop great art from getting out, it would have been serving better the interests of Malians” by providing a cosmopolitan aesthetic experience (121,124). The difficulty “to find any group or society that has not entered into some sort of cultural exchange with another” becomes more of an impossibility. Further, Appiah argues that our differences should not cause fear but rather further appreciation, “connection not through identity but despite difference” (135). Despite our differences, the deep connections we feel are not through defined as ours, but the truth that can come by observing foreign art to reflect some aspect of ourselves. Thus, our identity is no longer about nation, people, or cultural products; it is about being human. If humanity is our identity, there is no need to fear any differences since at the core we share the same identity, that of our species which does stretch all cultural boundaries and origins further than any nation, invasion, or ancestral heritage.

In Suk Cha:
Can there be an ethics for peace that cuts across cultures? I stand with those who contend that we are already moving toward such an ethics and it is not an invisible hand that moves us, it is individual and collective agency. We have obligations though, as we never need have if we choose to believe that we are not responsible for decisions we make and the actions we take. Our obligations include examining the nature of societies in terms of their differences and similarities and in terms of how they change upon interaction. (6)

“Cosmopolitans think that there are many values worth living by and that you cannot live by all of them. So we hope and expect that difference people and different societies will embody different values. (But they have to be values worth living by.)” (145).

The most important part of this statement is the clarification placed in the parenthesis. If we are to have ethics across cultures, we must work to determine that there are right and wrong values. However, all the right values, and luckily in the same strain, all the wrong values, cannot be included in every person since as stated in the above quote. Having many people each of whom can have unique values adds incredibly to the beauty, diversity, and complexity of the human experience. Further adding to the problem is that humans a fallible, “our knowledge is imperfect, provisional, subject to revision in the face of new evidence” (144). If people learn to live as a fallible and pluralistic species, how can we take contentment and change it into a platform to understand our obligations to other societies, though other societies often have blurry borders. Further, each individual is responsible, not passive, in the process of overall judgments and actions of people as well we their individual actions, as Appiah, Friere, and Cha have emphasized. Not only can peace are harmony be solely found through incorporating the world outside of oneself, a truly ethical lifestyle and cosmopolitan can see differences but not disconnection in people.

In Suk Cha:

That human nature is conflicted and oppositional, there can be no doubt. That is surely one thing that every society has discovered, just as every society discovers that whatever is decent, beautiful and just exists only because of societal living. Civil union can bring out the best and likely the worst in human beings, but without civil union, there is no humanity. (10)

As a species, which is how both Cha and Appiah advocate seeing as the broadest stroke of connection, we are socially dependent. However, as a living organism with a competition for resources, reproductive success, and quality of life, each person is forced to be selfish and inward turning. While social pressures and ideas can contribute this process, I believe this is the main reason behind the conflict. We need each other to prosper for ourselves to prosper, however each individual will always desire to prosper just a little bit more, or a lot more, than their neighbors. So, what is the balance point where selfishness counter-balances the social obligation? Appiah had a good take on the idea of saving a child in a shallow pool, sitting on an airplane writing this has brought another example to mind: put your oxygen mask on first. An individual is less able to help those in need if their needs are met and, further, if their needs aren’t met to the point that they are performing at near optimum level. By performing at optimum level, each individual is more inclined to make informed decisions about proper resource management rather than reacting from the “obligation” gut. “Cosmopolitanism is about intelligence and curiosity as well as engagement” meaning that instead of simply saying disparities in the human race stem from poor resource management alone, which could be solved by sending all your belongings above the average global level to those with belongings below the average global level, that there are deeper root causes over holding “they are rich because we are poor” (168,172). As a cosmopolitan, that inherent selfishness need not to be in conflict with humanity, bring out the worst in letting the selfish instincts take destructively misuse society. Rather, being cosmopolitan-selfish aides to the community by being employed in an ethical work environment, using community resources such as parks and festivals, and sharing art in traveling exchanges if not actual trades. Being conflicted selfish can be seen in many examples in our society, the banking crisis, cash crop exploitation of farm land where food subsistence is not met, and the decrease of public education funding by tax payers who benefitted from the system originally.

By using examples stretching further and further back into human history, Appiah shows the impracticality and misguided ideas of cultural purism. Because we have no one culture, no one living situation, and “not all values have a single measure,” the uniformity advocated by counter-cosmopolitans can be a force which oppresses ideas under absolutes (166). There is no “disbelief” in cosmopolitanism, only values and ideas which can be revised in context of judgments which incorporate pluralism to the greatest extent without starting to condone unethical behavior, that which violates universal human ideals. Appiah finishes his conclusion by trying to define what we must take up to become cosmopolitans, “If we accept the cosmopolitan challenge, we will tell our representatives that we want them to remember those strangers” because “reason, principle, conscience, the inhabitant of the breast” (174, 174). We must find moderation in all things, our acceptance and judgments of other cultures, our obligations, and our ideal of the individual. We are not just “humans,” though that should be a corner stone of ourselves and our interactions, because we have differences, designations, priorities, opportunities, and lives. By doing research on HIV/AIDS, I found many of the problems lay not in a lack of funding or education but rather in the breakdown of the social network, the idea that the differences place people into a context were they “don’t matter very much” and thus places them at risk of disease, poverty, and isolation (153). Not all people can matter to us equally, but all people can matter to us to the point we feel obligation to bare responsibility for their well being in our society. Emphasizing these differences simply attempts to reduce our obligations and dehumanize those we do not know how to or are unwilling to aide. The very fact that we must work to dehumanize through stigma these people illustrates the strong universal connection within humanity.

