Thursday, March 25, 2010

Thinking and Moral Considerations

Is "it better to be wronged than to do wrong?" (Arendt p. 181) I'm not so sure. "Wrong" seems to imply that there is a judgement that can be passed - which only a community of people can determine. After all, a given action which may be seen as wrong if done in a community setting (between people, or when other people are present) may not be considered wrong if done alone. And yet, Arendt suggests that we are never alone - as we are always with ourselves. Yet, what we do alone seems to be different than what we would do with others.
Perhaps this wrong that we conceive of occurs with another person present (whether to them, or with them, or with them simply witnessing) - we would obviously be aware of them, and yet find ourselves still carrying out the action. How do we then reconcile the fact that we have committed a wrong? Perhaps the wrong is not in the action itself, in such a case, but in the fact that we have de-valued the other person to such an extent that they cease to be a person at all. In other words, we objectify them in order to carry out an action that we would not be willing to carry out in the presences of another (one that we do value).
All of this goes back to the idea of thought - that thinking, and perceiving the world around us, is what determines what is good and evil. If thoughtlessness is the source of evil (and wrong actions), then these would never take place if we did not cease to value others that are present.
Of course, this is all assuming that if no one else were around, that we would act in a way that is not acceptable - that we value the opinion of others to such a degree that we place our own views on hold in favor of theirs. This is not the case. But in order to find our values, our beliefs, there is an action that is required: thinking. For it is only by thinking, and making those leaps of intuitive thought, that it is possible for us to know what are values and beliefs are. Thoughts and thinking are what let us arrive at a decision (there can be no decision without at least some weighing of the possible consequences of alternatives).
But what about habit? Those decisions that we have made so many times before that we no longer even are aware of the thought process. Are these where evil arises? Is it from lack of re-examining a thought process that leads to us committing breach-of-morality events?
Perhaps it is worth discussing with myself on occasion why I continue to repeat certain actions, and even the order in which I pursue them.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.