Thursday, February 10, 2011

Humanism- Good For You, Good For Me

I enjoyed this reading more than I thought I would when I realized that author Richard Norman was right. "...humanities are worth studying because they foster valuable features of human life and celebrate valuable qualities of human beings" (p.14). With this being said, I believe that both what Norman was arguing for and what he was arguing against is what why it is worth keeping an open mind. I feel that this was an interesting read to me because I am very much a Christian agnostic (p.16). Pico argues that we should use and "cultivate our intellect to study philosophy and theology drawing us closer to God" (p. 4). Conversely, Bertrand Russell states that "the real ally of humanism is not religion but science" (p. 5). The similarities of Pico and Russell are said to be simply, "the dignity of human beings resides in their capacity to use their intelligence and to act as a free man" (p. 5). I believe that the underlying "need" for human beings is to find meaning. This is obviously a subjective and often complex search.Humanism has several different perspectives throughout history. French philosopher Sartre states that there is actually two meanings of humans. One "holds man as the supreme value" (p. 5) and the other is that human beings have no fixed nature but can make themselves what they choose through their exercise of freedom" (p. 6).
"d'Holbach, himself a a thoroughgoing atheist" (p.12) states that "man is the work of nature: He exists in nature: he is submitted to her laws: he can not deliver himself from them" (p. 11).
One of the original voices in the modern Communist movement, Karl Marx was one of the first to use the term "humanism to "...refer to the positive side to atheism" (p. 13).
One school would have you believing if you believe in God, you are right, the other school would have you believing you were wrong. Reminds of Henry Ford's saying, "Whether you think you can or you think you can't, you are right. This reading was valuable to me personally because I could take both sides advice, use my intellect to be my own man and see what I can make of new information bounced against old biases. The question is, am I open-minded because nothing has worked so far and I am miserable in my existence, or because I have had such great success with integrating/ internalizing new ideas.
The difference between an pessimist, optimist, and a realist is that a pessimist complains about the wind, optimist hopes the wind will change, while the realist adjust her/ his sails! Each contributor of this article brought their own bias and agenda. This is clear in Chapter 5 of Norman's book.
I agree with Norman that spirituality is a very elusive quality and sometimes confusing, ambiguous term. " I have to confess that I am quite uncertain about what is meant by spirituality" (p. 136). I find this kind of ironic because he finds this term "slippery, distrustful" (p.136). However, he speaks with real confidence about what he believes in, Humanism! I have no investment in whether Norman believes in God, however, his biases are blaringly loud which is not very scientific/ relying on the objective....

Thursday, February 3, 2011

Finding Strength in What Remains & What is to Come

In the novel Strength in What Remains Deo arrives in New York thinking that he in a sense is going to start his life over, and that everything is going to work out for him. However, he soon begins to realize that not everything is how one imagines it to be. Deo left his land of Bujumbura to get away from all the war, death, poverty, and starvation, but all he gained when he arrived to New York, was the modern version of his old life.

Since the first time Deo stepped foot off of the airplane he experienced a new sense of war: discrimination. Being that Deo did not speak any English nor knew the norms and rules of the U.S. Deo was constantly questioned by authorities and society. Everywhere Deo went he was judged, questioned and misunderstood. Only very few people saw something special in him and helped him along the way.

Since before Deo arrived in America, he was able to gain the affection of a variety of individuals that would eventually help him follow and complete his dreams. It all started with his friend who was able to get him to New York, and throughout this journey there was always someone there when he most needed them.

Although Sharon was a very important figure in Deo’s life one person that impacted me the most as I read his story was the woman whom he helped carry her groceries to her apartment.

““Wait.” He turned back. She said something he didn’t fully understand. The gist seemed to be that she didn’t believe he loved New York, and she wasn’t sure if this would really help him…. She was giving him a twenty-dollar bill!” (Kidder 26)

This quote was very instrumental to me because just like in Deo’s life I go to MCCS not knowing if I am going to make a difference in a student’s life; however, I go anyways because I feel that I might have a chance of at least making a tiny difference. For Deo those twenty dollars that the woman gave him could have served him to buy food, or get to work. The fact that she tipped him more than he gets paid in one day was amazing. It shows that one never knows what kind of affect they may have in someone’s life but the fact that we try to do something to help, can make a world of a difference to that one individual.

It is amazing the impact we can have in one’s life when we think that we cannot make a difference at all. This is the reason I continue at MCCS, in the hope that I can make even the smallest difference in someone’s life, or at least try.

