Monday, September 5, 2011

Motivation: God's Gift/Curse to Man

Prompt: What motivates individuals and collectives to kindness/generosity rather than violence/destruction?  How does Deo's story speak to these universal themes in particular ways?

In all my years of education, I have NEVER been told to complete a writing assignment that is not a summary or an argument or a response to a specific prompt.  Not until this class, in my sophomore year of college.  For this assignment I was instructed to "think out loud," and I believe that is what I am doing.  It is a new feeling to not be restricted by the nuisance of specific instruction, and to simply write my thoughts in order to reflect.

My classmates and I were told to read Tracy Kidder's "Strength in What Remains;" the horrific and inspiring account of a young man who was able to fight against all odds and survive the Burundian/Rwandan Genocide.  He did what most people who were born and raised in the United States could not do; perhaps because of his background and family, his culture, his instincts, God's intervention, or maybe even pure luck. Not only was he able to survive, but he also came to America, went to a prestigious University, and most surprisingly, he went back.   He evaded countless near death experiences, escaped the horrors of his country, and found refuge in America.  The fact that Deo even lived to tell his tale is unexpected; the fact that he was able to find refuge in the United States of America goes against all odds; the fact that he was able to befriend strangers who housed, clothed, fed, and educated him is insurmountable.  However the part of his story that is the hardest to conceive is the fact that after all the suffering and pain his country and the people of his country had put him and his loved ones through, Deo went back.  And he went back to help others.

I imagine that surviving the genocide would be the greatest gift of all, and that most who survived would try to stay as far away from the source of the pain as possible.   Yet Deo didn't stay far for long.  He went back originally to help his living family members, but eventually he was helping thousands of strangers through the creation of his medical clinic.  Many of these strangers were the same ones who had been a part of the suffering Deo and his were put through.  Why is it that a person who has been forced to face an unimaginable amount of violence and destruction, can still be capable of kindness and generosity?  Not even Deo himself fully understood his actions, as proven through his statement, "...Sometimes I think, 'Am I crazy?' You try to save someone and you get killed, but that person.  You stay away, you get troubled, because you are not doing something you believe in " (229).  In order to attempt to understand, we must analyze the source of the kindness or violence.

All actions are performed in order to fulfill certain motives.  The motives for violence and destruction can consist of anger, fear, jealousy, hatred, spite, selfishness, etc.  However the motives for kindness and generosity can be love, care, mercy, and hope.  The key difference is that the motives for violence are emotions centered around oneself while the motives for kindness are centered around others.  Deo is able to push past the strong emotions of fear and hate which stem from the horrible events of his past, and embrace his long held longing to aid others.  He does this in hopes of setting an example to the people of his country, and teach them that there is no difference between human beings.  Deo exemplifies this during his visit to the Seminaire de Buta, the Catholic school where his own brother was murdered.  While examining the mural of the forty boys who were killed at the school, the author proclaimed that he could not tell which of the boys were Tutsis and which were Hutus.  Deo's repsonse was, "Exactly...and neither could the killers!" (211).  As people we all feel happiness and joy; sadness and regret.  We all have the choice to pick what we are motivated by.  In the end it is our own decision on what we decide to be motivated by which makes all the difference.

A World of Kindness -Meghann Jones

What motivates individuals and collectives to acts of kindness/generosity rather than violence/destruction? How does Deo’s story speak to these universal themes in particular ways? (Take whatever you want and build on it with your own ideas and tie into other parts of the text)

According to Webster’s Dictionary, motivation means to have a motive. Motive, in that same dictionary, means a reason to do something. On an individual level, motivation will depend on the individual who is being looked at. For example, Johnny grew up in a household that was very active in their local community. As a result, Johnny would not find volunteering as much of a hassle like Bobby, who spends most of his time playing video games, would. The act of kindness or generosity is variable from person to person but there is a universal or a collective acceptance of what kindness and generosity is. Reverting back to the days of kindergarten, when a nap was a part of the school schedule and we learned basics like our ABCs and counting to ten, the complicated concepts of kindness or generosity were starting to form. Like all lessons in life, the concept of kindness and generosity, is learned from a person’s experiences. In Tracy Kidder’s book, Strength in What Remains, the story of Deo’s escape from genocide and his survival in “Iburaya” or a faraway place that cannot be imaginable (6), supports the idea that things like kindness or generosity are learned from experience.

