Wednesday, February 4, 2009

Post New Ideas so that others can see and comment

Christine3500 said...

Re: John Wallace's Article "Making Philosophy Useful"
This idea of "Play" intriques me. The subject of Philosophy has always seemed so lofty and all about thinking. The idea of "doing" philosophy is difficult to get my head around. But the idea of give-and-take is appealing. Learning from one's experiment with philosophical concepts in a "playful" way makes it seem lighter and more manageable. To affect change in a playful way, to me, means to give more of oneself and not be so guarded. PLAY IS a philosophy. Does anyone agree? Disagree? And how playful can one be without drifting over the line of foolish or obnoxious?

8 comments:

  1. The reading, “We Make the Road by Walking,” by Myles Horton and Paulo Freire was about expressing your ideas in society. The goal was to educate people by changing the ideas and structure of society. I like the idea of picking a side and how these two educators went about teaching their own beliefs without getting their egos involved. I found this reading to be relevant to what I am going to pursue for my community service project. The best thing I have to offer is my story and my experiences of what I have gone through.

    ReplyDelete
  2. That is my comment above, Charlie Raven.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Paulo Freire proposes the educator to use as starting point what the student already know. In the alphabetization of adults, in which Paulo Freire excelled in Northeastern Brazil, he used the knowledge of the student in his practical life to induce the discovery of new words. For example, if the student needed to know some specific words to fill a form, he would learn it, before words unuseful to them at that moment. For example, he would learn seeds and sowing, instead of princess and elephant. Like that, theories and many more would be taught. Do you think this approach can be leading the student to other directions, and if so, how can we apply this kind of theory in our community service to be really effective in creating a functioning exercise of citizenship?

    ReplyDelete
  4. We are all philosophers, we all have a morals or ethics that serve as our standpoint, our personal philosophy. However, not all of us have a healthy philosophy. I see the idea of teaching philosophy as trying to equip the student with the ability to rationalize and make decision based on good morals. Being inquisitive is the building block of personal philosophy. It is the philosophy teachers job to aggitate and provocate the thought of his listener. Like Socrates or Horton answering a question with a question that would make one evaluate ones initial response, and then respond accordingly. I beleive that in order for a Philosopher to truely be effective he or she must have passion for the thoughts and ideas they wish to convey.Horton stood on the back of social justice, a cause that he believed deeply in. Because of this he was able to convey and persued others to his philosophy.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Happy Birthday Darwin and Abe Lincoln. Its sort of ironic that these two men share not only the date but they were born on the same day. In some ways the Emmancipation Proclamation marks a step forward in human evolution. Charles Darwin's thereoy of evolution demonstrates to me one of the very best aspects of humanity. Creativity. It took a huge creative leap to come to the conclusion of Evolution. It is good to see organized religion stand up for Darwinian thereoy, however I think that the author has mistaken religion with science when he writes "There are questions that push us beyond the desire for knowledge alone and direct us to the need for the gift of wisdom. Without it the deeper moral structure of truth is denied.Instead of serving humanity, science becomes an instrument of oppression and destruction. Or does it work both ways?

    ReplyDelete
  6. Well I think that you're both right! For sure, science stands the risk of being used as an instrument for destruction--as does religion which can be used to rationalize destructive and inhumane acts also.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I agree as well. Science can easily be used to harm other people or places in an instant. If information gets into the "wrong hands" who knows what could happen. Science was used to make advances in our world, but there are some people who will take that to the next level and cause damage to others.
    Religion is also a touchy subject. People can interpret the words of any religious book and turn it into something negative and destructive. Religion was created to give a feeling of a higher power and make people strive for good in life. With conflicting ideas though, people feel that they must prove their way is right and it could lead to wars because that is what their "god" told them to do.

    ReplyDelete
  8. And going back to philosophy...
    According to Wikipedia.org "Philosophy is the study of general problems concerning matters such as existence, knowledge, truth, beauty, justice, validity, mind, and language."
    Philosophy is something that is around us everyday of our lives. It is up to us to know right from wrong and do what we can to make sure our existence is important to not only other people in our communities and world, but to ourselves. It may sound selfish, but we need to take care of ourselves before we can help other people. What I mean with that is there is no way we can help other people live a better life if our own lives are a mess or in pieces. The only way to help others is to help yourself first. Do you agree with the idea of taking care of yourself first?

    ReplyDelete

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.