Tuesday, September 20, 2011

The Evolution of Society- J. Kiefer O'Sullivan

I have to argue against Taylor’s viewpoint in The Ethics of Authenticity. I think individualism is a good thing, as is the rise in technology. True, that perhaps this results in what some call the “’disenchantment of our world” (3), but we are replacing the “enchantment” with hard facts and reason, something that is not as pleasing to think about, but is important for the evolution of our species. I agree with Taylor in that change can be seen to affect the mindset of people from older generations in comparison to newer ones. However, I feel that in modern times, what we lack in poetic beauty, we make up for in hard science that goes quite far in advancing society. Taylor argues against the use of technology in decision making, but I think technology is essential in making decisions about how we should run our world. Taylor makes the example on page 5 that because of technology we are “insensitive to the needs of the environment” and our decision making process is a lot colder and more robotic, but that simply is not true. It is technology that makes us sensitive. Technology gives us the information that is otherwise unperceivable. Technology can be used as an extension of our humanity. If we did not have the level of technology that we have now, how would we be able to know the status of our planet? How would we be able know the level of CO2 in parts per million, and what that means for life, without our modern sophistication?

Taylor also argues that technology introverts the members of society, so that they seek value in their individuality. I would argue against this, at least to a point. I agree with the idea that in modern society we are taught to value ourselves, and find our own identities among our collective group. However, in my experience as someone who actively uses technology, and is a product of the society Taylor is describing, I cannot say that collectivism has fallen in the way of individuality. We choose to be individuals, but technology today gives us an immense opportunity to connect, no longer on a house to house, or town to town level, but on a global level. Not all youths are disenfranchised introverts who value keep and value themselves above all. Now, through the internet, we connect as a global family. People from around the world, in areas such as politics, music, art, literature, philosophy, sociology, all connect around the world and share their ideas. Taylor quotes Alexis de Tocqueville in saying that people today are “’enclosed in their own hearts’ and [few] will want to participate actively in self-government” (9). Personally, through the internet, I have been involved in several political movements that have helped change matters around the world. These range from petitions, protests, letters, and awareness raising, all possible thanks to the mass communication technology gives.

I do not believe in the death of the “good old days”, but rather, I believe in its evolution.

Qui Suis-Je?

Who am I? Personally, I feel my own thoughts, experiences, and actions shaped me the most throughout my life rather than big groups of people because I could never conform. My whole life I’ve longed for that conformity; to fit in and not stand out amongst the crowd. I have never wanted to be completely independent of others and no matter how much I try to assimilate into a group I would like to identify with, I’m still different. Yet, I struggle to actually know who I am as an individual. Through inability to conform, I’ve only figured out what I’m not. I agree with Porter that, “the self is thus the bit-by-bit product of experience and education; we are what we become…particular parents, surroundings and stimuli produce individuated selves. Identity is thus unique be contingent, and the cumulative product of ceaseless occurrence.”(7) There are categories that I identify with: only child, daughter, female, democrat, biologist; but I do not feel like those genres can define who I am as an individual. I am still working on finding my identity and I am sure that one’s identity changes many times throughout life according to one’s experiences.

In today’s society, your public identity is defined by your occupation. It may not be what you want people to assume about you, but it is a major defining feature about a person if nothing else is known about them. I do not agree with Taylor when he says, “It's not just that people sacrifice their love relationships, and the care of their children, to pursue their career. Something like this has perhaps always existed. The point is that today many people feel called to do this, feel they ought to do this, feel their lives would be somehow wasted or unfulfilled if they didn't do it.”(17) I think people have always been identified by their occupation. Generations ago, one’s last name was their occupation. My great-grandmother’s last name was Baker; based on this fact, I’m sure that one of my ancestors was a baker. They were probably born into the profession and had no choice but to follow in the family footsteps. So they sacrificed relationships and children to pursue a career that they may have been good at, but was in no way a means of inspiring any sort of individual identity within them. In today’s society, we are not born into our profession, we can finally follow our “calling” and if we do land that dream job we can associate it with our identity and be proud of it. If anything, being born into a profession is more unfulfilling because it may not be anywhere close to the individual’s true self.

