"Responsibility and Judgment consists mainly of lectures on practical philosophy delivered in the 1960s, concentrating on the relationship between the world of public politics and that of personal morality. Arendt argued that the two worlds had a lot in common, in that neither political issues nor moral ones could ever be settled definitively, or by the mechanical application of ready-made categories: The truths of morality and politics were to be brought into being by a process of deliberation rather than discovered by acts of reasoning or observation. Moral and political dilemmas were like artistic ones; they both called for what Kant called "judgment," or the kind of infinite thoughtfulness that is willing to expose its own standards of assessment to the challenge of the issues it encounters. On the other hand, there was also a fundamental difference in that moral judgments are concerned with the self, or the kind of person one wishes to be, whereas political judgments are concerned with the world, and the kind of society one wants to live in. Having established an analytical distinction between public and private life, Arendt went on to warn of the dangers of blurring it in social action."(http://hannaharendt.net/reports/whateverII.html)
Saturday, February 28, 2009
More about Responsibility and Judgment
(I also added more info about Arendt's "phenomenological" approach as comment #25 under the post for last week)
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteEgads! The comments above are just what I've been thinking about this week. But before I go on to my formal submission I want to share something with you all that I stumbled upon. Kinda fun.
ReplyDeletehttp://www.philosophersnet.com/games/morality_play.htm is the link to TPM, or the Philosopher's Magazine.
And they have an activity called "Morality Play."
Their discription:
"In this activity you will be presented with 19 different scenarios. In each case, you will be asked to make a judgment about what is the morally right thing to do. When you have answered all the questions, you will be presented with an analysis of your responses which should reveal some interesting things about your moral framework and how it compares to others who have completed the activity."
It takes about 10 minutes and is not loaded with any form of advertisement or diversions. You might enjoy it... especially if it keeps raining!
There is also a link on the home page to games like Do-It-Yourself-Diety.
Stay dry!
Back later with Blog.
TPM is fun, I enjoy it because it makes philosophy playful and witty! And this is a fun little exercise for sure. But I do want to add the caveat that it is an exercise and whatever it tells you about yourself may have no bearing on reality--meaning what happens when you are actually in one of these situations. So, have fun but don't think that this actually has too much to do with what kind of moral being you are. We will only know that in the moments in which we are not in control and not able to access our purely rational, logical selves. It is the same as ethics classes that use hypothetical situations--this is a synthetic way to explore an idea of morality but maybe not the way that it looks when we are confronted by the situation itself. I still agree with Christine that we should play and have fun with these ideas--but let's not kid ourselves into thinking that this is really going to tell us something about who we are.
ReplyDeleteI think this is why Arendt is so effective as she looks at the way things are/appearances in the world and then unpacks those and doesn't out the cart in front of the horse.
Thinking and remembering is the human way of striking roots, of taking one's place in the world into which we all arrive as strangers (p.100)
ReplyDelete...but limitless, extreme evil is possible only were these self-grown roots, which automatically limit the possiblities are absent (p.101)
Solitude means that though alone, I am together with somebody (myself, that is). It means that I am two in one.(p.98)
And as to the banality of evil:
[Where self-grown roots are absent is where] men skid only over the surface of events, where they permit themselves to be carried away withou ever penetrating into whatever depth they may be capable of (p.101).
These are the things I gleaned from this week's reading. I am interested to watch my thinking more this week and see if my experience is richer. Things seem kinda flat at my SL... and it could stem entirely from the depth of my own thinking. I'll be thinking about the banality of evil also. Where did I read: Morality requires a full stomache?
According to wikipedia.com "Social responsibility is an ethical or ideological theory that an entity whether it is a government, corporation, organization or individual has a responsibility to society." It can have both a negative and positive. This sort of responsibility can be "negative." in the sense that it is a responsibility to refrain from acting in a type of resistance stance. or it can be "positive," meaning there is a responsibility to act also seen as a proactive stance.
ReplyDeleteI feel that it is my social responsibility to spend my time with children that may not always get the attention they want or deserve at home. It is up to me to do whatever I can to encourage this children to be creative in all aspects of their lives. Whether it be in art, sports or even the classroom.
So far I am happy with the decision I have made to work at my SL. I feel that it helps make me a more understanding person as well as more thankful for what I have been lucky to have while growing up.