Wednesday, October 19, 2011

Humans are not Evil, Our Actions Are

I have previously heard of the terms "collective responsibility" and "collective guilt," however I have never thought thought about the terms deeply.  Arendt states in "Responsibility and Judgement" that there is no such thing as collective guilt.  This is because "guilt, unlike responsibility, always singles out; it is strictly personal" (147).  A group cannot collectively feel guilty because the group dynamic and the individual dynamic are distinctly different.  It is strictly metaphorical because "we can say we feel guilty for the sins of our fathers or our people or mankind, in short, for deeds we have not done..." but we are not responsible for them (147).  This conjecture makes perfect sense when it is analyzed.  A German person may feel guilty for the actions of his or her ancestors during World War II, but because that person was not directly involved in the actions, the guilt is not placed upon them.  However, if one has knowledge of an immoral act performed by another and does nothing to stop it, then one is just as guilty as the person who performed the act.  One may feel compassion for another who is suffering, however if one did not directly or indirectly cause that suffering then it is impossible for that person to feel true guilt.  
In the following chapter, Arendt discusses the concept of the "banality of evil" and "the absence of thinking."  According to her, the "banality of evil" is  "...the phenomenon of evil deeds, committed on a gigantic scale, which could not be traced to any particularity of wickedness, pathology, or ideological conviction in the doer..." and "However monstrous the deeds were, the doer was neither monstrous nor demonic"(159).  This conjecture leads to the idea that people are not innately evil.  Although human beings are capable of performing horrible deeds, the motive to perform said deeds does not stem from evil within us.  Arendt continues her discussion and explains that the root cause of evil actions is the absence of thought.  Blatant evidence which supports this view can be drawn from the actions of Nazi soldiers who ran the death camps during the Holocaust.  When the war was ended and they were asked to explain their actions, the excuse which was repeatedly offered was that they were simply following orders.  Nazi soldiers murdered, starved, and mutilated millions of innocent people because they were following orders, and not thinking about their actions.  Although this seems like a ridiculous excuse, if analyzed it makes sense .  The Nazi soldiers did not think about their monstrous deeds; but if they did then they would never have been able to commit the crimes that they did.  They were not evil people to the core, they simply performed evil deeds.  Arendt states, "the most conspicuous and most dangerous fallacy in the proposition, as old as Plato, 'Nobody does evil voluntarily,' is the implied conclusion, 'Everybody wants to do good.'  The sad truth of the matter is that most evil is done by people who never made up their mind to be either bad or good" (180).  This fact is often overlooked, and can be related to my experience at MCCS.  I believe that many of the students who go there believe that there is something inherently wrong with themselves which causes them to go down the wrong path.  If they understood that they, as individuals, are not "bad" or "stupid" and that it is simply their absence of thinking which leads to their bad decisions, they would be more motivated to be successful in life.

Prompt-Text/Service Reflection: Precarious Life

Use the following points to help you "pull the thread" of Butler's ideas--please make sure that you find a connection to service and that you include other quotes from the reading.

Make sure to notice where Butler identifies issues and presents alternative formulations, often in the form of questions, sometimes as very clear statements.


The rise of anti-intellectualism—what does Butler mean by this/how does she illustrate this phenomenon/ what are the implications?

Terminology and framing of events: why is it crucial to think/critique the ways in information (through language/narratives/images etc) that we receive about violence: “the frame works both to preclude certain kinds of questions [and] historical inquiries, and to function as a moral justification for retaliation” (4). Find examples of the dangers and the alternatives that Butler suggests.


Find other places in the text to unpack what Butler mean when she asks, “Can we find another meaning, and another possibility, for the decentering of the first-person narrative within the global framework?” (7).



Butler asks, “What social conditions help to form the very ways that choice and deliberation proceed? . . .” (16) Explore her discussion around these questions.


“Who counts as human?” (20). Why are the experiences of loss, vulnerability, grief, mourning integral to Butler’s thesis? Do we agree that these are universal human experiences that might be a source of moral response?


“Let’s face it, we’re undone by each other. And if we’re not, we’re missing something (23). Do you have a significant moment from service that illustrates this?

Significance of the discussion of identity/autonomy/the body (24-38). Tie back to other points. This leads into important discussion of vulnerability—how does she then tie this back into the previous points she has built?


Dehumanization of the Other 32-49. Crucial points here and she weaves in all the other points.


“We do not need to ground ourselves in a single model of communication, a single model of reason, a single notion of the subject before we are able to act” (48). Think about this in relation to the thesis Butler has built and, if possible, in relation to your service-learning experience.

Do you see echoes of Arendt in any of Butler’s points? Where? There are also many points about vulnerability that remind me of the reading from On Kindness. Also, think back to Deo and the violence and loss he experienced, does his story illustrate some of Butler's ideas as well? What about the Cornell piece on the "Moral Obligations of Living in a Democratic Society" and the necessary struggles and asking of hard questions. . .? (Finding common themes, that are also illuminated through your service experience, will help you formulate your final paper.)

