Text Reflection: Cosmopolitanism: Ethics in a World of Strangers by Kwame Anthony Appiah
I found our readings to be very interesting, and I appreciate that the author inserts his parenthetical humor into the text. Actually, I think I followed most of the text, but I confess that I found the second chapter a bit confusing; however, since (per the syllabus) we will be discussing this chapter in class, I won't try to hash it out too much right now.
It seems to me that Appiah, in Cosmopolitanism, is trying to find how different cultures are united--or if they are or can be united--by common beliefs and shared responses. I think. Furthermore, I believe Appiah is saying that our universe is full of strangers, but that there are universal characteristics: "Folktales, drama, opera, novels, short stories; biographies, histories, ethnographies; fiction or nonfiction; painting, music, sculpture, and dance: every human civilization has ways to reveal to us values we had not previously recognized or undermine our commitment to values that we had settled into" (30). He notes that, "…evaluating stories together is one of the central human ways of learning to align our responses to the world" (29).
I also thought that Appiah's discussion of how witchcraft comes into play in his homeland of Ghana was quite fascinating. At first I thought, "Pshaw," regarding witchcraft, but then as he went on to explain that just as my type of reaction was undoubtedly due to my upbringing, his Ghanaian relatives were brought up to believe in witchcraft and its power. And really, is that much different from believing in a Holy Trinity (as he also notes) or in omens or superstitions? Is it that different from believing in miraculous births, i.e., those of Jesus, Siddhartha, Lao Tse, etc.? The power of tradition is incredibly influential; likewise, so is the power of thought. If one truly believes something, I think it might be the strength of that particular belief that sustains the individual rather than whether the belief is true or not. Appiah notes, "In belief, as to everything else, each of us must start from where we are" (38).
I will end with a quote from Stuart Chase that I think is apropos: "For those who believe, no proof is necessary. For those who don't believe, no proof is possible."
pretty colors!
ReplyDelete