Tuesday, November 2, 2010

Life as a project

In this weeks reading a theme that came up was life and the way we live it. "In other words, this way of life owns up to what is always the case: that you are what you do, and that you can and should own up to this fact and take responsibility for what you are creating. (p.132)" It seems to be a social trend to try to get out of responsibility for actions. From the Deepwater Horizon oil spill to the handling of hurricane Katrina we have examples of companies, governments, and organizations trying to avoid taking responsibility for their mistakes. These examples can influence the people in our society that they can get out of responsibility for their significantly smaller blunders. I remember trying to get out trouble as a child and every time I was found out my parents would tell me that I had to take responsibility for my actions. Reading this book I wonder who will tell us that we have to take responsibility for our actions and if we as a society would even listen.
The readings in this class are chosen to make us think about our lives and the world we live in. This quote made me think about my life differently "To face up to death is to see your life as a finite project, something that can and will be finished. This awareness of human finitude brings with it the realization that it is up to you to determine the overall shape your life will have.(p.133)" I never thought of my life as a project. My life seemed to me something I had control over, but not a project that I would take credit for. We won't live forever and we should all accept that. We should make the most of our time alive, but that seems like a series of decisions to me. I never thought about the finished project of my life and who I would show it to.

Realizing Authenticity

Revised: I posted an incomplete draft originally/this one is complete.

In his last chapter Guignon revisits the assumptions previously outlined about authenticity, acknowledging "mucking around inside the mental container, far from leading us to a better, richer life, might be a path to confusion and despair" (p. 147). He then tries to narrow in on what authenticity is by drawing on past responses to Romanticism and our own modern battles with the authentic self. His conclusion is less a strict definition of what authenticity is than what authenticity does, stating that through "attentiveness and activism…the authentic person takes a stand not just on his or her own life, but on the community's project of achieving a good society" (p. 162). Calhoun goes into the details of authenticity, stating why integrity is vital to acting constructively as an authentic person and answering the question "What is worth doing?" (p. 257, Standing for Something). Guignon's conclusions, as well as Cheshire Calhoun’s expansion on authenticity, gave me an academic view of authenticity that reached beyond a personal understanding of self to a shared yet individual identity.

This book, and this concept, was not one that I particularly wanted to go over: in fact, it seemed like this was another opportunity to beat the concept of authenticity into my head with a stick. My home has never been the most stable environment and it took until last spring for me to break away from being defined by circumstance and cultivate a strong personal identity. My understanding of self is now extremely determined because I grew up with very little personal structure or security and huge familial, social, and societal expectations. As both Calhoun and Guignon note, the narrativist view “assumes there is something within me to which I do have privileged access or knowledge”; however, without a personal identity, my authentic nature was defined for me and the integrity of what I did was stripped away (p. 140). It is impossible to stand for something when you have no foundation for your beliefs, and even more so when you are taught to follow others beliefs with no thought about your own. I am really thankful I found friends who taught me it is always possible to strive for something better.

I am extremely vocal about my identity, partly because coming from an environment where everyone chose my identity (or lack of one) for me, it took me my entire life to find it and like someone lost at sea who found solid ground I'm not letting it go. Because it took an entire lifetime to gain self-definition, becoming a Christian was faster on paper than it was in process; it took me half a year to go from belief in God to commitment through Baptism, another half a year to truly identify as a Christian. Every day I learn something new about what it means to truly follow Christ's example in my life and how I can become a better human being. It gives me integrity.

Having that center defines my purpose, but knowing in my heart that I was made as an individual with a unique body, spirit, and mind and can have an individual relationship with God not only gives me identity within myself but through my actions, in my community, and through the good that I can do. I battle with fear and anxiety over being successful or not living up to the standards I make for myself, but I refuse to let the desire to become consumed with myself or to become apathetic to life keep me from making a difference in the world.

