In chapter five, Appiah wrote, "Conversation doesn't have to lead to consensus about anything, especially not values; it's enough that it helps people get used to one another" (85). I found that this line in particular related well to my service-learning experience. That was what much of tutoring at Marin County Community School was for me: getting used to other people who are very much unlike me (though not so much that I couldn't imagine their beliefs or use my imagination to "walk a while in their moccasins," if you will (63)) and people getting used to me.
But the thing about this is that while conversation doesn't have to lead to agreement, it can often lead to an unearthing of commonalities. Commonalities, while not always present, usually are, and they can help us to see something of ourselves in others. Commonalities, no matter how trivial, can help to place us with people who are different than us, rather than against them. In my opinion, it is the commonalities that help us to fully appreciate the differences. Appiah elucidated this when he wrote, "Once we have found enough we share, there is the further possibility that we will be able to enjoy discovering things we do not yet share. That is one of the payoffs of cosmopolitan curiosity. We can learn from one another; or we can simply be intrigued by alternative was of thinking, feeling, and acting" (97).
There was one particular instance of this (of which I have spoken before), when I had a conversation with a girl named Olivia about food. It was getting close to Thanksgiving, and I had asked her what she was doing. She told me, and then proceeded to tell me about all of the food her family makes. Some of it was conventional Thanksgiving food, but much of it was food that I was raised on: collard greens, baked macaroni and cheese--you know, soul food. My mother lived in various Southern states growing up, and makes the best Southern food I've ever had. We had found a commonality here--a love for tasty, home-cooked food. Thus, when we shared things that the other person couldn't easily relate to or understand, we still had this small, unimportant commonality that kept us united.
I realize this is silly. But I find magic in it.
Not silly at all. Food is a very important element of our humanity and it is very strongly rooted also in culture. It nourishes on so many literal and metaphorical levels. . .
ReplyDelete