As I jotted down snippets of ideas that occurred to me as I read this week's assignment, I realized I had a common thread running throughout. Almost everything that struck me in these readings ultimately spoke to me in terms of shifting perspectives. This may not have been Appiah's point in chapters 4-6, but it is certainly the one that jumps out at me.
For instance, in recent years, when asked to explain my spiritual philosophy, I usually say that although I was raised in a protestant family, my brother and I were expected to view the bible as a collection of stories and ideas rather than the actual word of God (how can I believe that something is gospel when it says it is okay to sell your daughter into slavery as it does in Leviticus?). So, it comes as no surprise, at least to me, that I've never been able to accept, among other things, the idea of Immaculate Conception. Because of this, my personal spiritual philosophy has just been to follow the Golden Rule: Do unto others as you would have them do unto you. Well, this has served me well, but thank God I'm not a surgeon who has to grapple with whether or not to give a Jehovah's Witness a blood transfusion (60)!
All these years, I have simply accepted the Golden Rule as a fair and just guideline for my behavior and my expectations for the behavior of others. And, I still think it is--for the most part. But Appiah's argument has caused me to shift my perspective; I had never thought about the Golden Rule in the way that he discusses--that is, that my behavior expectations might not agree with the behavior expectations of others. "The first problem with the Golden Rule, in any of its versions, in practice, is that to apply it I have to know not just why I am doing what I am doing unto others--the description of the act that matters to me--but also how the act will strike others" (61). Given this shift in my perspective, I am no longer sure that my work with my service learning partner is truly beneficial. I see it as beneficial to the homeless population, but those individuals might not agree.
"The idea behind the Golden Rule is that we should take other people's interests seriously, take them into account. It suggests that we learn about other people's situations, and then use our imaginations to walk a while in their moccasins. These are aims that we cosmopolitans endorse. It's just that we can't claim that the way is easy" (63). Hmmm. Yes, I agree; perhaps my definition of the Golden Rule should be to be respectful of other people's beliefs and expect that they will be respectful of mine. Is it enough to recognize individuals rather than masses? Will this alone be enough to help one recognize what someone else's life means within the context of that person's society? While it might, I think that imagination can come into play, as Appiah noted above. As a writer of fiction, I often play little games with myself. I like to imagine a person and "walk a while in their moccasins." This is an exercise that can kick-start the writing process for me, particularly when I am trying to determine a character's actions or motivation. Sometimes, the person I imagine is very much like me, but often the person is as different from me as a sock is to a slab of marble. What, I wonder, is that person doing at that very moment? Time shifts, climate, and societal circumstances are all part of the picture, but I fill in the blanks with my imagination. This exercise provides me with writing material, but the byproduct is that it has helped me to be a more compassionate human being.
Shifting perspectives can happen because of differences in cultures, or even in changes within one society over the course of several generations. What was accepted may be no longer. What is acceptable in one culture may not be acceptable in another. In writing about values, judgments, and reasoning, Appiah notes that "…a good deal of what we intuitively take to be right, we take to be right just because it is what we are used to" (72). In writing about shifting perceptions of why we think certain things, Appiah writes, "And when it comes to change, what moves people is often not an argument from a principle, not a long discussion about values, but just a gradually acquired new way of seeing things" (71). During this portion of the text, Appiah writes about shifting perceptions of homosexuality, social and cultural trends, choices, etc.
But shifts also occur in language, as Appiah notes on page 96. I was recently reminded of this shift when my daughter sent me an e-mail with a quote from a book she was reading. She was aghast at the language used--not, I might add, because she is averse to the use of vulgarity or profanity (wtf!), but rather that a well-known author would use a term that she personally found offensive and demeaning to women. "… it's my own particular, one and only, four starred pussy. The super pussy of all old pussies." Well, my daughter was reading a book that my mother, a very ladylike octogenarian, had lent her. What, my daughter wondered, was Grandma doing reading about pussies--and why did Grandma see nothing wrong with that word? When my daughter asked her this, my mother replied, "You're being willfully obtuse." Hence my daughter's e-mail to me. So then I asked her what book she was reading. It was Agatha Christie's Death of an Expert Witness. Pussy, back then--particularly in England, was a term used to describe an old woman. Hmmm. It makes me wonder why that term was used. Was it because women were considered catty? Was it because they were warm and purred if you treated them well? Was it, in fact, actually rather demeaning? Whatever it was, it was an accepted description of females in the earlier part of the 20th century, but now it is defined as a more vulgar term--and one that implies being female and being weak, i.e., "He's such a pussy," or a crude reference to female genitalia.
