Wednesday, March 30, 2011

Our New Kind of Body

When I finished reading this article it reminded me of the saying, “Actions speak louder than words.” It is not enough to have ideas and “know” what is good, it must be acted out everyday, we must consciously be aware of it. Needleman brings new light to the understanding the relationship between our mind and our body. We must first accept our state of being. “The Christian doctrine of ‘original sin’ was no doubt intended as an expression of this idea. As such, it was perhaps intended to help men and women confront the degraded state of their being and by so doing support in them-in us- the healing action of remorse”(Needleman, n.p.). Remorse, unlike guilt, we’ll bring us to understand ourselves and accept what and who we are, “ a relaxation that opens the heart and body to receive a new quality of attention-an attention or conscious energy…” (Needleman, n.p.).

Our body is the primary instrument or, as Needleman puts it, the “necessary element” which will lead us to do “good.” Our bodies are alive and we know when it physically feels good or when it is in pain. “In such states one may observe that the body is temporarily transformed and permeated with a fine energy, a subtle quality of sensation unlike anything we experience in the ordinary course of our lives…” (n.p). This “sensation” occurs whenever we experience love, anger sadness. Our body feels it too.

e HeAs we have seen from our service learning, it is our actions that have made the biggest impact on our communities. We all chose to use our bodies as an instrument to make good differences. Our ideas and good intentions are being put to action. This is the “sensation” that Needleman refers to in his article. Even if we haven’t realized it yet, as we continue working with our community partners, we ourselves are building a “new kind of body, a body that has a new aim, a new purpose: voluntarily to serve the Good” (n.p.). This may also lead to new discoveries within ourselves “that we perhaps glimpsed in our lives…”

Personally, I have been learning a lot about myself through my experience at the pet shelter. It wasn’t till I started volunteering at this place that I realized how much comfort these creatures can bring to a person, especially to me. It feels really good that I have been able to take care of them and give them to a loving family. I now know that to do good does not only mean to other humans but to our environment, nature, animals, and anything else that is alive. I am sure that we have all discovered something new about ourselves that we didn’t know before working with our community partners. I encourage everyone to share anything new that you have discovered about yourself.

Tuesday, March 29, 2011

From Tom: Kindness is a leap

The world seems rarely kind, most would agree I think. Why is this the case? Barbara Taylor and Adam Philips in On Kindness says it is our culture that informs our attitudes towards being kind. "Kindness is the saboteur of the successful life"(5) is a common misconception. When we decide to be kind to another person, we are opening ourselves up to them, letting our defenses down in the process. I think after enough time when you are rebuffed for being kind, or met with the antithesis of kindness when you offer it, it tends to make one cold and hard. Then guess what? When others open up to you, you meet them with that same coldness.

Many intelligent people, like D. H. Lawrence mentioned on page 8, thought kindness was more like a selfish act and therefore not to be trusted. "All compassion is self-pity," he is said to remarked. The authors believed this kind of attitude picked up traction about the time of Thomas Hobbes in his work Leviathan, and his personal philosophy of all men basically being selfish. Those that professed to be kind were really weak, and relied on the Christian ethic of kindness and its reciprocity.

According to the authors, this Hobbesian mode of thinking took hold gradually, despite the efforts of men like David Hume attempting to counter it. Hume insisted that any man who denied his natural inclination towards being kind "has forgotten the movements of his heart."(5) This may be more true than what is generally known regarding the heart as a thinking organ. In Tom Shadyac's I Am, a few scenes from that documentary take place at the Heartmath Institute which shows that living things may be connected in ways we never thought were possible. Something as primitive as a dollop of yogurt can sense your emotional state, so it seems.

According to their research(check it out at www.heartmath.org), the heart acts as a hormonal gland and facilitates emotions in the brain. That's why you feel love in the heart, though conventional science says you are experiencing a mere chemical response in the brain. The Heartmath Institute calls this "neurocardiology," the study of the heart-mind. It's pretty fascinating stuff.

