Thursday, February 17, 2011

From Tom: Are you a 20 percenter?

I love Dr. Cornel West. He explains himself with gusto, passion, and alliterative flair like few others alive today. And from sentence to sentence you don't know if he's going to quote Aristotle or start beat-boxing! Dr. West has a fine point made regarding tradition being a struggle. "In Tradition and Individual Talent T. S. Eliot claims that tradition is not something you inherit -- if you want it, you must sacrifice for it. In other words, tradition must be fought for...."(West, pg. 209).

Traditions aren't simply automatic, they're maintained by those that feel they are worthy of maintaining -- or at least you hope others are maintaining them because they are worth maintaining. I think that's one of the salient points in West's narrative, that if a culture grows apathetic and loses its bottom to fight for a better tomorrow, then the culture atrophies like so many grapes on a withered vine.

Is America losing its bottom to fight for better conditions, or a bigger piece of the pie? I think I need a picture to wrap my head around it.



Not quite the statistic quoted by West(top 20 percent owns 94 percent of the wealth), but it's close. It is not hard to figure out why there is such a disparity, after all most of history consisted of tiny groups of elites on one side and hordes of plebs on the other. Naturally, the elites held most of the wealth.

I believe that in America's history it has been one of the few places where you could become an elite through wealth accumulation. Entrepreneurs, inventors & patent holders, and those that just worked hard and served a need well. This wasn't really a choice for many of the new immigrants, however. Blacks, Hispanics, and just about anyone who couldn't readily assimilate into American culture couldn't just hang out a shingle anywhere they wanted.

It has changed over time, but large shares of people find themselves struggling to stay afloat day after day while others seem to afford luxuries like botox and shopping addiction. This is a recipe for disaster according to Dr. West; harbingers of cultural decay and decadence leading to a callousness to the bottom 80 percent by the 20 percent above. Eventually, the 80 percent will get angry.

I can't say for sure if there has ever been a time in human history where this wasn't the case. In fact, I would guess the wealth disparity was worse in the past. But I do think we can't rest on our laurels, and the 80 percenter's need to realize there is a workable path to something better, something they can be involved in.

West states, "The ultimate logic of a market is...I want power now."(Pg 213). Market culture and non-market culture should be separate entities, but one is in danger of being capsized by the other for venal drives. That is the root of the problem, or it might be more correct to say the rootlessness of the problem. That man becomes a solely economic creature unable to emote values, such as honor, justice, and compassion. How one does this, yet maintains personal freedom to individuals I'm not quite certain.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.