Tuesday, March 29, 2011

From Tom: Kindness is a leap

The world seems rarely kind, most would agree I think. Why is this the case? Barbara Taylor and Adam Philips in On Kindness says it is our culture that informs our attitudes towards being kind. "Kindness is the saboteur of the successful life"(5) is a common misconception. When we decide to be kind to another person, we are opening ourselves up to them, letting our defenses down in the process. I think after enough time when you are rebuffed for being kind, or met with the antithesis of kindness when you offer it, it tends to make one cold and hard. Then guess what? When others open up to you, you meet them with that same coldness.

Many intelligent people, like D. H. Lawrence mentioned on page 8, thought kindness was more like a selfish act and therefore not to be trusted. "All compassion is self-pity," he is said to remarked. The authors believed this kind of attitude picked up traction about the time of Thomas Hobbes in his work Leviathan, and his personal philosophy of all men basically being selfish. Those that professed to be kind were really weak, and relied on the Christian ethic of kindness and its reciprocity.

According to the authors, this Hobbesian mode of thinking took hold gradually, despite the efforts of men like David Hume attempting to counter it. Hume insisted that any man who denied his natural inclination towards being kind "has forgotten the movements of his heart."(5) This may be more true than what is generally known regarding the heart as a thinking organ. In Tom Shadyac's I Am, a few scenes from that documentary take place at the Heartmath Institute which shows that living things may be connected in ways we never thought were possible. Something as primitive as a dollop of yogurt can sense your emotional state, so it seems.

According to their research(check it out at www.heartmath.org), the heart acts as a hormonal gland and facilitates emotions in the brain. That's why you feel love in the heart, though conventional science says you are experiencing a mere chemical response in the brain. The Heartmath Institute calls this "neurocardiology," the study of the heart-mind. It's pretty fascinating stuff.

The important point of the documentary and the book is that kindness is more than just a psychological need, it's a biological need too. Most people who unwittingly take the Hobbesian point of view towards kindness often cite Charles Darwin as one of their inspirations. Since Darwin postulated that competition is the essence of natural selection, anything that doesn't offer immediate gain is of little value. Genuine kindness is often done with no regard to the self, so it must be a sign of weakness and the province of those "less fit."

But those that think that haven't explored what Darwin was teaching very deeply. "Sympathy and cooperation were innate to man, Darwin argued in The Descent of Man(1871), and a key factor behind humanity's evolutionary success."(97) Kindness and community have always been a necessity because we simply can't provide for ourselves alone. Another reason why it's difficult to be kind is the inherent vulnerability in offering your kindness to another.

Unwanted kindness is awkward, something like the ultimate in rejection. And no one likes to feel rejected! That's the risk you have to take, I suppose. What's stronger than the fear of rejection, though, is what you get out of it. "Real kindness doesn't require selflessness, it is rather that real kindness changes people in the doing of it, often in unpredictable ways."(13) Overcome your sense of vulnerability and practice kindness, then watch it ripple through people like a wave. Kind of like reversing the spin of a karmic wheel when its not turning your way. That's powerful stuff.

1 comment:

  1. From Teal:
    “This is a historical story-about how and why people have been talked out of their kindness-but also a psychological one, that is, a story about how vulnerability becomes traumatic to people (11).” Being in a position of vulnerability is something that is terrifying people, which can be a major reason for why people do not recuperate any source of kindness. An example of this is when my brother went to open the door for a lady and she stood there and stared at him, as if she was scared of him. Since that incident my brother does not open doors very often. Kindness is a confusing act; it can be received in a negative or positive connotation.

    Kindness is something that is obtainable by anyone, yet not many people understand what kindness is. “So it is not that real kindness requires people to be selfless, it is rather that kindness changes people in the doing of it, often in unpredictable ways. Real kindness is an exchange with essentially unpredictable consequences (13).” An act of kindness can be anything that is selfless, yet the idea of selflessness is not realistic. I believe that many people do acts of kindness because they believe that they will receive some sort of act back. Kindness does have unpredictable consequence, such as people’s reaction to kindness. When a person does an act of kindness, and have a negative affect they do not repeat kindness.

    ReplyDelete

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.