Sunday, March 22, 2009
Precarious Life-
Butler has a way of explaining grief that I have never been exposed to. As I'm reading the chapter on 'Violence, Mourning, Politics' in Precarious Life, I can't help but be deeply affected by her take on Mourning. She starts with the question of the human asking, "Who counts as human?" (Butler, 20). Our experiences of loss, vulnerability, grief, and mourning are universal. These are human conditions which are felt on a normal basis which then provoke feelings and actions outside of ourselves. I agree these experiences are a source of moral response. We all have lost someone, whether it being to a physical death, or a death of a relationship. Mourning is a natural process but I believe people look at the concept of mourning completely differently. Like Butler says, "I do not think that successful grieving implies that one has forgotten another person or that something else has come along to take its place, as if full substitutability were something for which we might strive," (Butler, 21). Everyone deals with losses in a different way. Some people choose to distract themselves from the situation and try to forget about the loss as quickly and efficiently as possible, keeping busy and getting rid of all the artifacts and memories from the physical world. Then there are those who soak in the grieving process; don't leave home, and believe they will never grow from this, and sometimes never fully come to terms with the fact of the matter. I look back on of my relationships that ended very badly, with me being broken hearted and alone, and I can't express the deep pain of grief that I felt for more than a year. The end of a reltionship was a death, it was as if someone had died. It was a slow mourning process, and I needed time to come to terms with it, which for me worked. I needed to be able to have the time to properly come to the realization that I am just as good a person being alone then being with him, and I had to find myself again. I lost my true identity by being so caught up in the romance and the fact that I wanted to be someone that I wasn't. My loss was actually my gain, because I was able to truly find myself again and discover what I wanted. Just as Butler says, "one mourns when one accepts that by the loss one undergoes one will be changed, possibly for ever," (Butler, 21). There is a transformation within the mourning, that allows us as humans to reexamine ourselves, our beliefs, and more importantly, our morals. Overall, how could these human experiences NOT be a source of moral response? We are linked as humans through suffering, vulnerability, and mourning.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Butler suggests that because we all exist on the physical plane, that level of existence can enable us to consider ours personal, communal, and national responsibilities differently. Because we are embodied, we are all vulnerable and we all experience loss in each of these circles. If we stay with our grief and broaden our sense of community instead of acting out immediately, we may choose actions that don’t perpetuate harm.
ReplyDelete“The body has its invariably public dimension” (pg. 26), or said another way, “the personal is political.” Self-determination is done in relation to others. I identify myself as “disabled”, or “White”, or “American”. These are all community memberships, and when I act, I represent my community. Conversely, when something happens to me, such as being attacked, it happens to my community.
Because we have physical bodies, we are vulnerable to physical harm. Butler refers to both individual vulnerability and community vulnerability. “Violence is surely a touch of the worst order, a way a primary human vulnerability to other humans is exposed…” (pg. 28). Through physical harm, be it the September 11th attacks, AIDS, or accident, our vulnerability is actualized and we experience loss.
Butler contends that mourning is the key to increasing or decreasing our connection to others in the world. While examining what qualifies a life as “grievable” (pg. 32 & 38) Butler considers the story of Daniel Pearl. Because she shares traits with Daniel – those of family origin, religion, and education – “His story takes me home and tempts me to stay there” (pg 38). His life is grievable because it is ‘known’ to her, because she has a connection to his life.
So, how do we grieve the lives of those we do not know? We can acknowledge the vulnerability of those lives and its commonality with our own vulnerability. “[O]ur utterance enacts the very recognition of vulnerability…. We make the claim, however, precisely because it is not taken for granted” (pg. 43). This recognition “instigate[s] a transformation, to petition the future always in relation to the Other” (pg. 44).
If we don’t rush to resolve our grief, “we develop a point of identification with suffering itself” (pg 30). Through that identification, we can see that suffering is not limited to just oneself, our community, or even our nation, but that suffering is common to all physical beings.
