Tuesday, November 2, 2010
Life as a project
Realizing Authenticity
In his last chapter Guignon revisits the assumptions previously outlined about authenticity, acknowledging "mucking around inside the mental container, far from leading us to a better, richer life, might be a path to confusion and despair" (p. 147). He then tries to narrow in on what authenticity is by drawing on past responses to Romanticism and our own modern battles with the authentic self. His conclusion is less a strict definition of what authenticity is than what authenticity does, stating that through "attentiveness and activism…the authentic person takes a stand not just on his or her own life, but on the community's project of achieving a good society" (p. 162). Calhoun goes into the details of authenticity, stating why integrity is vital to acting constructively as an authentic person and answering the question "What is worth doing?" (p. 257, Standing for Something). Guignon's conclusions, as well as Cheshire Calhoun’s expansion on authenticity, gave me an academic view of authenticity that reached beyond a personal understanding of self to a shared yet individual identity.
This book, and this concept, was not one that I particularly wanted to go over: in fact, it seemed like this was another opportunity to beat the concept of authenticity into my head with a stick. My home has never been the most stable environment and it took until last spring for me to break away from being defined by circumstance and cultivate a strong personal identity. My understanding of self is now extremely determined because I grew up with very little personal structure or security and huge familial, social, and societal expectations. As both Calhoun and Guignon note, the narrativist view “assumes there is something within me to which I do have privileged access or knowledge”; however, without a personal identity, my authentic nature was defined for me and the integrity of what I did was stripped away (p. 140). It is impossible to stand for something when you have no foundation for your beliefs, and even more so when you are taught to follow others beliefs with no thought about your own. I am really thankful I found friends who taught me it is always possible to strive for something better.
I am extremely vocal about my identity, partly because coming from an environment where everyone chose my identity (or lack of one) for me, it took me my entire life to find it and like someone lost at sea who found solid ground I'm not letting it go. Because it took an entire lifetime to gain self-definition, becoming a Christian was faster on paper than it was in process; it took me half a year to go from belief in God to commitment through Baptism, another half a year to truly identify as a Christian. Every day I learn something new about what it means to truly follow Christ's example in my life and how I can become a better human being. It gives me integrity.
Having that center defines my purpose, but knowing in my heart that I was made as an individual with a unique body, spirit, and mind and can have an individual relationship with God not only gives me identity within myself but through my actions, in my community, and through the good that I can do. I battle with fear and anxiety over being successful or not living up to the standards I make for myself, but I refuse to let the desire to become consumed with myself or to become apathetic to life keep me from making a difference in the world.
One of my biggest reasons for working with Big Brothers Big Sisters is that I might be able to give other children the opportunity to find their authentic self before society has smothered their identity by defining them. This Friday one of the best events of the year is taking place with Big Brothers Big Sisters of the North Bay, "Morning of Inspiration". It provides an opportunity for donors and sponsors to hear stories from Bigs and Littles about their experience of the program, each other, and becoming involved in a program that gives them both greater self definition. I helped work on the decorations for the event last Thursday, with hundreds of photos of Bigs and Littles in the community bonding in ways that wouldn't seem out of the ordinary to most people; when you consider that the few hours per week that many of these children spend with their mentors fishing, coloring, studying, or even just talking, are some of the only moments they have to think of their owngoals and aspirations, its really special. This August, when I volunteered at Bocce for Kid's Sake I met a Little named Alex who was amazing and had the most moxi of any 12 year old I had ever met; I didn't find out until the end of the day that she'd been bouncing from foster home to foster home for years and that at times her Big had to call multiple contacts to get a hold of her new location. Somehow, her Big always found her, and somehow Alex is still strong and smiling, which is why I think that authenticity and defining yourself is such a huge part of Big Brothers Big Sister's mission.
