Saturday, March 26, 2011

Prompt for extra credit reading: Why Can't We Be Good?

One of the reasons that I originally picked this piece is that Needleman, unlike many philosophers, acknowledges the role of the body, the fact that we are embodied and it is the body that moves in the world and manifests thought through action. Reading this on the heels of Arendt's Responsibility and Judgment, it is interesting to note that he too sees guilt as a way of hiding from responsibility. He writes that it is "such emotions as guilt and fear, with their reflexes of self-pity and anger" that can lead to emotional reactions that do not include the necessary reflection that will lead to ethical action. (pdf pgs. 2.2-3.1).
This is part of his larger question regarding crossing the Socratic threshold between thought and action. The whole question, Why can't we be good?, rests on this, not the fact that we may
know what is good but what " we do, with painful frequency" is the very opposite (pdf. 7.2). "Ideas . . . are necessary. But they are not enough" (pdf 9.1).
Needleman writes,
we need to make use of the ways and means to be outwardly 'in the street' in our actual lives, while somehow, or to some extent remaining inwardly in the theater of the mind . . . to be in two places at once. . .We need something that is fundamentally unknown to ourselves: to question our lives without inwardly or outwardly holding back from whatever life offers and asks of us. (pdf 10.1)
Think about these ideas in relation to our class, the ways in which we are trying to cultivate the habits of mind that lead to the capacity to question ourselves and at the same time we are "in the street," in our bodies, living these ideas in our service. Use specifics from the text and your service to illustrate how this dual experience and what you are learning.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.