Toward the end of our readings this week, Appiah delves further into universals and commonalities. He writes about the differences in perceptions of color, etc., and it got me to thinking about whether there really are any universals. Appiah had already put the kibosh on my personal, but not original, credo: the Golden Rule. Well, of course there are universals, I said to myself. How about this: to be human is to have a gender. To be male or female. But then, I thought, is this really true? Sure, the majority of humans fall into these broad categories, but what about hermaphrodites? What about the man who is sure he should have been born a woman or the woman who is sure she should have been born a man? And then, how do we even categorize what it means to be a man or a woman? What is gender? Ultimately, I suppose, it is that a man has reproductive organs that produce sperm, and a woman has reproductive organs that produce eggs and allow her to carry a fetus. So then, if that's true, what about a person who is born without a uterus or ovaries? Is that person then not a woman? And what about a man who has a vasectomy? Has he rendered himself genderless? And those who are barren--are they genderless? And what about those of us who have the reproductive apparatuses but choose to stymie them by using birth control? Are we denying our genders? And maybe this is a silly argument anyway, since a universal refers to one--it wouldn't be split into two, like I did by defining gender as being male or female. I am giving myself another headache.
But all this also brings me back to my point about shifts in language. When Thomas Jefferson wrote, "…all men are created equal…" one could argue that he was just referring to the male, white, property owners. But it is also likely that he used the word "men" to refer to all humans regardless of gender. I wonder why he didn't say "people"—perhaps he did mean just men. The utilization of words like this to refer to either gender isn't really inclusive; rather, it is just the opposite. I think it underscores the differences and, perhaps, general lack of respect for generations of women. And on this note, sometimes one wants to be able to refer to an individual without qualifying that individual with a gender-specific pronoun. One can do this in the plural with "them," but not in the singular unless you want to refer to someone as an "it." But perhaps I digress.
Appiah notes that humans have many common traits and biological natures (96). In defining Wittgenstein, he writes, "It's a shared human nature…that allows us to make sense of one another" (97). I am thinking about this in relation to my service learning work. To understand the homeless, do I need to understand that, "…the points of entry to cross-cultural conversation are things that are shared by those who are in the conversation. They do not need to be universal; all they need to be is what these particular people have in common. Once we have found enough we share, there is the further possibility that we will be able to enjoy discovering things we do not yet share…We can learn from one another; or we can simply be intrigued by alternative ways of thinking, feeling, and acting" (97). Perhaps what I share with the homeless population that I am trying to serve is, in addition to our geographic location, the need for food, shelter, and hope. Whatever those commonalities might be, I think my perspective has gradually shifted to see what we share rather than what we don’t.
Wow--this is a very astute and very entertaining engagement with the text--Appiah would be enormously pleased to read it, I think as you capture and illustrate exactly what, I think, he is hoping to convey. And yes, morality does need imagination to be sure--empathy comes from our capacity to imagine the situation/experience of others. We can't pretend to know what it feels like to be someone else, to suffer their joys and their pains, but we can use our own experience, our self-awareness to begin to imagine the lives of others. Of course, we have to be careful not to believe that our imaginations are accurate or right, but just the process of extending ourselves imaginatively is an opening and also an acknowledgment of our own "unfinishedness." The challenge is to be open to those shifts in perspectives that allow us to expand, to question our own "vocabulary"/way of seeing the world, while also being able to stand for something--meaning we have to be able to also critically engage views and actions which ultimately can and should be judged as universally wrong--a crime against humanity/individuals. But in order to do all of these things, you have to acknowledge the incredible complexity, as you have started to explore here. But we can't shy away just because it is very difficult and requires knowing when to stretch to further flexibility and when to understand that the contortion is just plain unnatural. Anyone who can justify genocide is a perverted yogi. Okay, enough metaphors but you always get me going! and OMG, the pussy fable is priceless!!!!
ReplyDeleteHee hee. I am really enjoying this book--I find it quite accessible. In fact, I quoted Appiah in the introductory essay of my senior project!
ReplyDeleteBut I have a wee confession: I thought my daughter told me the book was Death of an Expert Witness, but it was really A Murder is Announced by Agatha Christie.
I don't know if other grandmothers call their grandchildren willfully obtuse, but that's my mom. Makes me feel all warm and fuzzy.