When I finished reading this article it reminded me of the saying, “Actions speak louder than words.” It is not enough to have ideas and “know” what is good, it must be acted out everyday, we must consciously be aware of it. Needleman brings new light to the understanding the relationship between our mind and our body. We must first accept our state of being. “The Christian doctrine of ‘original sin’ was no doubt intended as an expression of this idea. As such, it was perhaps intended to help men and women confront the degraded state of their being and by so doing support in them-in us- the healing action of remorse”(Needleman, n.p.). Remorse, unlike guilt, we’ll bring us to understand ourselves and accept what and who we are, “ a relaxation that opens the heart and body to receive a new quality of attention-an attention or conscious energy…” (Needleman, n.p.).
Our body is the primary instrument or, as Needleman puts it, the “necessary element” which will lead us to do “good.” Our bodies are alive and we know when it physically feels good or when it is in pain. “In such states one may observe that the body is temporarily transformed and permeated with a fine energy, a subtle quality of sensation unlike anything we experience in the ordinary course of our lives…” (n.p). This “sensation” occurs whenever we experience love, anger sadness. Our body feels it too.
As we have seen from our service learning, it is our actions that have made the biggest impact on our communities. We all chose to use our bodies as an instrument to make good differences. Our ideas and good intentions are being put to action. This is the “sensation” that Needleman refers to in his article. Even if we haven’t realized it yet, as we continue working with our community partners, we ourselves are building a “new kind of body, a body that has a new aim, a new purpose: voluntarily to serve the Good” (n.p.). This may also lead to new discoveries within ourselves “that we perhaps glimpsed in our lives…”
Personally, I have been learning a lot about myself through my experience at the pet shelter. It wasn’t till I started volunteering at this place that I realized how much comfort these creatures can bring to a person, especially to me. It feels really good that I have been able to take care of them and give them to a loving family. I now know that to do good does not only mean to other humans but to our environment, nature, animals, and anything else that is alive. I am sure that we have all discovered something new about ourselves that we didn’t know before working with our community partners. I encourage everyone to share anything new that you have discovered about yourself.
I agree with Julia's post, that actions do indeed speak louder than words. It is not enough to say something good, helpful, or beneficial to someone or something, but not back it up with some form of action. What good does that do anybody? Our service learning teaches us the value of doing. The value of acting. The ability to see the needs of our clients, and actually have the opportunity to 'help' by 'action' is significant. I think this speaks to the article by Needleman.
ReplyDeleteI found Needleman's article very interesting. In particular was the realization that so much of our history, human history, has been fraught with examples of behavior far from good. Egypt, Rome, China - wars and torture, enslavement and genocide... this has been going on for as long as recorded time. "How could we not wonder and hope that there does exist a missing element, a genuine and noble secret that we have forgotten..." (Needleman, 9) which will lead us to the "real reality" of goodness. I think it is also of interest to think about the idea of self - individuality and the ego, and what that means for goodness. We are surrounded by examples of the opposite of goodness. Commerce and business, money and finance, sports, entertainment (movies and video games) constantly show competition and the drive for the 'holy' dollar. We buy into this every time we open a magazine, or see a commercial on TV that persuades us to act in a certain way... to buy a certain pair of jeans, make up or beverage... we need to cut the subliminal strings which bind us to consumerism. All this feeds the ego and pushes us further from our true selves. As Needleman noted, Socrates secret goal of uncompromising dialogue on the way to self-knowledge, and the work of self-knowldege and its role on the way to virtue can lead us only to the "threshold of moral power" (Needleman, 7).
For me the question becomes, do humans have the ability and strength of character to do good all the time? Is this something even attainable to the every-day man or woman? Saints and humanitarians have come close but I wonder what it would take for the rest of us? I know it seems like we are products of our environment - remember Canada and his work in the Harlem neighborhood? We have the capacity for so much love, so much good, and so much beauty, but we also have that other side to our personalities too... When will the balance of the dark swing back in favor of the light, and how do we maximize the time in that state of goodness?
Julia and Jason--because I posted this as extra credit on moodle, I am not given a grade box that I can respond to you--so am doing it here.
ReplyDeleteJulia--what a beautiful and insightful piece of writing. I very much appreciate that you picked up and ran with Needleman's point about the body. How beautiful to think about these points in relationship to your nursing career. It is so important to be embodied when dealing with the bodily ailments of others and to recognize the huge connection between physical and mental well-being.
Jason, another beautiful piece of writing and questioning of/engagement with central textual concepts. I appreciate your closing statements very much because, yes, goodness is and cannot be an all or nothing reality--it is a process, a striving to be engaged and embodied and learning through every experience to strike the balance that you speak of. Yet, the challenge is that the balance is ever-shifting. You don't arrive at balance and have the luxury of staying there. Life isn't static. That's the beauty and the struggle that is also beautiful, right? Even what is good or not in every situation will shift to some extent. Thanks to both of you for inspiring me in me and bringing light into my afternoon.
From Teal Why Can't We Be Good?
ReplyDelete“The force of human evil-call it by what name you will-reaches as deeply into the individual human heart as it reaches into casual chain of human history (pdf2.)” I believe this is very true and relevant to the human race, history does have a chain of “evil” that is continuous today. I believe that each person has the ability to do what they believe is evil but its personal morals that keep one from falling into temptation. “And we cannot imagine, cannot comprehend the greatness and goodness of what we are in our hidden essence and what we are meant to be: conscious instruments of the Absolute (pdf2).” Evil is more dominate in society and is continuous, which makes the fact of doing good and achieving greatness a far reach for many.
I believe that many of the students at MCCS relate to the affects of “evil” that Needleman is discussing. Students that I have had the chance to get to know, discuss the feelings of being held back and unable to pursue what they want. One girl that I have worked with almost every week talked to me about how she wants to get out of MCCS and go to normal high school then to beauty school. She kept telling me that she cant do it because she keeps getting into trouble, “evil”, and finds it difficult to get out of repeating the same cycle. She believes that she wont be able to go to beauty school after she graduates due to the lack of support from her family, which would repeat the cycle of her parents. I believe that if she really wanted to achieve those goals, she should be able to break the history of “evil” but due to her surroundings it makes it difficult for he