The important point of the documentary and the book is that kindness is more than just a psychological need, it's a biological need too. Most people who unwittingly take the Hobbesian point of view towards kindness often cite Charles Darwin as one of their inspirations. Since Darwin postulated that competition is the essence of natural selection, anything that doesn't offer immediate gain is of little value. Genuine kindness is often done with no regard to the self, so it must be a sign of weakness and the province of those "less fit."

But those that think that haven't explored what Darwin was teaching very deeply. "Sympathy and cooperation were innate to man, Darwin argued in The Descent of Man(1871), and a key factor behind humanity's evolutionary success."(97) Kindness and community have always been a necessity because we simply can't provide for ourselves alone. Another reason why it's difficult to be kind is the inherent vulnerability in offering your kindness to another.

Unwanted kindness is awkward, something like the ultimate in rejection. And no one likes to feel rejected! That's the risk you have to take, I suppose. What's stronger than the fear of rejection, though, is what you get out of it. "Real kindness doesn't require selflessness, it is rather that real kindness changes people in the doing of it, often in unpredictable ways."(13) Overcome your sense of vulnerability and practice kindness, then watch it ripple through people like a wave. Kind of like reversing the spin of a karmic wheel when its not turning your way. That's powerful stuff.

Saturday, March 26, 2011

Prompt for extra credit reading: Why Can't We Be Good?

One of the reasons that I originally picked this piece is that Needleman, unlike many philosophers, acknowledges the role of the body, the fact that we are embodied and it is the body that moves in the world and manifests thought through action. Reading this on the heels of Arendt's Responsibility and Judgment, it is interesting to note that he too sees guilt as a way of hiding from responsibility. He writes that it is "such emotions as guilt and fear, with their reflexes of self-pity and anger" that can lead to emotional reactions that do not include the necessary reflection that will lead to ethical action. (pdf pgs. 2.2-3.1).
This is part of his larger question regarding crossing the Socratic threshold between thought and action. The whole question, Why can't we be good?, rests on this, not the fact that we may
know what is good but what " we do, with painful frequency" is the very opposite (pdf. 7.2). "Ideas . . . are necessary. But they are not enough" (pdf 9.1).
Needleman writes,
we need to make use of the ways and means to be outwardly 'in the street' in our actual lives, while somehow, or to some extent remaining inwardly in the theater of the mind . . . to be in two places at once. . .We need something that is fundamentally unknown to ourselves: to question our lives without inwardly or outwardly holding back from whatever life offers and asks of us. (pdf 10.1)
Think about these ideas in relation to our class, the ways in which we are trying to cultivate the habits of mind that lead to the capacity to question ourselves and at the same time we are "in the street," in our bodies, living these ideas in our service. Use specifics from the text and your service to illustrate how this dual experience and what you are learning.

Thursday, March 24, 2011

From Dayna: On Kindness

This idea that Phillips and Taylor perceive that “our motives are utterly self-

seeking, and that our sympathies are forms of self-protection,” can be quite true in our

society. I feel when looking at yourself you might say, no that’s not true. But if you look

at our society as a whole, it is this constant competition to be better than somebody else.

For some one to act kind to a stranger or someone they know, with the only goal in mind

to get something back in return. That they are acting on kindness, but there underlying

focus is selfish. This relates with the film, “I Am, directed by Tom Shadyac, which

generally discovers that the human race has been raised to understand that the top priority

in our society is competition. That stepping on others toes will get you ahead and that

you cannot be truly happy until “you have it all.” Whatever “it all” is. Which is not true,

happiness and kindness can come from the smallest thing, volunteering your time to

support a group of teenage mothers who need the help and advice or seeing a child use

the skills you taught them to then succeed at it on their own (one of the children in my

class today learned how to tie his shoe completely on his own!). These things make me

happy, as well as many more things. I agree that our society acts in this selfish way but I

don’t understand it.

