On Kindness, pages 1-45 was very interesting reading. On the whole, I think we still live in a competitive, individualistic, egotistically inclined capitalist society that follows the male oriented approach to succeed, and that relegates kindness mainly to the domain of soft-hearted female qualities. Not to say there aren’t exceptions to this everywhere. We have huge diversity of human qualities. Americans can be very generous and charitable as a whole, but there is huge differentiation in the rationale people use (if they use it at all), for performing acts of kindness. Just last week I was at a fundraising luncheon for Warm Wishes, an organization that provides warm articles of clothing to the homeless. I was talking with a representative from a corporate sponsor, who was conflicted about whether it was a good idea or not to give money to a homeless woman with her two young children in tow—rationalizing that surely she would be forced by a brutish male to hand it over for his drinking money. I was trying to place which camp he stood in—the benevolence crowd or the others described in On Kindness. He also described his experience with this own brother, who was a hopeless addict, and projected his view of how helping the homeless with money is like putting fuel on the fire. This man was not able to separate all his worries and judgments from a simple human desire to help another who is suffering. Perhaps that is why he chose to help (or his corporate sponsor employer) with Warm Wishes’ mission, which gives not money but clothing, directly to homeless people.
The text spoke a lot about how Rousseau’s work. What bothered me about Rousseau, despite his fame for his philosophical prowess, was his inability to apply human kindness in his own life. Anyone who puts his own five children into orphanages to protect them from his wife’s relatives has a serious problem with human kindness (37)! It was disturbing to read that. As to whether the egoists or the benevolents have a better rationale for kindness, I’m not sure where I stand on that argument. I’d need to re-read this to get a better sense of who is who. But I recognize the male vs. female tendencies described in the book (the self-interested egoist male mentality, versus the bleeding heart feminine mentality) toward kindness (44), as, unfortunately, still relevant today in our society; an adamant man is perceived as assertive, while an adamant woman is perceived as hysterical….. and so on. Also interesting was the notion that helping those who suffer only encourages more suffering “overbreeding” (38-39).
I found the early philosophers who argued that infants are self absorbed, selfish beasts to be absurd. If we all acted out against our infants for such behavior the human race would have ceased to exist long ago. Thank heaven for the natural female sympathetic tendency toward her infant, and others, for that matter!
No comments:
Post a Comment
Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.