Because we are embodied, we are “…vulnerable to violence; but also to another range of touch, …the physical support for our lives.” This is the gift of embodiment. By understanding that all people of the world are susceptible to harm and care, we can reconsider acting harmfully, and act carefully. “Mindfulness of this vulnerability can become the basis of claims for non-military political solutions” (pg. 29).
While not overtly violent, the AIDS crisis and reaction can illustrate Butler’s premise. When AIDS was first recognized in the United States, it was in the gay population. In the early years, the nation did not perceive the sickness and deaths of gay men as a major concern since it was attributed to a disease known as “gay-cancer” or “gay-related immune deficiency (GRID)”. Gay deaths were not mourned by the nation, because these individual deaths were not widely reported, the victims stories remained untold. Therefore mainstream America felt it had nothing in common with the people affected by this disease. The gay community came together to form its own support networks and organizations like the San Francisco AIDS Foundation to care for its community.
It took several years for the mainstream, heterosexual, population to experience the same pain and loss of AIDS related deaths. That experience of loss spurred greater action. In 1988, seven years after the first deaths in the gay population, the U.S. government launched a national HIV/AIDS education campaign and started needle exchange programs. Once the common vulnerability was realized at a societal level, our national viewpoint changed and a more compassionate response to AIDS was crafted.
The material has been covered so thoroughly and aptly thus far; I struggle with an approach. Yet, thanks the hard work of my predecessors, perhaps I have a chance to "play."
ReplyDeleteI’m imagining a seesaw. On one end is the autonomous body; on the other end is the body politic. Supporting both in the middle by which they teeter is human vulnerability. When one end of this seesaw is down, the other springs into action (so to speak). The autonomous body protects its community only to the degree it can identify with the human vulnerability of its collective group; likewise the body politic (the community to which the individual belongs) protects the individual only to the degree it can recognize the human vulnerability of each autonomous body. It’s a precarious situation, but it works.
That’s if everything is functioning properly. Immediately after September 11, our teeter-totter was summarily dismantled. In its place we got the Crazy Mouse. I still get a little nauseous thinking about it (no joke.) And this is what makes me sick, as Butler puts it in the first paragraph of the Preface: “It was my sense in the fall of 2001 that the United States was missing an opportunity to redefine itself as part of a global community when, instead, it suspended constitutional rights and developed forms of explicit and implicit censorship.”
Being of an inquisitive mind, the shutdown of legitimate information in this situation caused a certain frustrated aggression on my part… (In other words lots of cussing and swearing, but nowhere to take it.) The frustration was this; at our most vulnerable, the body politic had failed to elevate us; an opportunity to engage the entire world with all of its intellectual and material resources was thwarted. What we got instead was censorship.
And this is what I appreciate most about what Butler puts forth, her articulation of the grief I felt for the nation in our rush to the confined values of absolutism. “In a strong sense, the binarism that Bush proposes in which only two positions are possible – “”Either you’re with us or you’re with the terrorists” –make it untenable to hold a position in which one opposes both and queries the terms in which the opposition is framed (p.2). For nowhere in this binarism is there room to consider what Butler refers to as our interdependence. And it is at this point, which so many of us, robbed of our ability to mourn, began to fear that our government teetered dangerously on the brink of totalitarianism, and even our language rang of conspiracy and impending doom.
Which brings us back to our proverbial seesaw and the vulnerability at the intersection of our interdependence and personal responsibility to one another. I think it imperative that we think of this vulnerability also in terms of a residual openness to growth resulting from the mourning of a loss. As Katie says in regards to the potential of this resultant openness: “There is a transformation within the mourning, that allows us as humans to reexamine ourselves, our beliefs, and more importantly, our morals,” And as Steve puts it regarding the acquired insight of vulnerability, “By understanding that all people of the world are susceptible to harm and care, we can reconsider acting harmfully, and act carefully.” VFS!
When it comes to a tragedy especially involving death, it often brings people closer. The loss of one can tighten a community. The loss of thousands can unite a country. Whether we realize it or not, the fact that we lost "follows that we have had, that we have desired and loved, that we have struggled to find conditions for our desire"(p.20). If we hadn't experienced so much joy and happy memories while "we had" then we would not have experienced such sorrow and grief with its loss. I have to agree with the comments above, that going through the mourning process makes us stronger. It takes us within ourselves to examine our emotions, feelings, beliefs and morals. It makes us human and allows us to breakdown enough to connect to others on an equal level.
