Cornell West's Moral Obligations poses interesting ideas about “...the struggle for decency and dignity, the struggle for freedom and democracy” (first paragraph). The idea that common, ordinary people were once viewed as “weeds and rain drops” (2, bottom paragraph) nothing more than a collective mass, is I think, a viewpoint from elite society. The divide between the haves and the have-nots continues to expand. “One percent of the population owns 48 percent of the total net financial wealth” (3, second paragraph) this statistic supplied by West demonstrates why even though we are one of the richest nations in the world, we still have people living without food or shelter. I find it remarkable that those in the position to make real change (the Bill Gate's and Steve Job's of the multi millionaires club) don't do more to help those less fortunate. West describes a human history of “elites, of kings, queens, princes... all of whom subordinated and exploited everyday people” (3, first paragraph). Think about the victims and the devastation caused by Hurricane Katrina for a moment. Members of our own country desperately waiting for assistance, but it does not come immediately. Yet when another country is devastated, like the Indonesian tsunami victims, the US pledges millions of dollars in aid. This is wonderful and something our nation should do to help others, but why is it so difficult to help those in our own country? As West puts it “These sets of conditions are immoral” (3, third paragraph).
West also mentions the need for “public discourse” when it comes to the “civic responsibilities of corporations” (3, fifth paragraph). Why are corporations growing and CEO's getting richer while local school districts are laying off teachers or closing schools because of a lack of money? Might this be an opportunity for corporations who have “a disproportionate amount of wealth, power, and influence” (3, fifth paragraph) to make a decent and necessary contribution to the betterment of local society?
West's description of 'non-market values' is poignant. “Mercy, justice; they are non-market. Care, service; non-market. Solidarity, fidelity; non-market. Sweetness and kindness and gentleness. All non-market” (5, sixth paragraph). This made me think of my Service Learning client and the difficulty we face - trying to convince administrators, principals, teachers and parents with strong religious or social beliefs to see another side of an issue. “It is hard to convince people that there are alternative options...” (5, seventh paragraph).
As West puts it in his final paragraphs that “there is no overnight solution” (6, second paragraph) to our problems, he does suggest that we look to our past to find 'empathy.' If we can put ourselves in the shoes of those less fortunate, those who faced prejudice and remember their struggles, “...the struggle for decency and dignity, the struggle for freedom and democracy” (first paragraph), than we will as West believes, find hope for a better future. These words remind me of something Du Bois wrote in his book The Souls of Black Folk, where he brings up the famous words upon which our nation was built:
“By every civilized and peaceful method we must strive for the rights which the world accords to men, clinging unwaveringly to those great words which the sons of the Fathers would fain forget: 'We hold these truths to be self-evident: That all men are created equal; that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable rights; that among these are life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness'” (DuBois, 50).
I enjoyed reading Cornel West reading about Moral Obligations.
ReplyDeleteThe question for discussion was, how does West define the "tradition of struggle?
It is interesting that West refers to the begining understanding of Moral Obligations begins "the existential level"( 210) " The tradition always begins at the existential level, with the experience of what it is to be human under specific set of circumstances and conditions" ( 210). I think that as stated that we do start with understanding our past before we can really move on with our future. West explains in page 213 of his growing up how when he was growing up how teh neighborhoods he grew up in were actuakky neighbor hoods and not "hoods" (213) as the young black people called them.