Thursday, February 10, 2011

Humanism- Good For You, Good For Me

I enjoyed this reading more than I thought I would when I realized that author Richard Norman was right. "...humanities are worth studying because they foster valuable features of human life and celebrate valuable qualities of human beings" (p.14). With this being said, I believe that both what Norman was arguing for and what he was arguing against is what why it is worth keeping an open mind. I feel that this was an interesting read to me because I am very much a Christian agnostic (p.16). Pico argues that we should use and "cultivate our intellect to study philosophy and theology drawing us closer to God" (p. 4). Conversely, Bertrand Russell states that "the real ally of humanism is not religion but science" (p. 5). The similarities of Pico and Russell are said to be simply, "the dignity of human beings resides in their capacity to use their intelligence and to act as a free man" (p. 5). I believe that the underlying "need" for human beings is to find meaning. This is obviously a subjective and often complex search.Humanism has several different perspectives throughout history. French philosopher Sartre states that there is actually two meanings of humans. One "holds man as the supreme value" (p. 5) and the other is that human beings have no fixed nature but can make themselves what they choose through their exercise of freedom" (p. 6).
"d'Holbach, himself a a thoroughgoing atheist" (p.12) states that "man is the work of nature: He exists in nature: he is submitted to her laws: he can not deliver himself from them" (p. 11).
One of the original voices in the modern Communist movement, Karl Marx was one of the first to use the term "humanism to "...refer to the positive side to atheism" (p. 13).
One school would have you believing if you believe in God, you are right, the other school would have you believing you were wrong. Reminds of Henry Ford's saying, "Whether you think you can or you think you can't, you are right. This reading was valuable to me personally because I could take both sides advice, use my intellect to be my own man and see what I can make of new information bounced against old biases. The question is, am I open-minded because nothing has worked so far and I am miserable in my existence, or because I have had such great success with integrating/ internalizing new ideas.
The difference between an pessimist, optimist, and a realist is that a pessimist complains about the wind, optimist hopes the wind will change, while the realist adjust her/ his sails! Each contributor of this article brought their own bias and agenda. This is clear in Chapter 5 of Norman's book.
I agree with Norman that spirituality is a very elusive quality and sometimes confusing, ambiguous term. " I have to confess that I am quite uncertain about what is meant by spirituality" (p. 136). I find this kind of ironic because he finds this term "slippery, distrustful" (p.136). However, he speaks with real confidence about what he believes in, Humanism! I have no investment in whether Norman believes in God, however, his biases are blaringly loud which is not very scientific/ relying on the objective....

No comments:

Post a Comment

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.