ReplyDeleteOften it is through loss that we start to recognize the ties and connections we have with others. This being on a human level. "We are undone by each other. And if we aren't, we're missing something" (p.23). I absolutely love this quote. In order to fully live, love and experience we have to allow ourselves to connect with others. This may mean taking down walls and barriers that we put up as protection from getting hurt. This may also be some of the same barriers that we as people set up to dehumanize certain groups in order to limit our emotional response to their distress. Butler points out "how easily human life is annulled" and yet "our lives are profoundly implicated in the lives of others" (p.XVII, 7).
After the events of 9/11 Americans started to unite and connect with one another. They started to help others for the sake of helping because we all were mourning, because we had all experienced loss. While this was all very positive and euphoric, many Americans did not feel as deep of a love for humanity as we may have thought and liked to imagine and ended up taking out their grief and anger on other people and cultures. This dehumanization began to become apparent with the racism towards Muslims that started to occur before and during the War on Iraq. It seems that when anger gets involved with grief and mourning, the “need” to seek revenge and get even seems to creep into play. This may be a huge struggle, but learning to recognize the insignificance in violent attacks towards others, as well as ourselves, both verbally and physically will make a huge difference in the way our community functions. It will strengthen our morality and bring us closer not only to each other but also to other cultures and countries.
In the preface Butler writes, "This fundamental dependency on anonymous others is not a condition I can will away. No security measures will foreclose this dependency... (pg. xii)
ReplyDeleteReading that paragraph and thinking about my own life I feel that we, as humans, are constantly looking to others. We are looking to them to protect us and hold our hand. We like the concept of someone else looking out for us and making sure we are safe at night. I feel that if people stopped thinking about how others should watch over them, and thought about helping others our world would be in a much better state than it currently is.
The idea of service learning through volunteering is something that should be a requirement in all schools and even in the work place. We should be constantly trying to help others out and put them before ourselves.
I have learned that if you do something nice for someone, either a person you know or a complete stranger, they are likely to do something nice for someone that crosses their path.
As humans, we are likely to be selfish instead of selfless. If people started to think less about themselves and more of the people in their lives, we will be on our way to a more successful world. Everyone deserves to have a good life and it is important to make sure we look out for one another.
As I reread Butler again and again (Dion and I are leading the discussion tonight, so I feel the need to over think it) I keep coming back to the first chapter. Is there anyone that doesn’t still ask, why? Butler states “Our collective responsibility not merely as a nation, but as part of an international community based on commitment to equality and non-violent cooperation, requires that we ask how these conditions came about…hearing beyond what we are able to hear”(pg.17). Will we ever engage in a truly honest debate on the cause of the war in Iraq without this? Just as in other aspects of our lives, without the willingness to acknowledge the truth or be open to the possibility of being wrong, we cannot prudently move forward. I think we have to ask ourselves, is examining the truth so daunting, and the thought of taking some responsibility so unacceptable that we would rather ignore it, and possibly continue to perpetuate the same conditions that were present, and made 9/11 possible? That alone seems self defeating. As well, are we any less vulnerable then we were before 9/11, or more? “Conditions do not ‘act’ in the way that individual agents do, but no agent acts without them” (11).
ReplyDeleteWhen I think about the kids at County Community School, I ask myself the same question, why? What has come before this for them? Can we make an impact on their current situation without knowing the conditions by which they have been created? I don’t think we need to understand necessarily, I would never presume to be able to, that would be dishonest. I still would like to know where they have been failed, and how it is that collectively this was allowed to happen, and what it is that I can do, in my own small way, to support and bring about change for them.
Grieving the death of those we dont know is our way of dealing with our own mortality. Death is universal. When death comes sudden and by violent means it makes us look at our own frailty.
