Thursday, March 3, 2011

Sight and Blindness

I really enjoyed the statement by the chairman of GM Alfred P. Sloan, “Gentlemen. I take it we are all in complete agreement on the decision here... Then I propose we postpone further discussion of this matter until our next meeting to give ourselves time to develop disagreement and perhaps gain some understanding of what the decision is all about” (218). Good leaders, as noted with Abe Lincoln “always encouraged vigorous debate and discussion” (218), before making an important decision. Moral decisions “require taking other people into account” (175). This seems so basic and fundamental to us – what lesson do we learn in preschool when we monopolize all the building blocks? Our teachers tell us to look at Billy and see how sad he is that he has no building blocks to play with. We see the tears in Billy's eyes and we connect the moral decision – Billy is sad. Billy is sad because I have all the building blocks. Give some blocks to Billy so he will not be sad. Lehrer states “Selfishness needs to be balanced by some selflessness” (175), and I agree completely. I think our modern day world of technology and consumerism might be tipping that statement back in the other direction. The more time kids/adults spend alone in their room/office looking at their computers – fully convinced that they are “plugged-in” to the world illustrates the differences in Lehrer's personal and impersonal moral decisions. Because as he mentioned with the example of the military using new battle field tactics like when “bombs are dropped from forty thousand feet, the decision to fire is like turning the trolley wheel: people are detached from the resulting deaths” (180). This desensitization is based on the illumination of visual context. This was also demonstrated with the experiment by the eighteenth century philosopher Adam Smith, where he studied the behavior of the “ultimatum game” (182) and the change in generosity when two people are split up. When face to face, people use the 'reflective mirror' to use their own imagination to predict how the other person would feel if they were not given a fair portion of the money. Take the human closeness/contact out of the equation and our personalities and responses change. “When people play the game with computers, they are never generous” (182). I think human interaction needs to be brought back, revitalized, revamped. Written letters not e-mails are more personal and meaningful, and so too in the business world when a handshake and your word of honor used to be thought of as having more weight than a phone call.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.