One of my biggest reasons for working with Big Brothers Big Sisters is that I might be able to give other children the opportunity to find their authentic self before society has smothered their identity by defining them. This Friday one of the best events of the year is taking place with Big Brothers Big Sisters of the North Bay, "Morning of Inspiration". It provides an opportunity for donors and sponsors to hear stories from Bigs and Littles about their experience of the program, each other, and becoming involved in a program that gives them both greater self definition. I helped work on the decorations for the event last Thursday, with hundreds of photos of Bigs and Littles in the community bonding in ways that wouldn't seem out of the ordinary to most people; when you consider that the few hours per week that many of these children spend with their mentors fishing, coloring, studying, or even just talking, are some of the only moments they have to think of their owngoals and aspirations, its really special. This August, when I volunteered at Bocce for Kid's Sake I met a Little named Alex who was amazing and had the most moxi of any 12 year old I had ever met; I didn't find out until the end of the day that she'd been bouncing from foster home to foster home for years and that at times her Big had to call multiple contacts to get a hold of her new location. Somehow, her Big always found her, and somehow Alex is still strong and smiling, which is why I think that authenticity and defining yourself is such a huge part of Big Brothers Big Sister's mission.

As Guignon relates in his final chapter, authenticity is personal and societal, singular and plural, individualistic and integrative. Authenticity is "one of a group of character traits that play a key role in fitting us for membership in a society of a particular sort", a way of saying who you are relative to where you are/want to be and navigating that divide (p. 161). The key to both his and Chalhoun's definitions is that by starting with what authenticity is not (a choice between self and society), they can break down the modern conception of authenticity as "a virtue more concerned with the individual's personal fulfillment…than it is a social virtue comparable to fairness an decency" (p. 150). Once stripped of the convenient options or responses to a fairly complicated and complex question, it is possible to admit what we know and don't know and approach authenticity with authentic and honest answers.

Monday, November 1, 2010

The Bigger Picture

According to Guignon, "we all draw our concrete ways of understanding and evaluating ourselves from the pool of possible interpretations made accessible in the social context in which we find ourselves" (127). As "socially constituted" (126) collective individuals, our definitions of self are as much (or even more) determined by our positions and experiences in society as they are by self-reflection and internal evaluation. Rather than seeing this inevitable social integration and impact as a bane, though, Guignon examines the boons of such a way of living, and the greater moral implications leading interconnected lives forces us to face.

Guignon's discussion on the "social embodiment" (163) aspect of authenticity speaks most prevalently and relevantly to me, to see "life [as] as open-ended and inconclusive project" (129) due to the influences and inclusion of an ever-changing world and ever-morphing society; as Freire put it in his Pedagogy of Freedom, the "unfinishedness" of humanity. Guignon argues that given this truth, that we can never truly "become" ourselves unless we acknowledge that we never actually had to, nor never really can become ourselves, we must thereby strive to "envisage some range of goals and ideals and do our best to bring them to realization, leaving the rest of the contingencies of the real world" (129).

Guignon also notes that as humans we are "inescapably embedded in a wider context of meaning, a tradition, which itself has the shape of an unfolding narrative" (135). We are the products, and the producers, of our given realities. We are the victims of our circumstances, and also the creators of the lives we choose to lead. Either way, we are always in some way, constantly connected to the greater. Losing sight of our interconnectedness not just within ourselves, but also to the world as a far larger whole, we run the "risk of slipping into a life so prone to self-absorption and compulsive self-surveillance that one becomes isolated from all those who share this preoccupation" (147). In focusing solely on ourselves, we sacrifice that vital human experience of being and becoming a force within the larger and more collective force.

"... The ability to be a reflective individual who discerns what is genuinely worth pursuing within the social context in which he or she is situated," influenced but not completely swayed by society, is to Guignon a part of the ideal of authenticity. I agree largely with this philosophy. I don't believe that anyone can truly and wholely escape the grasp or influence of "society." I don't think that isolation guarantees a deeper searching and discovering of self, nor do I believe that society always knows what is right.

In struggling to find balance between autonomy and conformity within myself, I see authenticity as the power and courage to develop one's own internal self despite the influences that our modern society forces upon us. To acknowledge the existence of societal norms, and to allow them infiltrate our worldviews, but also to sort through what we are told and to stay true to our own, deeply personal opinions.

In my work at Canal Alliance, I am seeing Guignon's arguments for authenticity as both a personal and social virtue in my approach to my service learning. I feel as though I am developing myself as an individual through the volunteer work I am doing to (hopefully) benefit others. But beyond selfish motivations to improve myself, I am genuinely loving the experience of teaching others some of the things I have come to take for granted, which has consequently led to me realize how fortunate I am to be where I am and to have had the education I have, and to appreciate that which I am doing for others that someone at one point has had to do for me.