Arendt begins by talking about guilty and how, “unlike responsibility, [it] always singles out.. [and] is strictly personal” (147). She then goes on to talk about responsibility, collective responsibility more specifically. She says that there are 2 conditions, which are that “I must be held responsible for something I have not done and the reason for my responsibility must be membership in a group which no voluntary act of mine can dissolve” (149). This reminded me of a bank robbery. When a person holds up a bank, they usually have apprentices and the apprentices don't usually do anything to stop the robbery even though they know its wrong. They just go along with it, maybe because they fear they will be hurt by the robber or they want to “fit in”.

A line that resonated with me was when Arendt said, “the question is never whether an individual is good but whether his conduct is good for the world he lives in. In the center of interest is the world and not the self” (151). I feel like this line is very important and very true. The line basically states that a person’s actions not only affect them but the world around them. It’s the idea of “putting the world in front of ones self” basically.

Another line that resonated with me was that thinking is a continuous process and cycle. It never ends. It gives space to rethink, expand our thoughts and ultimately grow. I agreed with Arendt when she quotes Kant in “I do not share the opinion....that one should doubt once one has convinced oneself of something...Our mind has a natural aversion against it” (166). I feel like Arendt is conveying that when we fix our minds on something, we may not be entirely fixed upon it. There’s room for doubt that lies in the back of our minds but it is only accessed when something doesn't add up. We all say that this statement is true, once you are convinced, there should be no going back but we often find ourselves doing so.

I really like how Arendt took the word “house” and said that “the word...could not exist unless one presupposes thinking about being housed, dwelling, having a home” (172). This was very interesting for me to read because I know that as humans think, they come up with things but I never saw it written in such a way that could make an impact. Lastly, when Arendt states that “A man cannot try to discover either what he knows or what he doesn't know...he doesn't even know what he is to look for”, it reminded me of my philosophy teacher who said “How can you search for something when you don't even know what it is or where it can possibly be found?” (170). It seems straight forward, either you wait or you just search blindly, but nonetheless, it is one of my favorite quotes.

The Power of Thinking

How does Arendt define collective responsibility and the conditions that must be present to define it as such?

According to Arendt, there are two conditions that define collective responsibility. Those are, “I must be held responsible for something I have not done, and the reason for my responsibility must be my membership in a group (a collective) which no voluntary act of mine can dissolve (149).” If these two conditions have not been met then a collective responsibility is not at play. Responsibility is a personal term along with guilt, “guilt is strictly personal (147).” In order to feel true guilt or responsibility, there has to be an action taken or active thought present. By saying there is a collective responsibility then the responsibility is taken off the guilty party and put onto a group as a whole. Responsibility needs to be taken by the offending party which cannot be done when there is a blanket term such as “collective responsibility.” An example can be used during the Holocaust. The true guilty party is the Nazis but all Germans were stigmatized for allowing Hitler into power. Not all Germans were involved; some of them were even actively supporting the Jews. Therefore collective guilt is not an accurate term.


What are Arendt’s points about the “absence of thinking” and its implications in relationship to her concept “of the banality of evil”? (178,189,etc)

The concept of evil, according to Arendt, is that, “the sad truth of the matter is that most evil is done by people who never made up their mind to be either good or evil (180).” By not thinking, a person is committing evil. Take the case given by George Orwell in 1984. Because the citizens did not make up their mind the government was able to take control of the citizens’ lives. Thinking is necessary to make sure that your rights are not taking away. Always question everything or evil will take place

Tuesday, October 18, 2011

In Hannah Arendt’s book, entitled Responsibility and Judgment, She first begins by distinguishing between collective responsibility and guilt by making the powerful statement “Guilt, unlike responsibility, always singles out; it is strictly personal.” I completely agree with her. I believe that everyone has different emotional blueprints. Therefore, in a certain situation, everyone expresses varying amount of guilt (even if you are not directly involved in the situation). However taking responsibility for ones actions is completely independent of guilt and depends heavily upon one’s involvement in the situation. For example, Hannah Arendt uses the example of a team of professional swimmers letting a person drown. She then goes deeper by drawing a distinction between our responsibilities and morals “What I am driving at here is a sharper dividing line between collective responsibility, on one side, and moral and/or legal (personal) guilt . . . “ I do agree with the authors position that a lot of our morals come from our religious origins and backgrounds. I also believe that one’s religious views should not act as the main source for one’s values and morals.
The author then goes on to make the point that our “Nonparticipation in the political affairs of the world has always been open to the reproach of irresponsibility of shirking one’s duties to the world we share with one another and the community we belong to.” When applied to community service, this quote is dead on. It seems as if a bad habit has developed. Everyone plays an important role in the community they live in. I feel as if people are neglecting the roles in they play in their community and not getting involved in the political issues they face with. This not only affects that individual, but also the individuals around them. According to the author, the health of a community would be a collective responsibility. The author states it beautifully saying “we live our lives not by ourselves but among our fellow men,” and attitude that I hope many of us adopt as we go though out our community service experience this year.