As Guignon relates in his final chapter, authenticity is personal and societal, singular and plural, individualistic and integrative. Authenticity is "one of a group of character traits that play a key role in fitting us for membership in a society of a particular sort", a way of saying who you are relative to where you are/want to be and navigating that divide (p. 161). The key to both his and Chalhoun's definitions is that by starting with what authenticity is not (a choice between self and society), they can break down the modern conception of authenticity as "a virtue more concerned with the individual's personal fulfillment…than it is a social virtue comparable to fairness an decency" (p. 150). Once stripped of the convenient options or responses to a fairly complicated and complex question, it is possible to admit what we know and don't know and approach authenticity with authentic and honest answers.
Monday, November 1, 2010
The Bigger Picture
Saturday, October 30, 2010
In All Things, Moderation...
Friday, October 29, 2010
Wednesday, October 27, 2010
Social Virtue
As the final chapters of Charles Guignon's book On Being Authentic unfold we are faced with the final verdict on authenticity. What does it mean to really be authentic? Though Guignon has thus far only given us a historical and factual understanding to the meaning of authenticity, here he finally gives his own opinion of what theories and ideas he thinks make up the true self.
In a nutshell, he believes that we are "self-making or self-fashioning beings"(127) and that "we have the ability to organize our lives into a relatively cohesive story"(130) which we shape by our experiences, interactions, and feelings; these creative, unique configurations make us into self-made people. Though he mentions death, responsibility, and the concept of time, his overpowering concept that he is trying to express deals with the role society plays in forming an authentic self. In previous chapters Guignon has given various accounts on the way society has been viewed in the past in relation to finding the self. What he now proposes is that the best way to look at authenticity is as a "social virtue"(156), not as only a personal one. He argues that we are "shaped and defined by society"(155) and that we find our identity and integrity by being conscious of what the issues of the world are and by enacting our own selves accordingly; "becoming authentic involves becoming more clear-sighted and reflective about the issues that face us in our current situation"(161).
In her essay "Standing for Something", Cheshire Calhoun focuses on the integrity of being. She offers that integrity is a social virtue that is expressed by people who "stand for something". Having something that you are wholeheartedly committed to does not necessarily make you authentic; for example being dedicated to money or power is not usually considered a virtue. It can be considered a virtue if it is being sought after not only for personal gain but for social precedent. She also states that the personal virtues that we do hold help us to conduct ourselves properly with others and allows for relationships of mutual respect to form.
In the service-learning experience I have had so far I have learned more about myself then I thought I would. With this statement I do not want to imply that my rewards have only been to realize my "personal identity", just that I have seen that humans as a whole, which also includes myself, are ever changing and that the encounters and experiences that we have shape us into people who can interact with society and who can develop the virtues that are crucial to living with others. I have visited a few families in the Marin Parents of Multiple's Club outreach program and have seen the dedication that Jana has put in to helping out the struggling parents. I have also personally experienced how my identity has shifted since I have been interacting with mothers, who identify themselves with a different group than I do. Also, I have realized that since I am living in society, I should also be an active member of it not just a self-centered being who focuses inward to find authenticity. By reaching out in my community I have been able to commit to something that will improve the well being of society.
-Ilaria Guerra
Monday, October 25, 2010
Prompt for 11/2: On Being Authentic and "Standing for Something":
Both argue for the ways in which our "authentic" identity hinges on our participation with others in the world. Guignon states this concisely when he summarizes the philosophical views of Bernard Williams:
“It is only through the our social interactions that we become selves whose inner episodes are given enough steadiness and cohesiveness so that our relations to others can be built on cooperation and trust” (155)And again, later:
“when the ideal of authenticity is understood in terms of its social embodiment [the ways in which we engage with the world] it is clear that being authentic is not just a matter of concentrating on one’s own self, but also involves deliberation about how one’s commitments make contribution to the good of the public world in which one is a participant” (163).
Calhoun similarly argues that “integrity” can and should be seen as a social virtue:
Integrity calls us simultaneously to stand behind our convictions and to take seriously others' doubts about them. Thus, neither ambivalence nor compromise seem inevitably to betoken lack of integrity. If we are not pulled as far as uncertainty or compromise, integrity would at least demand exercising due care in how we go about dissenting. (260)Please think about one or more of these statements in relation to your service-learning experience, and discuss making connections with other textual quotes/ideas and specifics from your work with the community.