I do not think that individualism has harmed society. Of course there should be a balance between being an individual and working within a group, but everything requires balance. Although I believe “It takes a village,” (Hillary Clinton) for a society to function properly, I also believe that it is each individual within that village that can contribute something unique and can make society blossom.

~C. Standridge-Folsom

Society vs. the Individual: An Unending Conflict

This topic, like so many others, will never have a definite answer. The most definite answer, I believe, that we will ever achieve is that we must find a balance between what is healthy for society and what is healthy for the individual. Ideally, this would require individuals unafraid to sacrifice for the greater society; and a society that will put the rights and well being of individuals above all else. Clearly, as is demonstrated by our world today, this is not possible. This is partly because all it takes is one person acting on selfish motives to bring down another person, therefore causing that person to feel the need to do the same (a chain reaction). It is also partly due to a society with an obsession of the perfection of the individual, and a government that places the needs of things such as large corporations above those of the individual.


I have to say that in all honesty, I really dislike this whole topic. I believe that my reason for this relates to Taylor’s statement, “There is a certain way of being human that is my way. I am called upon to live my life in this way, and not in imitation of anyone else’s.” (Taylor 29). My objective isn’t really to be who I want to be, or to bring something new to the world. I want to help people through medicine. I want to make people’s lives better and give them the chance to live that they may not have previously had. I think that is why I dislike this topic. My way of living isn’t about being the next Lady Gaga, or changing the norms of society, but it’s not to conform and be society’s image of perfect either. To me it’s not about who you are. It’s about what you do with yourself and the life you’re given.


When discussing the downfalls of individuality, Taylor stated, “People lost the broader vision because they focused on their individual lives.” (Taylor 4). Who is to say that we can’t have both a broad vision and a focus on our individual needs? People need to learn recognize the line between need and want. If you as an individual NEED something, than you should be able to get it. In fact, society should give it to you; however, it is the movement towards a selfish culture which has caused people to lose “the broad vision.” People want things, even if it has a malevolent affect on the larger whole.


Many people complain about how our individuality is being challenged by the conformity of society. Regardless of how much we are bombarded by all of these ideas of perfection and fitting in, we are equally bombarded with the ideas that it’s great to stand out and be who you want to be. I don’t even understand fully what the point of this argument is! Everyone is there own person, whether they want to fit in or stand out. There is no shortage of iconic figures that fit in to societal norms and stand apart from them. On one hand, we are not antisocial creatures. As humans, we feel the need to communicate and form relationships with others. On the other hand, we each have individual wants and needs. When we find a balance between what is good for each other and what is good for ourselves, the world will be a much happier place.