"This sort of releasement means no longer putting ourselves at the center of the picture, no longer letting our egos get in the way in every situation. It points to a way of getting into the swim of what is going on around us without asking where we stand in it all" (165).


Phillipa Armes

Saturday, October 30, 2010

In All Things, Moderation...

Individuals in modern times are grappling with finally obtaining the long fought for and flourishing independence in their relationship with society. No longer are our actions pre-judged based off of our ranking. I was not born a baker, nor would society ever judge me only in that role were it to be my profession. I am free to determine and pursue my own interests to the best of my abilities. Questions start arising quickly though, including how to judge our wants, pursue our wants, and what affect do ethics have on the answers to these questions. The independence of thought and action can force us to questions what is good and bad. Further, with the secularization seen in modern philosophy, we must decide what motivating and determining forces on which to rely. Both Guignon and Calhoun discuss the focus inward in authenticity and integrity.
                 Even with the independence and freedom of thought, the world around us greatly affects our thoughts. One of the major faults seen in the philosophy of integrity is “this understanding of integrity as a personal virtue, guarding one's integrity must be largely self-protective” (Calhoun 253).  Authenticity as well seeks to “[pull] back from your entanglements in social game-playing and going with the flow so that you can get in touch with your real, innermost self” (Guignon 146).   Modern philosophy unhealthy and inaccurately wants us all to cut the connections and separate the world form ourselves.
However, we are not in a closed system nor are we passive. Yet, removing the self creates the impression that by being authentic or having integrity, we have finally achieved a different sphere from the world. In this different sphere, striving for results does not involve the “outside” world. Calhoun presents counter examples from our judgments of other’s integrities noting in one case, “integrity here seems tightly connected to viewing oneself as a member of an evaluating community and to caring about what that community endorses” (Calhoun 254). Integrity can mean being true to the outside world in many forms including a direct community, an extended nation, the human species, or even for some all the living creatures man is interconnected with on planet Earth. If integrity can be based on these outside factors, the self is also based on all these surroundings. Even this is to passive an approach, Guignon continues by declaring that “to be fully authentic is to recognize the need to be constantly vigilant in one’s society, to be engaged in political action aimed at preserving and reinforcing a way of life that allows for such worthy personal life projects as that of authenticity” (Guignon 162). Upon our shoulders is not only the weight of defining ourselves but also defining the world around us, especially given man’s prominence on the planet.
For better or for worse, individuals are not alone. Working at Marin AIDS Project, I have seen run ups against the system. If the populations attempt to support the poor through medical aid and food stamps, it is seen as socially responsible. However, leaving post-pubescent young-adults with abstinence only education feeds our citizens into these special programs and is morally irresponsible. Using AIDS as an example of immoral based actions which are sounds from the “self” view but not the “non-self” view, one can see many donors who contribute to AIDS organizations across the world but vote for legislation which often foils the very efforts of the organizations they claim to support, major examples for HIV/AIDS include the cutting of public health services of those with the disease, the underfunding or elimination of testing programs, foreign policies which lead to further instability in HIV prevalent areas, and the move to abstinence only education which increases high risk behaviors as well as the social stigma.
Yet, I do not want to say that not caring deeply enough and following issues closely is the only  error in expressing authenticity. One individual recounted a story of his ex-wife trying to but a ranch in Nevada to serve as a wild horse refuge. (Wild horses in Nevada are sterilized in a state program to try to reduce or eliminate the population. Wild horses effect both ranching and native wildlife, some of which has been further endangered by increasing human presence in the state.) Yet, this man was on government aid programs with multiple health problems, and the ex-wife would sell the home they owned in the state to pay for her work in Nevada. Is it moral to confront these skewed priorities, to ask the downtrodden to abandon convictions and get their lives together first? It certainly is accepted to tell middle-class Americans to do just that from changing education plans when college comes during a recession or judge a mother who does not vaccinate her child. Is it condescension or guilt which discourages our judgment of these people in the same fashion? Rather than feeling the actions of the ex-wife authentic or socially progressive, I felt them selfish, misguided, and leeching. This type of blind dedication to a cause without taking in social or practical concerns, “non-self” aspects, even when seen as efforts towards a helpful cause, illustrated to me the dangers of a disconnect between personal wants and true, ethical authenticity and integrity.
We want to feel part of the solution, but both common modern ideals of authenticity and integrity promote ideas of uncompromised, “right answer” pursuits in a multifaceted world in which sometime the most ethical, authentic solutions are ones in which the self is left behind. 