ReplyDeleteThe first time I saw a man shot to death I was 20 years old. I did not know the man, but that did not stop me from grieving. I did not sleep for two days after I saw this happen. His name, I later learned, was Ronnie Horton, and all he was trying to do was help his friend who was being beat up by a group of guys in front of a night club. He ran into the crowd and came flying back out with the sound of 3 loud cracks and 3 poofs of fire into the dark sky. Seconds later he was dead lying half in the street and half on the sidewalk.
After 9/11 I was left with the same feeling as when I saw Ronnie Horton Murdered. I was laeft with frief and questioning my own frailty, my own mortality, as well as those who I love. Like Nicole points out it forces us to look at what we have, to take stock in our feelings and prioritize the importance of those in our lives.Butler says "Our own acts are not considered terrorist." We have to asses this on a personal level, when violent acts are perpeterated on the individual it does harm to those around us.
"Is a Muslims life as valuable as legibly First World lives?" (12) In order to view a Muslims life equal to the value of that of an American, one needs to first feel the value of human life is equal regardless of race, gender, politics, or moral values. If an American feels that he is better than a Muslim because his moral views and political opinions are the correct and only way to live by, then he may view the value of his life to be worth more than that of an individual that does not live life with the correct and proper morals and values that he feels one should live by. Is this way of thinking the cause for the disgust and hatred Americans have caused their enemies to feel for them? If we close our minds and cannot see the value of life for our enemies we are seeing the world through a closed mind. To see the world with an open mind would mean, one would need to acquire the ability to see their enemies not as less then worthy but as equals to oneself. To be able to take responsibility of the outcome of one's political and moral views and to be okay with the fact that others may disagree with them, and not to see them as less of a human than they are because they think differently.
ReplyDeleteIt is hard to see the suicide bomber walk into a market place and set off his bomb killing innocent people, including women and children, as a human being equal to oneself! If you only see the person as the violent crime that they committed it will be hard to view them as human. What helps is to try to look at the life that he led and try to imagine or understand the events that individual went through in order to make him feel so passionate about his beliefs, he was willing to die for them.
I incorporate this way of thinking into my service learning. When I first met this one kid at the school, he walked into the classroom with a bad attitude and he was swearing at the teacher for no reason. He did not want to sit in his chair and he walked around the classroom firing up all the other kids trying to engage them in his inappropriate behavior. What is wrong with this kid,I thought to myself. Then I learned more about him and the unfortunate circumstances he has been faced with and had to deal with, and it gave me a better understanding of why he acts the way he does, and with that knowledge I was able to view him as simply a child faced with unfortunate circumstances and not how I first viewed him, as just another problem kid that will probably end up in Juvenile hall if he hasn't spent time there already. Having the ability to be able to understand why people do bad things makes me feel like a better person for being more open minded about others and the world around me.
I have experienced loss a few times. Someone mentioned previously that loss can bring people/community together. I agree with this, on the contrary, the one time my loss was so profound that it brought me further away from my friends (Our best friend died). So I guess the affirmitive in both cases is true. In terms of bringing the person closer or futher apart as the result of grief, one must look at the nature of the relationship, loss, and what it affects in yourself in depth. "Who counts as human? Whose lives count as lives? And finally, What makes for a grievable life (20)?" Butler goes on to so that loss makes a tenous "we" of all of us. Can it ever make a tenous "I" in me and what makes one person's loss greater than another's?
ReplyDeleteButler says, "It is not as if an "I" exists independently over here and then simply loses a "you over there, especially if the attachment to "you" is part of what composes who "I" am (22). This points out that under these conditions you are nobody without that person in the extreme, but most likely who am "I" with out "you"? I must now ask that what if "I" was nobody before "I" lost "you"? And what if "I" became somebody upon that loss and you said, "Look at what I have now become as a result of that loss?" Can you mourn the person that you were?
Half hour later... I guess, upon further reflection, that one loss that drew me away from a community to another thousands of miles away with a spiritual dependency and responsibility to remain loyal to that.
Terrible loss either brings people together or pulls them apart, but at the end of the day, and before you know it one might have better relations to hold us together.