The horror and desolation that occurred in Rwanda and surrounding countries during the genocide was a terrible event. The images that Deo had to witness will always be with him in his memories but the lesson to take from Kidder’s book is that even good can be a result of such a huge tragedy. Deo barely escaped with his life and came to New York in pursuit of starting with an essentially clean slate. His first experience in the United States was trying to get through Customs. Deo’s was then taken under the wing of Muhammad who provided him with a place to live and a job delivering groceries. It wasn’t much a living and he survived on, “milk, and bread, and cookies ( 27)” but he got by. It was the moment he delivered groceries to Sharon McKenna that changed his life. Deo recognized that Sharon was someone to rely on and even though sometimes he thought, “I hate this woman (56),” he relied on her for his survival and Sharon was the one that found him housing with Nancy and Charlie. It was hard for Deo to rely on others to get what he wanted but his dream of being a doctor was only possible with Nancy and Charlie’s help. In 1995, Nancy and Charlie had Deo enrolled in Columbia University in New York (99). Both Nancy and Charlie acted as Deo’s American parents and supported his academic journey from college to medical school. Deo later received his residency as an American citizen in 2007 and in November of that year his clinic opened to the community in Kigutu.

Deo barely escaped with his life but it was his constant exposure to the kindness of total strangers that helped him to prosper in the United States. Because he experienced kindness and generosity first hand, his way to show kindness was to start the clinic. It is a never ending cycle that will keep going as long as the kindness still remains. There is no explanation of why a person will be kind to a total stranger but the fact that he or she is kind may lead to the next person showing kindness to another stranger. Until eventually, there will be a world that knows kindness instead of violence. Unfortunately, there is violence prevalent in society today but the little acts that each person can do make a difference. A perfect quote to wrap up this idea is in the Epilogue when elderly women tried to apologize to Deo for the genocide. His response was, “What happened happened. Let’s work on the clinic. Let’s put this tragedy behind us, because remembering is not going to benefit anyone (259).” In other words, Deo will never forget his past but what is important to him now is the future and that is to lead a life of giving and kindness through his clinic.


-Meghann Jones

The Polar Nature of Humanity

“What motivates individuals and collectives to acts of kindness/generosity rather than violence/destruction? How does Deo’s story speak to these universal themes in particular ways?”

More than a story of success against great hardships, the chronicle of Deo’s life offers insight into the expanse of human nature. Closer to the point, Deo’s experiences include extreme acts of kindness as well as despicable examples of violence. I believe that kind acts, such as those experienced by Deo, are the product of humanity’s innate compassion whereas violent experiences result when individual desires overrule a person’s inherit ability to care about others.

There are many instances where people showed great goodness by assisting Deo. Muhammad takes Deo to where he lives and helps Deo find a job, even though Deo is a complete stranger (11-18). Sharon McKenna works tirelessly to try to find Deo a good place to live (56). Nancy and Charlie Wolf let Deo live with them for free, even though they really don’t know him that well (67). Perhaps the greatest show of kindness came from the Hutu mother, who likely risked her life to help Deo get into the refugee camp (126-129). In all of these cases, people make sacrifices to help Deo with no concrete benefits for themselves.

In stark contrast to the acts of kindness, Deo’s life story involved a significant amount of violence. He grew up in a school system where the children were frequently found at fault and therefore beat (81). He witnessed refugees being led away to their deaths and women being taken away to be raped (132). Of course, the largest source of violence for Deo was the attempted genocide of the Tutsis by the Hutus. In all of this violence, the morality of humans was being overruled by other aims. In the case of the beatings, the teachers were trying to enforce strict discipline amongst the students. The refugees were probably murdered on the off chance that they were Tutsi. Women refugees were raped to satisfy the soldiers’ desire for power and lust. The entire war was caused by anger that stemmed from prejudice and ethnic inequality.

It is my belief that humans are naturally altruistic and can frequently sacrifice to help others, as evidenced by Deo’s encounters. It is only when desires and emotions overpower this fundamental morality that people resort to great violence.


- Christopher Galbick

Twisted Nature - J. Kiefer O'Sullivan

I believe kindness and generosity are a fundamental part of human nature, and that it is society that warps individuals into selfishness, inaction, and apathy. Sharing has always been essential to the survival of our species. If our hunter gatherer ancestors didn’t return with the food they had caught and had shared it with the rest of the tribe, the cohesion and overall health of the tribe would suffer, and the members would be less likely to survive as a whole. New scientific research is now even discovering an “altruism gene” present among a wide variety of living creatures, from small insects to chimpanzees. Members of a group who selflessly share their food when they have some to spare contribute to the overall health and success of the group, and therefore also the individuals that are a part of it. Nature is not as “dog eat dog” as we once thought. Of course, one can then extrapolate what this looks like in humanity: generosity, charity, philanthropy.

