Saturday, March 5, 2011

From Tom: My prefrontal cortex made me do it

The thesis of How We Decide is fascinating: moral judgements are made more through the emotional centers of the brain rather than just the rational. In fact, the merely rational mind can fail in catastrophic ways when formulating a moral value. On page 172, Lehrer writes, "...confronted with an ethical dilemma, the unconscious automatically generates an emotional response." The emotional response forces one into a kind of reaction, like say responding to a sudden slap across the face. In less than a second you know right from wrong.

To paraphrase Lehrer from page 175, moral decisions aren't made to maximize one's own enjoyment, they are made based on the consideration of other people. When we learn about a wrong, something we just know is unethical or immoral, we have an almost instinctive need to right it. I can see this kind of attitude in my community partner — the living conditions and dropout rates of minority high school students in poverty cause a visceral reaction. When you know you can help the situation, however modestly, it becomes a kind of moral imperative in your life.

The case for the brain making decisions as an argument seems pretty reasonable to me. Maybe most of us suspect that we are fooling ourselves when we think we come to a decision in a purely objective manner. Chances are if the decision felt good, then we probably sneaked in some prejudices somewhere along to the conclusion. That good feeling can be perceived as confidence that you're right.

I'm not convinced that we are at the mercy of this internal argument, however. If you are conscious of your reasoning and the "internal argument," you should be able to reconsider a position taken. Of course, that's easier said then done when a highly emotional charge is involved. But that emotional charge can be useful too.

A study was mentioned showing the charitable giving decisions made by people when faced with the story of a starving Malawi child. The personal account of another suffering with hunger and extreme poverty moved the test subjects to donate to help the child. When faced with the statistical facts of starvation and poverty for all Malawi children, the test subjects did not contribute anything close to the amount in the first case. Having that emotional connection, that ability to empathize, makes more sense to people.

I think personal narratives should play an important part in communicating needed social change. A person you can help, and facts on paper are just that to the emotional mind.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.