Saturday, February 19, 2011

Prompt for Whatever it Takes: Geoffrey Canada's Quest to Change Harlem and America

Find quotes and places in the text that point to:
What motivates Canada?
What are some of his personal ethical challenges/inner debates?
Can you relate to anyone you have met in your service-learning or to your own experience, thus far?
The second chapter, "Unequal Childhoods," chronicles some of the history of the debate surrounding the causes of generational poverty: "Canada had come up against one of the most nettlesome questions in all of social science: Why are poor people poor?" (23). It is interesting to note how non-objective science can actually be, depending on who is designing the tool of measurement, deciding what should be measured, and how this data should be interpreted--on top of all of this, politics also enters the picture. Paul Tough does a good job of laying out some of the different approaches and attitudes to the issue. What most surprises you? What appears finally to be fair and less biased accounts of some of the root causes of poverty? Can you relate any of these findings to your service-learning or why your community partner organization exists?
Watch Canada on 60 Minutes

2 comments:

  1. Geoffrey Canada wanted to help the children of Harlem break the cycle of poverty and reduce the disparity between them and the rest of America's society. Canada continually analyzed the situation and questioned himself as to how he could be more effective. He was disturbed by, "the waiting list of children who needed his help and couldn't get it". Although he was providing supportive programs, they seemed inadequate to him. His continual questioning allowed him to look deeper and deeper into the problems of Harlem and poverty and refine his approach. Paul Touch explains Canada's drive as, "what mattered was the overall impact he was able to have on the children he was trying to serve". He wasn't satisfied with random assistance programs, he wanted to address the roots of the issues that prevented Harlem's children from becoming, "functioning participants in America's middle-class life". Adding to the problems was deciding which needs to concentrate on and which needs to bypass. Geoffrey Canada's level of unselfish commitment is inspirational and impressive. it is difficult to compare my community or service learning organization with the enormous challenges faced by Mr. Canada.

    I have wondered myself, "why are poor people poor" and was interested to explore this topic. I was shocked by Herrostern and Murray's idea that a lack of intelligence was the cause of black people's poverty! Evidence of successful black people throughout America dispute this claim. As the depression showed, anyone can become poor. Poverty is situational.

    The correlation between an toddler's home life and their potential income level as an adult was surprising. I was aware of the importance of positively reinforcing a child's behavior rather than criticizing them but I did not know it could effect their IQ or determine their effectiveness in society. Laurel stated middle class parents raised there children differently than they had been raised and were unaware how activities would give their children an economic edge in the future. They participated in extra curricular activities available to them or popular at the time and created new roads into the future. This is another division between middle class and the working class. Working class family priorities are more likely to be on basic needs rather than enriching activities without realizing the disadvantage that is occurring.

    While my community partner cannot change a student's home life, they do encourage critical thinking through classroom enrichment and support educational opportunities through scholarships with the hope of inspiring children to reach their full potential.

    ReplyDelete
  2. From Lindsay: Canada's efforts to help our children

    Growing up on eitherside of the tracks, is hard to imagine how one is doing. When your rich growing up, you may not neccessarily think, how are the other kids who are less fortunate then me doing. Vice-Versa as well. Poor kids may not think about kids in rich neighborhoods who go to prestigious and dignified schools. They see whats in front of them and make their choices on doing what they have to do as far as their education.. I believe Canada's influence on wanting to help Harlem kids was because he wanted them to grow up and make a difference as citizens. So he asked himself a series of questions and wanted to know the ulitmate goals for himself and the children that were going to be benefiting from this program he was going to develop. " He wanted them to be able to grow into fully functioning participants in mainstream America middle class-life" ( what ever it takes part 1). Canada had a strong passion to help underprivilged kids. "He was too familiar with the "fade-out" phenomenon, where a group of needy kids are helped along by one program or another, onlyto retirn to the dissapointing mean soon after teh program ends"(whatever it takes part1).

    ReplyDelete

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.