As humans, I believe we are destined from birth to grow up and contribute to society, to help and share so that we all may be at peace. However, the society we have constructed does not reward those who share this belief. Society demands that we take what we can get, whenever we can get it, and savour it for ourselves. We live in a world of need. We are forced to believe that there is just not enough to go around and that if we don’t take what we can get, somebody else will. Now, because of this belief, it has become the truth, it has become the world we live it. We are made to help, but taught not to by society. I believe this is the reason why most of humanity is suffering.

Individuals are motivated towards evil, not by nature, but through a warping of their natural selves. This can be seen many times in Deo’s story. One phrase that really resonated with me that I feel illustrates this is in the way Deo interprets the PIH’s message: “Prevent people from suffering! Don’t wait for people to feel like their lives are not worth living. Once they feel that way, how are they going to feel about another person’s life?” (155). Suffering begets suffering, evil begets evil. It creates something akin to a positive feedback loop, the more suffering exists, the more suffering will exist. Essentially good people commit evil acts because they get caught up in this cycle. I feel Deo illustrates this well when he is quoted speaking about the living conditions in his country: “How are you going to think right? With pain everywhere. So it’s been really hard to blame people all the time. They were not themselves. They were something else” (187).

I believe humans are benevolent creatures, but suffering is what changes us, for worse or for better.

Sunday, September 4, 2011

Desperation -Whitney Myers

I have been told, in various forms, at various times, in relation to various events, that a society has erupted into violence and destruction because that society’s groups, be they religiously, economically, or ethnically based, experienced desperate levels of inequality. Desperation drove the conflict, because the situation that those groups found themselves in became so dire that violent change became a viable option. While the idea of violence as a logical choice seems hopelessly impossible for me to comprehend, something that could never become acceptable to me, the idea of such complete desperation also seems incomprehensible. It seems to me that I cannot condemn a society or group or person for resorting to means I cannot imagine when they suffer pain I cannot imagine.

Deo has a similar explanation for the violence, but cites misery and pain as the root cause of the conflict in Burundi and Rwanda. “How are you going to think right? With pain everywhere. So it’s been really hard to blame the people who have been slaughtering each other, though I do blame people all the time. They were not themselves. They were something else” (187). Like me, Deo finds it difficult to hold those in desperate pain accountable for resorting to violence. Desperate levels of pain or misery, or even economic desperation, is something I have never felt, and so cannot understand, but Deo has felt desperation, and believes that desperation has the capacity to change a person to the extent that they cannot be completely responsible for their violent actions.

Following the logic above, the Hutus and Tutsis experienced so much ethnic discrimination and economic inequality that they became desperate, and therefore accepted violence as an acceptable means to deal with their desperation. I wonder, in that case, what separates one person’s desperation from another’s? Though Deo’s situation was desperate, he did not pick up a machete and join the brutality, as others did. He cannot have been so much better off than those instigating the violence, and yet, according the explanation above, desperation should determine violence. So there must be further factors determining who will adopt violence as a tool for change.

Whether people react more like Deo did or more like those who joined the milita men did may be influenced by Deo’s concept of “distracting pain with pain” (208). Deo says “pains exist in layers, with the most excruciating at the top obscuring the pains beneath” (209). This idea seems to have merit to me, and to have broad application, as Deo said. Though the application most apparent to me is the childhood practice of pinching the area next to a mosquito bite in order to alleviate the itch by obscuring it with the pain of the pinch, it does seem, as Deo says, to have a much larger psychological application. “So many years of paying attention to the topmost pain of war, he felt, had left many of his people numb to all the rest” (209). Perhaps Deo did not react to his desperation by picking up a machete and attacking because he was relatively unexposed to violence before the genocide, and had not become numb to brutality on the level of the militias. Perhaps, becoming numb to violence through layer upon layer of pain will predispose a person in a desperate situation to react in a violent way.

In order to motivate a group or person toward kindness and generosity rather than violence, they must be removed from desperate situations that can trigger violent action. Whether they react to the desperation like Deo did or like those who joined the militia men did, if they are not placed in desperate situations, then they will not have reason to resort to violent means to escape the situation. Deo’s clinic is an excellent example of alleviation of desperation leading to a more peaceful community. “It seemed to Deo that Kigutu was becoming a ‘neutral ground,’ a place where Tutsis from the mountains and Hutus from the lakeside could mingle without fear” (259). When Deo assisted in lessening the suffering in the community, those in the community became less desperate, and therefore less likely to resort to violence.

