When I was little, I think about five or six years old, my dad told me about the Golden Rule: Do unto others as you would have them do unto you. I thought that was a good idea. It made sense. But then he told me there was something better. Better? I thought to myself. He said there is a Platinum Rule. I asked him what it was and he replied, “Do unto others as they would have you do unto them.” To me that is the real rule of kindness. Sometimes we think we know what others want or need and so we instead project ourselves onto others. Treating them the way we want to be treated.
On Kindness stated it best I think on page 49, “In short, only an adult, who has learned to bear frustration, is capable of putting the needs of someone else before her own.” Couldn’t this be a definition for parenthood? I think every parent has had to learn how to bear such things on an almost daily basis. And perhaps because women have been expected to fulfill this nurturing role most often, it is inevitable that women should be seen as icons for this type of relationship as adults.
Where the text lost me was in getting all wrapped up in Freud. We have to remember to take Freud in proper context. Yes, he provided some fantastic insight into how the brain works and had some innovative ways of looking at human interaction and sexuality. However, his patients were primarily women who decided of their own accord that they needed therapy and could AFFORD the services he provided. In this way his findings are about a very specific demographic an not the population at large. I personally do not feel that the underlying intentions behind our actions are a cat and mouse game of sexuality. That is really an over simplification.
I agree with On Kindness on the theory that we seek from others the things that we are unable to provide for ourselves. And how we go about receiving those things from others without manipulation is the trick. Relationships between people have become so transactional that it can be difficult to know if we are being honest with ourselves regarding our intentions with others. This is becoming an ever greater concern as we are gradually losing our spiritual self amidst the materialness of our capital driven culture. The more we identify with the “things” around us the less we are identifying with what is within us: our spirit. It is when we are most connected to ourselves that we are capable of reading other’s needs. But in order to desire being kind one has to choose it of their own accord. On Kindness says this well on page 50, “Ordered to be kind, we are likely to be cruel; wanting to be kind, we are likely to discover our generosity.”
We do not like the shackles of obligation. We embrace free will! We want to see that we are choosing to be kind. If it is an expectation, it takes away the gesture of generosity altogether. This is why mandated community service becomes a sentence. Because it is seen as a punishment, the notion of helping others as a positive experience is almost completely lost.
It is easy for us to get lost also in the idea of individualism. Because we pride ourselves on our ability to be self-sufficient, we lose the beauty of our symbiotic relationship to every other being we share this planet with, animals and humans alike. On Kindness states, “We are all dependant creatures, right to the core.” (pp. 96) But this gives no credence to the truly collectiveness of it. Like we breathe in and out, bringing in what we need, we breathe out what others need. Balance. A careful construction of healthy co-dependency. To simply call it dependency, makes it feel again like obligation.
Kindness. Loving oneself enough to love others. That is really all it is.
Thanks Keiko, my parents weren't religiously affiliated and they taught me "The Golden Rule" as well. I really appreciate the upgrade to the "Platinum Rule". I feel like I all too often project onto others what I think I would like if I were them, when really I just don't know what they want exactly because I am not them! It has taken me some time to learn this, and I am still learning it.
ReplyDelete