From Denise: IT MAKES LIFE WORTH LIVING

“How do people come to forget about kindness and the deep pleasures it gives
to them?” (5). When relating this question to my service project, adult literacy
tutoring, I see that the “pleasure of kindness” (5), may go unrecognized by the
person who is “leading a secretly kind life” (4), namely my student. I’m sure
she has no idea of the kindness she bestows upon me, by her continual, obvious,
appreciation of my help and time. I admire her resilience and resourcefulness, and
cannot imagine the courage it took for her to pursue finding a tutor, from the testing
and evaluation of her literacy skills, or lack of skills, to the “vulnerability” (12) of
the risk in “connecting” with a complete stranger. She could have easily “kept her
distance from other people…to feel safe” (6) by accepting her language limitations,
maintaining contact only within her community.

Our relationship is a true example of what the authors call “real kindness…an
exchange with essentially unpredictable consequences”, it “is a way of knowing
people beyond our understanding of them”. (13). As for my part in this exchange,
I have always had “the universal human impulse to help strangers” and never
thought of myself as “selfish”, “narcissistic”, or a “self-approbation junkie” (111).
Although I often am the recipient of others’ kindness, I have also unfortunately
experienced way too much unkindness in the past few years, and “nothing outrages
us more than people being unkind to us” (10). I believe no matter what unkindness
is shown to me, “living a life guided by kindness” (10), offers me an opportunity to
see “kindness as being in solidarity with human need” (114). If I were to question
my own motives, “why should anyone care whether a person entirely unknown to
(me) gets the (literacy skills) he or she needs?” (100), the answer is that when I
show “real kindness”, it is because ”as every person, in some part of himself, knows:
that feelings of connection and reciprocity are among the greatest pleasures that
human beings can possess.” (110-111). I may be forced to accept some of my life
situations, but I have to believe, as long as I have “the kind of involvement with
other people that we both fear and crave; then kindness fundamentally, makes
life worth living” (113), and “it is the strongest indicator of (my) well-being, the
pleasure in existence”. (111)

Saturday, March 19, 2011

Prompt: ON KINDNESS

Against Kindness and Modern Kindness

The authors thesis (you may not agree but try to see this on a societal level, not from your individual perspective) is that, “[m]ost people appear to believe that deep down they (and other people) are mad, bad, and dangerous to know. . . our motives are utterly self-seeking, and that our sympathies are forms of self-protection” (4).

The authors suggest that although many of us live life in “instinctive sympathetic identification with the vulnerabilities and attractions of others. . . but without a language in which to express this, or cultural support for it” (4)

(Again, remember, at times we have to over-generalize in order to be able to examine collective issues, and if we look at the state of our own country in the moment, there may be some evidence that supports these claims.)

One of the reasons, that the authors suggest, for our ambivalence about our instinct for kindness, has to do with making ourselves vulnerabile, weak: “Bearing other people’s vulnerability—which means sharing in it imaginatively and practically . . .––entails being able to bear one’s own” (11). In a sense, what we have in common is our vulnerability (an idea that Judith Butler will elaborate on in Precarious Life).

Thus, kindness has an internal tension—it brings us pleasure but it also reminds us of all that we fear about ourselves including change. (There is also an interesting discussion about whether kindness requires selflessness—hopefully we will discuss in class as this is important and a theme that will come up in C. Fred Alford’s book on whistleblowers.) How do you see the role of vulnerability in your service-learning experience? Think about yourself, those you work with etc. As always use the text to support your ideas and specifics from service to illustrate.

Also think about this in relation to and tie in the final chapter, "Modern Kindness" where the authors start by citing Winnicott who wrote about our moral ability to imagine the "thoughts and feelings and hopes of another person" (95). Jonathon Lehrer also described this capacity for empathy and its source in the emotions. The argument is also very much the message that is so well captured in I Am, for those who saw it: "We depend upon others not just for our survival but for our being. The self without sympathetic attachments is either a fiction or a lunatic" (95).

The authors continue to discuss the reasons why this is such a difficult reality for us to face: "Our resistance to kindness is resistance to encountering what kindness means in us, and what we meet in other people by being kind to them" (113).

Of course, our issues with vulnerability and dependence as discussed in the first chapter are a large part of this resistance. So keep thinking about the connections and how you see the implications in your own relation to your service experience (remember to start with yourself, not just about what you see in others).