Saturday, September 3, 2011

A Universal Message

What motivates individuals and collectives to kindness/generosity rather than violence/destruction? How does Deo’s story speak to these universal themes in particular ways?

I am reminded of a quote from J.K. Rowling's Harry Potter and the Order of the Pheonix: "We all have good and bad inside of us. It's what side we choose to follow that defines who we really are." Every day we each fight our own battles – whether to help a classmate or ignore them so we stay on top in class rank; if we should trust that the weary man begging for money is truly using it for food or for liquor - and each day I'm sure we can all say there are some things we did that we are proud of, and others not so much.

The question remains, and as the prompt says: what drives us to do one or the other? Julia listed experience and environment as two of our motivations for kindness or destruction. Indeed, these are major factors that affect our personality and beliefs, but there are far more elemental traits, such as human empathy and the innate need to relate to the world around us, that are tied to our choices of good and bad.

If we sat down and thought about all the decisions we made in one day, no matter how small, I think we could eventually connect that choice to an act reflecting kindness or violence. In turn, that action would reflect an image of us. Most people, including me, would analyze an act and ask, “Why did they do that? What would I have done differently?” We ask ourselves these questions because we are all drawn towards understanding and relating. In Kidder’s novel, Nancy states, “I believe it is human to hope to find order and a connection between one’s soul and the world outside.” (168) Her belief manifests itself in Deo’s return to Kigutu and in his drive to create a better health care system for his family, friends, and fellow citizens.

Some would call his acts compassionate or philanthropic, and they are right to do so. But, I believe there are more to his acts than mere adjectives can describe. Kidder commentates, “…trying again to build a clinic must also be a way, I thought, for him to reach back to his former life and connect it with his new one.” (228) Deo’s actions, his story, reflect the universal understanding that we are all tied to relate and to connect with one another, which further drives our decisions towards kindness or destruction.

From: Julia Hand (and by the way--don't forget to title your post!)

What motivates individuals and collectives to kindness/generosity rather than violence/destruction? How does Deo’s story speak to these universal themes in particular ways?

In general, I don’t think human nature guides people towards acts of generosity and kindness. Of course there are exceptions to everything and a range that individuals span, but more often than not self interest plays into how people act. Personal motives impact whether or not someone will act.

Referring back to the original post, the second to last quote incorporates the idea that “we learn through trial and error, through the process of thinking and acting and thinking” (188) which plays into the idea that through personal experiences people learn that a life filled with kindness and generosity is more fulfilling then a life surrounded by violence and destruction.

I would think Deo learned this first hand as, in part one, he fled from his home country of Burundi fearing for his life. As Deo leaves Burundi for the first time he realizes that “for the lucky few with tickets, an airplane was just the fastest, safest way out. It was flight” (3). The violence between the Hutu and Tutsi groups impacted Deo in a way one couldn’t imagine had they not experienced the same destruction. Though malicious decapitations and merciless killings Deo saw the great amount of pain and suffering that one human could inflict upon another and because of his personal experience he could see that life without violence was much more pleasant than life with violence.

This concept not only applies to people fleeing genocide situation, but in everyday life. I experienced it first hand, last week on my first night of Service Learning with Canal Alliance. I wasn’t sure if I was going to enjoy the SL aspect of the course because it takes time away from other priorities such as studying. It’s two less hours I have every week to relax, hang out with friends, watch a movie, work, go to the gym…it could be anything. However, when I arrived, the other participants were upbeat, motivated and excited about being part of the program. Then the students arrived, and in the two or so hours I spent helping them refine their English, they must have thanked me five times for taking the time to help them. The students were really appreciative and so sweet that I am looking forward to going back next week. This positive environment shows me the fulfillment that helping others can bring and will subconsciously influence my decision to volunteer in the future.

Those two hours were productive, not only for the students, but provided me with a sense of accomplishment as well. By experiencing the kindness and generosity of others and seeing how my positive actions can make a difference, makes me want to continue building on the positives in my life. Through experiencing kindness and generosity I can see that I want my life to include more positives and therefore fewer negatives.

The destruction I have experienced did not leave me feeling the same way. Violence does not create a comfortable environment, so when people learn by experiencing they can see the negatives that violence and destruction causes. Through experiencing, living and reflecting upon situations, most humans would be drawn towards the positive. They learned through trial and error the consequences of negative actions and the rewards of positive actions. The knowledge gained by experience gets people to act in selfless ways, therefore motivating kind/generous acts.

-J.Hand