Just Be Yourself

As small children anxious to attend our first day of elementary school, we may have had the experience of asking our mothers right before we entered the classroom, "What if the other kids don't like me?"  Of course the typical reply would be "Just be yourself and they will like you sweetie."  It is highly unlikely that a six year old would understand the depth of that statement; in fact many grown men and women would not be able to either.  But if one actually takes the time to think about it, in order to "just be yourself" one must first know one's self.  Charles Taylor's "Ethics of Authenticity" and Roy Porter's introduction to "Flesh in the Age of Reason; Know Yourself" are writings which concentrate on the idea of the individual.  While Taylor focuses on the negative effects that individualism have caused in today's modern society, Porter wrote about the evolution of the individual throughout history.  
I could not agree more with Taylor's three malaises: Individualism is the cause of 1) The loss of meaning in life; 2)  Instrumental Reasoning in order to gain the greatest profit with the least amount of work; and 3) Lack of Freedom due to the industrial and technological society which we live in.  I will focus on the first malaise, for I feel it is the most significant.  
What is it that makes our lives meaningful?  Personally, I believe it is the relationships we maintain and create with other people and having a true impact in the world in any way.  However, in today's society people are taught to focus on themselves first, and only themselves.  Why give some homeless guy on the street your leftovers from a restaurant when you can eat it the next day for lunch instead of buying something else?  Why give your friend a ride to their house at night when you have to focus on studying for your huge test the following morning?  According to Taylor, "People lost the broader vision because they focussed on  their  individual  lives" (Taylor 4).  The society in which we live in is a dog-eat-dog world where competition is key. By concentrating on oneself and one's own success, we tend to ignore the world around us.  A real life and personal example of this would be the experience of many college students and our connection with world events.  Most of us are more concerned with finishing our homework, hanging out with friends, and even updating our facebooks that we don't even watch the news or read news articles.  It is not that we don't care about the world around us, but it is the fact that we care more about meeting the needs of our own lives.  Taylor acknowledges the fact that, although we do lose meaning in particular aspects of life due to our individualism, "The moral ideal behind self-fulfilment is that of being true to oneself, in a specifically modern understanding of that term" (Taylor 15).  The way we act is directly correlated to us being ourselves in our own society, in a manner in which we know and are familiar with.  However in order to be more satisfied with life in general, it would be logical to attempt to find meaning in all aspects of life and not just the parts directly concerning us.
Porter takes a different view in his writing and focuses on the evolution and development of "the self."  Individualism directly stems from humanism, which was a literary and scholarly movement which "rejected the dogma of the miserable sinner required to abase himself before a jealous God, and began to take delight in man himself as the apex of creation, the master of nature, the wonder of the world" (Porter 3).  Once the spotlight was switched from God to man, it would make sense that it would eventually switch again from man to self.  I never understood this concept until after reading Porter's introduction, and it honestly boggles my mind.  Thinking about the massive amounts of events, people, writings, and time required to change the ideology of the masses is truly humbling.  
A quote Porter cited in his writing stood out to me in particular; "the child is the father of the man" (Porter 7).  At first glance this statement didn't make sense to me, however when taken in context of what was being discussed it was extremely profound.  Porter was talking about John Locke's philosophy of man not being born with innate ideas, but acquiring knowledge solely through experience.  Accepting that the child is the father of the man is accepting that our experience growing up throughout life  has made us into the people we are at this very moment.  Our personalities and attributes were not specifically chosen for us; we make ourselves into who we are in the future, and therefore we are in control of ourselves.  And since I am in control of myself, it is necessary for me to focus on myself in order to grow and understand who I am as an individual; because only I can do that.  If worst comes to worse and one feels as if they have no control of the events occurring in life, I think both Taylor and Porter would agree with Mom's advise to "just be yourself" because we cannot control our lives, but we can control who we are in life.

Monday, September 19, 2011

Taking a Look at Individualism

I found the readings assigned for this week to be especially interesting. Both writings explored human individualism, but in very different ways. The chapters from The Ethics of Authenticity focus on finding a new way to merge individualism with a larger awareness. The selection from Flesh in the Age of Reason, meanwhile, gives more of a history of individualism.

Early in The Ethics of Authenticity, Taylor expounds on basic theory behind individualism. He summarizes, “…everyone has a right to develop their own form of life, grounded on their own sense of what is really important or of value. People are called upon to be true to themselves and to seek their own self-fulfillment” (14). As we progress through the chapters, however, Taylor also warns against fully committing to individualism. He explains that, in allowing people complete freedom of choice without any sort of reference, each option becomes equally valuable and therefore the actual choice ends up being insignificant (37-38). Taylor concludes that some sort of association as to what is meaningful is necessary when using reason to explore one’s own self (40-41).

Another point of view can be seen through Roy Porter, who states outright, “Our contemporary Western secular sense of identity stems directly from transformations occurring in the centuries since the Renaissance” (3). Throughout the chapter of Flesh in the Age of Reason, the reader is given historical examples that helped shaped modern day individualism. One exemplar would be Descartes, the seventeenth century philosopher who believed reasoning is what sets humans apart from other animals (7). Porter also brings up Adam Smith’s economic theory, which suggests that the collective can benefit from individuals making self-centered decisions (9-10).

In short, each text selection gave a unique perspective on human individualism. Taylor attempts to “fix” modern individualism by finding a balance between self-interest and a source of meaning, while Porter looks at what led individualism to become what it is today.

- Christopher Galbick

What difference can we make if we do not share ourselves with the world?

