In "Thinking and Moral Considerations", Arendt interprets the Socratic propositions, "it is better for me to suffer wrong than do wrong" and "it would be worse for me to be at odds with myself than in disagreement with multitudes of men" (182). I often find myself in situations where I know, when someone is speaking directly to me about something I am completely in disagreement with, if I don't "gently" relate my opposing view, it is as if I am in agreement with them. After yet another uplifting lesson with my student, I attended a social gathering with friends. A woman in the group shared with me, her frustration that when looking for a job, many positions require being bilingual. She was angry that she would have to "learn their language" when "if they want to live here, why don't they learn English". I could not agree with her and said so, especially since I hope to learn Spanish, for the universal ability to communicate, and not just with "those" people who came here "uninvited". I spoke about my student and how impressed I am with her efforts and determination to speak and read English. She could continue to get by without English skills, she and her husband have jobs, their children attend local junior high, high school and college. Her life is good in comparison to many, but she wants so desperately to communicate with the people she meets at her job and her children's teachers, that she is willing to spend valuable personal hours to improve herself. I reminded my friend, that if no one ever wanted non-English speaking people to live here, my grandparents as well as hers, would not have been allowed to enter the United States many years ago.
Thursday, March 17, 2011
I'm Not Necessarily in Agreement
If I have understood Arendt's conditions required for collective responsibility, I "must be held responsible for something I have not done" (149), namely the sexual abuse committed by Catholic priests, and the inaction of the Catholic Church to stop the crimes or punish the criminals. As a practicing Catholic, every time I attend Mass, receive Communion and proclaim belief in my faith, I as well as every other member of the Catholic Church, would be, according to Arendt, collectively responsible. My "membership in the group, (collective) which no voluntary act of mine can dissolve" (149), would make me responsible for unspeakable acts committed by others. I can freely choose not to participate, which Arendt says is "actually a form of resistance" (155), but by "leaving the community, and since no man can live without belonging to some community, this would simply mean to exchange one community for another and hence one kind of responsibility for another" (150). The community I would then be part of, is the DUC community, and still "collectively responsible" for these crimes, as is every employee, student, and faculty member of DUC, by financially supporting, accepting payment, and voluntarily participating in its programs that are "guided by its Catholic heritage" (DUC Homepage). Because we can dissolve our contracts with DUC, why are we no longer responsible, according to Arendt, for the actions of others? The choice is still being made to participate. Although she allows that there is no such thing as "feeling guilty for things that happened without oneself actively participating in them" (147), we cannot escape some guilt perceived or otherwise, for "the consequences for things we are entirely innocent of, (which) is the price we pay for the fact that we live our lives not by ourselves but among our fellow men" (157-158).
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment
Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.