Wednesday, March 24, 2010

Julia… you were not kidding about Arendt. There is a lot to digest. You quote the line from Arendt ”We can escape this political and strictly collective responsibility only by leaving the community, and since no man can live without belonging to some community, this would simply mean to exchange one community for another and hence one kind of responsibility for another.” I highlighted this quote as well because of how I saw St Vincent de Paul’s and its place within our community. Do we all have “collective and vicarious responsibility in which the member of a community is held responsible for things he did not participate in but which were done in his name.” as Arendt states it on page 154; you bet. But my experience at Vinnie’s exemplifies that this is not how the “surrounding community” feels. It seems like the approach to the homeless and the poor is to try and force them out of the community. The larger community would rather not acknowledge this segment of the community.  Marin county is in dire need of a overnight shelter, which the community, the city and the county do not want to provide because they are pressured from business’ and people living in the county who do not want to end up next to a shelter. Private interests don’t want to live or work next to a place that caters to the people who need this type of assistance. So here we see collective guilt being pushed away, not by leaving the community, but by pushing the issue, in this case the homeless and poor and they shelter they need out of the community. If we don’t see it, it does not exist, right? Out of sight out of mind?

            I live in Marin; I have a good job and a nice home. Sometimes I lose track of the fact that there are many people who suffer from many hardships and struggle day to day, but these folks are still part of my community and I am still responsible for them and their plight, Vinnie’s reminds me of that fact.

"What is important in the world is that there be no wrong; suffering wrong and doing wrong are equally bad" Never mind who suffers it; your duty is to prevent it. page 153. 

Arendt talks about they way "thinking" stops us from doing. "For it is true that he moment we start thinking on no matter what issue we stop everything else, and this everything else, again whatever it may happen to be, interrupts the thinking process." page 165. Later in that page Arendt relates that as soon as we "think" about someone or something it is "removed from our senses. And while our class discussions are great and putting our ideas into words via the blog or short papers helps us organize our thoughts it is  the experience of our actual work with our community partners that I believe has the biggest impact. We feel, we sense, we relate, we have real conversations, we have real emotions when we are actually working in our community environments. Arendt does not use this argument to promote action. In fact later Arendt states ""How can anything relevant for the world e live in arise out of so resultless and enterprise?" page 167. She a few words latter proposes "we have to trace experiences rather than doctrines." Is this her way of saying to us to go out and live and involved life? Will this lead to more knowing than thinking? Marty

1 comment:

  1. Marty--you really show how the experience helps us to understand the theory. . . strong points. And yes, the passages you chose about the differences between thinking in relationship to actual experience and thinking to gain knowledge for knowledge sake--aren't easy. But my interpretation has to do with the fact that Arendt was a phenomenologist:

    Phenomenology, “the study of ‘phenomena’: appearances of things, or things as they appear in our experience, or the ways we experience things, thus the meanings things have in our experience. (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy).

    For example: Arendt is looking at the phenomenon of the Holocaust and trying to understand the conditions that allowed the unraveling of this travesty and the larger implications thereof. She didn’t want to say—“It’s finished, we can go back to our lives now. A bad thing happened but now we move on.”

    Arendt was interested in the species of phenomenology that is characterized as having to do with the public space. “She regards philosophy as born out of the experienced discrepancy between this ‘world of appearances’ in which we live and the medium of words which support ‘thinking’ . . .understanding the world of appearances means an attempt to uncover the nature of the human living ‘in the midst of the world’ . . .Arendt was also aware of how this public space is manipulated by governments, by commercial advertising, by ‘spin doctors’, and in general ‘by speech that does not disclose what is but sweeps it under the carpet. . Arendt’s strong commitment to public life in the plurality, the requirement to listen attentively to the discord of many voices, meant that, for her, genuine thinking required a public space, and needed to be carried out under public scrutiny and sustained by public participation, and this meant for her the practice of a kind of intellectual journalism” (Dermot Moran ,Introduction to Phenomenology, 287-89).

    So, Marty, you are onto something, what I believe she is saying is that thinking should serve the world and deal with our histories and with our current realities. Thinking should draw on the truth of lived experiences, and reflect on our actions, in order that we might better use our human capacities to not repeat the same mistakes, to create a better reality. We should not get stuck in a world of pure abstraction that is ultimately not very meaningful or useful. Philosophy should be useful in the world. Thinking should be in relationship to experience--the experience should inform the thinking and the thinking the next action. . .

    ReplyDelete

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.