Sunday, February 15, 2009

Paul Farmer/Partners in Health--health care as a human right

3 comments:

  1. Even as political liberals in our most recent times advocate for health care as a human right, I have had a problem with the idea. Until... I read a (what I will call)most wonderful passage in the piece by Jacques Barzun as part of last week's assignment:
    "Honor here means knowing how little one brings and how much one has received, and feeling impelled to discharge the debt. Since repaying ancestors is not possible, neighbors and descendants become our natural creditors. To be sure, for those who live without history there are no ancestors to repay. And it is doubtless less agreeable to think of 'debts' than to think of 'rights' which serve our needs incessantly and so make us by instinct 'rights advocates'...To enjoy rights without making a return is the game of the usurper and despoiler."
    I just find this the most honorable way of stating our obligation to others and in the instance of health care, I see the very strong argument for "doing on to others...." Should we not relish the opportunity to pour out this most basic of rights to those with which we share this existence?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Great connection to Barzun, Christine--beautiful!
    I guess I think that healthcare would fall under a universal truth or value like "doing what we can to prevent suffering in the world."
    There is also more than a huge point about healthcare in this video story, at least for me--what do others notice--nuances anyone?

    ReplyDelete
  3. What I noticed in this video segment was that Dr. Farmer did not only believe in free health care, but he took action and developed a hospital in Haiti where children now do not need to die for treatable diseases. It is easy to talk about what we should do, but it takes a true individual such as Dr. Farmer to take action and make a difference. The video inspires me and makes me ask myself what I can do. So what can you do?

    ReplyDelete

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.