I have to argue against Taylor’s viewpoint in The Ethics of Authenticity. I think individualism is a good thing, as is the rise in technology. True, that perhaps this results in what some call the “’disenchantment of our world” (3), but we are replacing the “enchantment” with hard facts and reason, something that is not as pleasing to think about, but is important for the evolution of our species. I agree with Taylor in that change can be seen to affect the mindset of people from older generations in comparison to newer ones. However, I feel that in modern times, what we lack in poetic beauty, we make up for in hard science that goes quite far in advancing society. Taylor argues against the use of technology in decision making, but I think technology is essential in making decisions about how we should run our world. Taylor makes the example on page 5 that because of technology we are “insensitive to the needs of the environment” and our decision making process is a lot colder and more robotic, but that simply is not true. It is technology that makes us sensitive. Technology gives us the information that is otherwise unperceivable. Technology can be used as an extension of our humanity. If we did not have the level of technology that we have now, how would we be able to know the status of our planet? How would we be able know the level of CO2 in parts per million, and what that means for life, without our modern sophistication?
Taylor also argues that technology introverts the members of society, so that they seek value in their individuality. I would argue against this, at least to a point. I agree with the idea that in modern society we are taught to value ourselves, and find our own identities among our collective group. However, in my experience as someone who actively uses technology, and is a product of the society Taylor is describing, I cannot say that collectivism has fallen in the way of individuality. We choose to be individuals, but technology today gives us an immense opportunity to connect, no longer on a house to house, or town to town level, but on a global level. Not all youths are disenfranchised introverts who value keep and value themselves above all. Now, through the internet, we connect as a global family. People from around the world, in areas such as politics, music, art, literature, philosophy, sociology, all connect around the world and share their ideas. Taylor quotes Alexis de Tocqueville in saying that people today are “’enclosed in their own hearts’ and [few] will want to participate actively in self-government” (9). Personally, through the internet, I have been involved in several political movements that have helped change matters around the world. These range from petitions, protests, letters, and awareness raising, all possible thanks to the mass communication technology gives.
I do not believe in the death of the “good old days”, but rather, I believe in its evolution.