Friday, March 13, 2009

Arendt asks:

"How can anything relevant for the world we live in arise out of so resultless an enterprize[thinking]?" (p.167)

Could the answer be that thinking is relevant to the world because it results in engaged citizenship?

Are we not both thinker and actor as citizen? To be a citizen of a democracy, means to be engaged. And to be engaged means that it is our collective responsibility (as individuals) to think and especially question, always.

Collective responsibility is not something we do. It is the condition of who we are, politically. Citizenship IS collective responsibility.

"no moral, individual and personal, standards of conduct will ever be able to excuse us from collective responsibility(158). Says Arendt in her quizzical way. But it refers to, I believe, our status, our condition as citizens. We cannot escape it.

Perhaps, what Arendt means to stress is that regardless of our personal belief systems or line of thinking about who we are (the two in one), we can not escape citizenship. Within this context, even inaction would be a form of action, i.e., not voting has consequences equal to that of voting. Not participating rather than inconsequential, may actually mean more to one's community than one might think.

Arendt poses another puzzle in words, she says:

"Two conditions have to be present for collective responsibility: I must be held responsible for something I have not done, and the reason for my responsibility must be my membership in a group (a collective which no voluntary act of mine can dissolve, that is, a membership which is utterly unlike a business partnership which I can dissolve at will(149)."

Now go back and replace "collective responsibility" with "citizenship" and the puzzle appears to be solved. Where else does inaction matter as much as action?

This is how and why the term collective guilt can only be used metaphorically. It is not a literal proposition. I can not be held responsible for what I have not done, and yet I am always responsible for what I have not done within the context of my political group. In other words, I am always responsible to the "collective" as a citizen whether I choose to act or not.

As a citizen, I am always responsible for the banality of evil, especially when I refuse to think or act in a responsible way.

"It is better to suffer wrong than to do wrong"(153) takes on an entirely different meaning as we look at it within the framework of "Citizenship." I can suffer entirely alone as an individual, but to do wrong I necessarily and always involve others. A ripple effect, if you will, is always the result of my action within the larger political group.

When I committ a crime, I affect the whole negatively. When I am the victim, the perpetrator affects the whole negatively. Someone is always acting upon the whole in any overt action. But so too is someone affecting a democracy when one supposes they are doing nothing.

In my mind Arendt's emphasis lies in her admiration of Socrates and the freedoms of the United States. Democracy,and citizenship seem to me to be highly important to Arendt, personally, and influences her thinking. She is always reluctant, however to come right out, and influence ours. If we think for ourselves, however, we may very well come to the conclusion that being a Citizen, whether of a single country,or of the world, requires Responsibility and Judgement.

4 comments:

  1. Christine, this is a powerful and insightful unpacking of Arendt. I think that you are right on target with your insertion of the notion of citizenship and the responsibilities inherent to the functioning of any democracy (United States and beyond). You write:
    "Are we not both thinker and actor as citizen? To be a citizen of a democracy, means to be engaged. And to be engaged means that it is our collective responsibility (as individuals) to think and especially question, always." So, critique is also vital to maintaining a democracy--not just in extreme moments like we have now or in more extreme, such as the Holocaust. It may be of equal importance to employ critical thinking when times do not seem so bad, when we are more easily lulled into complacency. There is always inequity, suffering, or just run of the mill corruption and hypocrisy--even in the best of times. So, thinking is crucial on so many different levels.
    Thank you for this very fine illumination of these central ideas. Did you find concrete connections/implications of these ideas in relation to service with the Richmond Arts Center?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Wow Christine, for someone who has admitted struggling with Arendt's work, you really brought home the key element that is recurrent in her writing, teaching and speaking. Thanks for sharing your struggle over the last couple weeks, and your insight this week.

    For me, Arendt's summation on pages 187 - 189 really began to tie together the various threads of thinking, responsibility, and judgment that have been presented in the pieces Julia's assigned.

    At the risk of committing the very thing Arendt wants to prevent - stating a standard - I took the sentence in the middle of page 189, beginning "If thinking, the two-in-one..," and distilled it to this (read the "->" as "leads to"):
    The process of thinking about what I belive in -> The 2-in-1 intercourse within myself -> The realization of "This I can't live with" -> Judgment, that is "the ability to say 'this is wrong'" in a particular situation -> An over-ride of the tendency to be "too busy to think"

    ReplyDelete
  3. Christine, your post did illuminate some of my thoughts I wasn't able to organize. Thanks!
    Thinking comes as pre-requisite to citizenship, when we "order the house" on what is right and wrong. Arendt, however, made a difference between knowledge and thinking that bothered me to some extent: if thinking is done without the basis of knowledge, even minimal knowledge, it may lead to debatable conclusions about right or wrong. It also bothers me about education as the main road to a full citizenship also because it is my area of community service: without education (knowledge), the thinking process is damaged by many other issues (prejudice, fear, etc), therefore limiting the exercise of citizenship since the moral values achieved by the thinking process would be compromised. My children at the my service learn (acquire knowledge) the culture and then (after thinking) embraces it.
    Am I too far off the track?

    ReplyDelete
  4. One more thought: Christine said: "In my mind Arendt's emphasis lies in her admiration of Socrates", right to the point as Socrates thought that a man must actively decide for a life of virtue to be a good man, to live a good life, and it cannot be done by young people or children. It requires Knowledge acquired through one's life.

    ReplyDelete

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.