Personally, I do agree that I struggle to find my own identity and individualism yet also yearn to be part of the community. "The first source of worry is individualism" (pg 2). The stage of identity vs. confusion is part of our development and is where we as individuals strive to define ourselves, to find what sets us apart from one another. We want to be original and be known for those differences. It's also a sense of pride and independence. By having an identity of our own, we are able to nourish and enhance that identity and become stronger in our beliefs which allows us to be more comfortable with ourselves. I find myself struggling to find my own sense of individualism because I am still growing, learning and experiencing what life has to offer. With each new experience and teaching I feel that it shifts my perspective on my own identity.
"In other words, the relativism was itself an offshoot of a form of individualism, whose principle is something like this: everyone has a right to develop their own form of life, grounded on their own sense of what is really important or of value. People are called upon to be true to themselves and to seek their own self-fulfilment. What this consists of, each must, in the last instance, determine for him- or herself. No one else can or should try to dictate its content." (pg 14). We make our own choices but are influenced pretty heavily by society, regardless of whether or not we choose to admit it. Further, there is a constant pressure from society, especially in education when students compete to get into certain colleges then later on into different careers, to be authentic. People are looking for the ‘it’ factor and we try to find that ‘it’ factor within ourselves. There is a push to be memorable, unique and sometimes even a little bizarre. Pop star Lady Gaga is known for being extremely peculiar, odd and original from wearing an outfit made of meat to arriving on the red carpet in an egg. People strive to find their own ‘it’ factor that will be accepted by society although they are unknowingly emulating those who have preceded them. We are interdependent on one another yet there is such a movement in society to separate ourselves from the greater whole.
On the other hand, as a society, I feel that although we strive to be independent we also want to be a part of something bigger. We want to be in a club, on a team, or just a group that we can say we belong to. Because of this sense of belonging, we also feel needed, and in turn we feel important; We are a contributing member of society. Being social may seem simplistic, but I feel that it is a vital part of life. If we fail to interact and contribute ourselves to society, what purpose do we really serve? It’s just how Julia says that if a man goes to the top of a mountain and is enlightened but never comes down, what difference does it make? It is the balance between finding one’s own identity and having the ability to share it with the world without becoming lost that we hope to gain.

Individualism and word connotations

Reading the article "Know yourself" made me very angry and frustrated with the author's word choice and myself. While attempting tocalming down enough to be able to write something semi-coherent, I have been listening to Pandora on my computer, and the song "Superman" came on (by Five for Fighting). While listening to "Superman," these lyrics really jumped out at me:
"I can't stand to fly/ I'm not that naive/ I'm just out to find/ The better part of me/ I'm more than a bird/ I'm more than a plane/ I'm more than some pretty face beside the train/ And it's not easy to be me"
I feel that searching for "the better part of me" involves being a part of the greater good, and I do that through whatever volunteering I can be a part of- whether it be helping out through an outreach that my Tae Kwon Do school puts on back home or by being a part of the service learning. Volunteering my time is a way for me to push myself in directions that I would not be able to just by sitting at my computer all day. By being part of something bigger than ourselves, we as humans can accomplish things that can move humanity in a better direction.
As an individual who has been raised with what my mother likes to call "a healthy sense of individualism" and who feels able to put aside my own needs for the common good of a collective group of people, I feel that I disagree with this statement "People lost the broader vision because they focused on their individual lives." (Taylor 4) I don't agree because I feel that there are many people out there in this world who have their goals aligned to benefit humanity- people who want to become doctors or nurses, for instance. Understandably, some people are practising physicians who do their job solely to earn the best possible salary, but I feel that most are in their chosen career in order to make a difference in other peoples' lives.

This reminds of some of the things that I don't like about the article "Know Yourself": wording and connotation issues.

To me, "drug" holds a negative connotation- i.e. you shoot heroin or smoke illicit substances.

I would not call a medication that is a proven aid in helping people live more normal lives a designer drug. Keeping in mind, however, that I understand pharmaceutical companies strike deals with doctors to push the medication to a wider market of individuals. I understand that "designer drugs" are popular because they work well for a broad range of illnesses, but (in this context) it seems to be saying that doctors just prescribe meds without giving much thought to who actually really needs them versus those who would use the medication as a supposed “quick fix.”