Friday, October 29, 2010

Wednesday, October 27, 2010

Social Virtue

As the final chapters of Charles Guignon's book On Being Authentic unfold we are faced with the final verdict on authenticity. What does it mean to really be authentic? Though Guignon has thus far only given us a historical and factual understanding to the meaning of authenticity, here he finally gives his own opinion of what theories and ideas he thinks make up the true self.

In a nutshell, he believes that we are "self-making or self-fashioning beings"(127) and that "we have the ability to organize our lives into a relatively cohesive story"(130) which we shape by our experiences, interactions, and feelings; these creative, unique configurations make us into self-made people. Though he mentions death, responsibility, and the concept of time, his overpowering concept that he is trying to express deals with the role society plays in forming an authentic self. In previous chapters Guignon has given various accounts on the way society has been viewed in the past in relation to finding the self. What he now proposes is that the best way to look at authenticity is as a "social virtue"(156), not as only a personal one. He argues that we are "shaped and defined by society"(155) and that we find our identity and integrity by being conscious of what the issues of the world are and by enacting our own selves accordingly; "becoming authentic involves becoming more clear-sighted and reflective about the issues that face us in our current situation"(161).

In her essay "Standing for Something", Cheshire Calhoun focuses on the integrity of being. She offers that integrity is a social virtue that is expressed by people who "stand for something". Having something that you are wholeheartedly committed to does not necessarily make you authentic; for example being dedicated to money or power is not usually considered a virtue. It can be considered a virtue if it is being sought after not only for personal gain but for social precedent. She also states that the personal virtues that we do hold help us to conduct ourselves properly with others and allows for relationships of mutual respect to form.

In the service-learning experience I have had so far I have learned more about myself then I thought I would. With this statement I do not want to imply that my rewards have only been to realize my "personal identity", just that I have seen that humans as a whole, which also includes myself, are ever changing and that the encounters and experiences that we have shape us into people who can interact with society and who can develop the virtues that are crucial to living with others. I have visited a few families in the Marin Parents of Multiple's Club outreach program and have seen the dedication that Jana has put in to helping out the struggling parents. I have also personally experienced how my identity has shifted since I have been interacting with mothers, who identify themselves with a different group than I do. Also, I have realized that since I am living in society, I should also be an active member of it not just a self-centered being who focuses inward to find authenticity. By reaching out in my community I have been able to commit to something that will improve the well being of society.


-Ilaria Guerra

Monday, October 25, 2010

Prompt for 11/2: On Being Authentic and "Standing for Something":

Guignon has described the historical movements in intellectual thought that brought us to our present crux that he illuminates in the final chapers: we have the liberty to value the development of our individual being and at the same time we must also take responsibility for the condition of others if we wish to survive and thrive in community, especially in a democratic society.Chesire Calhoun, in “Standing for Something” reinforces Guignon’s final point that authenticity can be most fruitful understood as a “social virtue” (156) in which the personal undertaking o of seeking to be and act authentically is “made possible by a social world in which certain democratic ideals have emerged.”

Both argue for the ways in which our "authentic" identity hinges on our participation with others in the world.
Guignon states this concisely when he summarizes the philosophical views of Bernard Williams:

“It is only through the our social interactions that we become selves whose inner episodes are given enough steadiness and cohesiveness so that our relations to others can be built on cooperation and trust” (155)
And again, later:

“when the ideal of authenticity is understood in terms of its social embodiment [the ways in which we engage with the world] it is clear that being authentic is not just a matter of concentrating on one’s own self, but also involves deliberation about how one’s commitments make contribution to the good of the public world in which one is a participant” (163).

Calhoun similarly argues that “integrity” can and should be seen as a social virtue:
Integrity calls us simultaneously to stand behind our convictions and to take seriously others' doubts about them. Thus, neither ambivalence nor compromise seem inevitably to betoken lack of integrity. If we are not pulled as far as uncertainty or compromise, integrity would at least demand exercising due care in how we go about dissenting. (260)
Please think about one or more of these statements in relation to your service-learning experience, and discuss making connections with other textual quotes/ideas and specifics from your work with the community.