Thursday, March 4, 2010

Capitalism and Kindness

""Sweet commerce," as its admirers dubbed it, was inherently benevolent."
- On Kindness by Adam Phillips and Barbara Taylor, page 25.

"The great advantage of capitalism, according to [Adam] Smith, was that it turned individual desires to public benefit."
- On Kindness by Adam Phillips and Barbara Taylor, page 25.

It is ironic that such an argument would be put forward in order to justify why consumerism is necessary. After all, if consumers stop consuming, the result is a recession, depression, or even total economic collapse. As such, it is important that marketers find a way to convince the masses to continue to consume - even to the point of borrowing so that it is possible. The individual must be motivated to consume. The easiest way to accomplish this is to appeal to the selfish nature of the individual - to make the case that products are required in order to be happy - products, not other people. By creating the need for products, the debt that then results can be turned into yet another product and sold for profit.
Yet, the ironic part is that the most successful time of the year is when consumers purchase good to be given away to friends and family - when they practice a sort of kindness towards their loved ones. Capitalistic proponents seem to be unaware - or perhaps willfully ignorant - of the idea that kindness can sell products more than any other emotion. We have been trapped into a cycle of attempting to sell consumers on what each should desire and want - attempting to compel the individual to seek pleasure from the product itself. Perhaps, though, a cultural shift towards kindness could actually bring more prosperity to all, as consumers begin to purchase goods and services for each other. A recent study actually found that people pay less attention to price when purchasing an item for another person - this would allow for more profits, and greater economic output if such a cultural shift were encouraged by marketers.
I have seen small attempts at this: "... would make a great gift!" But it is always done in a less than subtle and rather cheesy manner.
If a marketer were to truly find a way to create the desire to be kind towards others, and to share a gift with someone else "just because," the end result could be awesome, amazing, wonderful. It could make the world a brighter place that really could solve many of today's most pressing problems and cause a very profound cultural paradigm shift.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.