Abstract Philosophy: Responsibility and Thinking

For this week’s reading we were asked once again to try to understand the ideas presented by a philosopher. More specifically, we took a look at two chapters from Hannah Arendt’s Responsibility and Judgement: “Collective Responsibility” and “Thinking and Moral Considerations.” The first chapter seemed to focus on a comparison of guilt and responsibility while the second chapter took an abstract look at thinking.

Arendt opens the first chapter arguing that responsibility can be accurately applied to a collective while guilt cannot. She writes, “…there is no such thing as being or feeling guilty for things that happened without oneself actively participating in them” and continues “guilt, unlikely responsibility… is strictly personal” (147). Arendt goes on to support that there is a very distinctive line between political or collective responsibility, and legal or personal guilt (150-151). A famous line of Socrates is brought up, “It is better to suffer wrong than to do wrong” (153). Arendt understands Socrates to mean that he would rather suffer wrong immediately than do wrong and have to live with it afterwards. However, she contends that this moral argument is very subjective and therefore difficult to analyze (156-157).

In her second chapter, Arendt brings up the complicated topic of thinking. One aspect she discusses is that objects of thoughts are representations of real things that have been created by the imagination (165). Since there is very little recorded as to the thinking experiences of “professional thinkers,” Arendt again directs the conversation to Socrates. It is explained that Socrates had these philosophical sessions of questioning things that tended to come right back to where they started (168-171). Examination of some of the things Socrates stated then leads to discussion of Socrates’ self-imposed label of a “gadfly” as well as another person’s label of him as an “electric ray.” Arendt’s interpretation of the “gadfly” label is that Socrates stimulated people into thinking and reflecting. The “electric ray” label, meanwhile, is suggested to refer to the idea that people can be paralyzed by too much uncertainty as a result of much reflection (173-174).

The article “Auschwitz Shifts From Memorializing to Teaching” by Michael Kimmelman can easily be related to Arendt’s first major point. In the article, Kimmelman explains the proposal of a revised exhibition at the Auschwitz-Birkenau State Museum. The new exhibition is not designed to revive blame against any group of people on a large scale, but rather to emphasize personal stories and experiences of those who experienced the atrocities of Auschwitz. In fact, the director specifically said that the new exhibition should inspire “responsibility to the present” in viewers (2). In short, the purpose of the exhibit shies away from distributing guilt on a broad level but instead seeks to perpetrate a collective responsibility.

- Christopher Galbick

Rise of communal thoughts

As Keifer and Whitney have said, Ardent describes collective responsibility as an individual's responsibility for an action he/she has not necessarily committed related to that individual's participation in a larger group that "no voluntary act of [one person] can dissolve." Straight to the point, she says, "I must be held responsible for something I have NOT done." (149) I love how she says that, because in order to be a part of a group, to hold responsibility in a group, you have to hold yourself accountable, even to things you'd rather not take responsibility for. I think this is an important ethical issue because in our collective democracy, it seems as though no one wants to take responsibility for anything. Rather, we are quick to point the blame on someone else. The media brainwashes us to think as individuals when in reality, we are connected. And I think that this false sense of individualism desensitizes us to think we can blame someone else for something done to us. This sparks the question, how could we ever be trained to think like this and believe it?

In the second chapter, "Significance of Thinking", Arendt tries to separate the ideas of thinking something and knowing something. Knowing and knowledge could be considered the more static portion of ideas - the basic elements, the cold, hard facts, the proof to a conclusion. But thinking, thinking is the synthesis of these basic elements in relation to the environmental factors in order to create a brand new idea or thought. Because thinking is more subjective, we are able to think and relate to each other from different view points. In a way, we all represent the different sides of a diamond - when we come together, our views create a great picture in the light.

Going back to my question, how could we ever be trained to think we are individuals when in reality, we are connected, we must go back to how thinking and knowing relate to our morals and ethics. Arendt summaries it well in her last paragraph of chapter two, "If thinking... actualizes the difference within our identity as given in consciousness and thereby results in conscience as its byproduct, then judging, the byproduct of the liberating effect of thinking, realizes thinking, makes it manifest in the world of appearances..." (189) I might be reading into this wrong, but what I understand from what she's saying is that from our ability to think comes our consciousness - our ability to think for ourselves and our needs - and from that stems judgement - our ability to assess our outside environment, which then comes together to form our view of the world and how we should act in it. Therefore, our idea of individualism in a connected world comes from our perception of the others and the situations around us, which, in our minds, makes it right.