Friday, November 26, 2010

Cosmopolitanism and "Toward Transcultual Ethics"

In "Toward Transcultural Ethics in a Multicultural World," In Suk Cha writes,

"One of the reasons why modern humanity cannot claim vestiges of primordial
fear of difference as viable cause for violence and conflict is that we humans share
too much in common with each other in our societies. It is difficult to find any group
or society that has not entered into some sort of cultural exchange with another." (5)
and:
Can there be an ethics for peace that cuts across cultures? I stand with those who contend that we are already moving toward such an ethics and it is not an invisible hand that moves us, it is individual and collective agency. We have obligations though, as we never need have if we choose to believe that we are not responsible for decisions we make and the actions we take. Our obligations include examining the nature of societies in terms of their differences and similarities and in terms of how theychange upon interaction. (6)

That human nature is conflicted and oppositional, there can be no doubt. That is
surely one thing that every society has discovered, just as every society discovers
that whatever is decent, beautiful and just exists only because of societal living. Civil
union can bring out the best and likely the worst in human beings, but without civil
union, there is no humanity. (10)
How does Appiah, support and illustrate these points in these last chapters? Why does Appiah support what he calls cultural "contamination" and what does he mean by the conceptual challenge inherent in his discussion of "counter-cosmopolitans," of "how to distinguish benign and malign forms of universalism?" (143). Can you relate these points to or illuminate them through your service-learning experience?

Tuesday, November 23, 2010

Scientists Are Amoral….

When we look at examples of “the kind of disagreement where the struggle is not to agree but just to understand,” it becomes a matter of how we can express a thought to others (47). The warping of ideas is not often because we have different values but rather because we have different perceptions and perspectives. Because of these different points at with which we approach a problem, often the reasoning and motivation for action scatters in many different unique directions. Education, learning, and curiosity are all important aspects of humanity. Yet, explaining why one does or does not attend college can range from greed, to security, to passion, to laziness, to fear, etc.

While the book is written for a general audience, the general audience in our society is heavily impacted and controlled by science and logic. In a world based off of science and logic, saying “it is often much clearer to us what we should do than why” is any oxymoron (63). To act requires a motivation, a stimuli which can be registered as a call to movement, change, and response, a why. Reductionism spread across almost all generations of scientific theory is based on this principle. If an apple falls from the tree, there must be a reason even if not apparent immediately. If there is a social change as well, there must a reason if not apparent immediately. While these occurrences may not be obvious to the item being acted upon, apple or person, the first because its lack of a central nervous system, the second because of his or her lack of outside and historical perspective, there are always forces behind them. “Efforts to justify what we have done-or what we plan to do-are typically made up after the event, rationalizations of what we have decided intuitively” implies that intuitively our brain is not rational (72). Yet, we are adapted to make decisions based of complex patterns about which we are constantly gaining more information; this item will help, this action will hurt, these are the risks involved, these are the possible results. Many times our intuition is better since it takes into account more facets of an occurrence than we would categorize as important for that decision logically. “Reasoning…comes not when we are going on in the usual way, but when we are thinking about change” (73). The reasoning discussed is about changing the intuitive response or reprogramming ourselves.

I disagree with Appiah in that I believe to understand each other the why has more impact, more potential understanding than any what could ever have. The what could be a short term foundation for discussions while the why rests an ultimate vehicle for by which we can establish judgment across cultures. These lead back to the question of whether motivation has an impact on ethics, which I have no final decision about at this point. Does motivation have an impact on understanding? Yes. Does motivation have an impact on living in harmony? No, a perfect example is that “our political coexistence depends on being able to agree about practices while disagreeing about their justification” (70). I do not believe we can take motivation out of all discussion in the pursuit of common ground.

We interact. As interacting changes our actions, our beliefs, understand one another better, or question the “usual,” it is not due to some greater force, “even the cleverest people are not easily shifted by reason alone,” yet the other things an argument might appeal to, mainly emotions, are all logical responses programmed to balance the individual and the society allowing for the best possible partnership. Greed and empathy come from our brains, not society, and are logical responses ingrained. “If the machinery of the mind is the same everywhere,” then do we really have a conscious choice? (94) Yet, I cannot believe we are solely at the fate of our programming. This is where our imagination and creativity comes in. We must inspire, expand, and promote imagination within our daily lives for fear of losing ourselves not to reason, since reason is an important part of every process, but to stagnant reason in which input does not lead to our adaptation, our becoming cosmopolitans. Building in the scientific community is often portrayed as lacking in imagination and creativity, as being an area grounded and petrified by logic. Yet, this is a hasty and one sided assessment. It misses several important aspects of being a human being. As a human being and a scientist, we do not only observe and rationalize our world.

Appiah approaches science as a stagnant philosophy. Yet, science too is reflecting what people are discovering organically through their daily lives, everything is connected. Emergent properties come from the interaction of parts, making a cumulative sum greater than the individual. To advance further in our technology and medicine, we are coming to more understand the differences in people, molecules, cells, and how that contributes to the greater whole. This trend is not due to an impulse to make everything whole but rather a logical revelation that everything was whole to begin with, only man has taken it apart.
The reading this week has led me down a rabbit hole of the role of logic, and thus science in its basic tenant, in the world. Sorry about the jumbled thoughts; I feel passionate about this discussion. If I continued, I believe I might end up with a bungled manifesto.