Strength in Hope

Deo's story is amazing. It demonstrates the hope we all desperately want to believe - that anything is possible. I think it is truly remarkable for an individual to view the world as a beautiful place and offer assistance to people in need if they have experienced a similar life to Deo. I was especially drawn to the stories Deo recalled while working for a hospice in New York. Deo reveals a glimpse of his emotional depth when he talks about why he tried to comfort the patients close to death. "Talking to them so that they could die the good death" (157). Deo is able to listen to their life stories and reflect upon his own. "Mostly they said they felt guilty, for having accomplished nothing compared with what they had planned..." (158). This resonates with me because we all have our moments of doubt. We all wonder about the road ahead. What I find interesting is how many people at the end of their journey wish they had done things differently. I guess the one thing humanity shares is finding that ultimate spot, or moment in time, wherein we feel complete, useful, and content. Deo is living proof of someone living the life he loves. When he talked about work and how it felt to walk into the offices of the PIH he said that it had felt like “...one of those transitions he'd read about in Greek myth, when the mortal consigned to the underworld is granted a parole to return to the light” (158). He continued to say that “Walking into that building was like a whole world opening for me. It was like opening my own house...” (158). To read Deo's story and all that he had to endure, and see how he ended up should give everyone strength in hope. Hope to dream for a better tomorrow. Hope to see and perhaps benefit from the generosity of our fellow man. And hope to find our place in the world. “Finally, finally, this is who I am. This kind of work is not just work. It's part of me, my life, me. There is no way of separating that and me. It feels so good!” (159).

My Thoughts

This book deepened my knowledge about the war in Rwanda, which a movie barely did in an hour. Deo, a man who felt he was less than human and finishing his third year of med school had to flee a country he loved dearly. This book also leads to realizations of the necessities and materials objects that we as Americans take for granted. For example, when many Americans are being taking into a home,they would feel thrilled and then soon later feel the act of kindness is justifiable. Deo on t the other hand who was taken in by Nancy and Charlie and began “going to an Ivy league school where he had been mistaken for the son of a King,” felt that he was “ selfish, useless and a parasite” (104). Deo’s character is much different from those of Americans which makes it how for him to adapt. An example would be that in many cultures children are “taught as a child” to be silent. Deo’s adaptations to American culture is just the icing on the cake, it traumatic experience. “According to rough estimates, about fifty thousand Burundians died in the violence of 1993, Hutus and Tutsis in roughly equal numbers… followed the beginning of Deo’s long flight ” (200).

From Tom: "History, more than memory, distorts the present of the past...

...by focusing on big events and making one forget that most people living in the present are otherwise preoccupied, that for them omens often don't exist." I have the Kindle version of this book so it doesn't state the page location like a book would, but that sentence comes from part 1. It's a warning that we all tend to miss the build up to something catastrophic, measured in miles, while all the while arriving to it, measured in inches. Tracy Kidder did such an excellent job with Strength in What Remains, I liken it to a Chips Ahoy cookie: no matter where you bite you're going to get a chip! The chips being extraordinary events and moral exemplars.

That Deo was able to contain an impulse for revenge after going through the horrors of being a refugee, on the run in Burundi then to Rwanda, only to end up back in Bujumbura is exemplified being reunited with Claude, his classmate during an earlier time. "Deo! Are you still alive?" Claude says. Claude continues to tell Deo that all of his family, with the exception of his cousin, is now dead. "God. Okay. Okay." Deo replies, walking in circles around his old dormitory building. Claude walking beside him, saying, "Hey, we can kill too. They also bleed."

I think Deo understands that retribution won't solve anything; it won't bring his family back. When Deo meets up with Jean, whom the locals call a "muzungu" (white person), he is able to win a brief respite. Jean sees Deo, clearly emaciated, and can easily empathize with his trauma. Jean creates a cover story about exporting African coffee for Deo in the hopes of getting him safe passage out of Burundi. "A woman received him at the embassy, a middle-aged woman. She spoke to him in French. He gave her the letter from Jean's father and delivered his lines about selling coffee, but she didn't ask him any questions about that. 'Where have you been?' she asked, like a worried aunt." It was obvious he was on the run.

Most of us can empathize with another person in pain, and it was demonstrated in many places in this text. Sharon, the former Benedictine nun, exemplifies this quality deeper than most. From the sound of it, Sharon was nothing short of a saint. And Deo's intelligence and ethical core was what saw him through this hell and kept him a whole person to the end of the story. Scarred to be sure, but at least whole. Being a lowly cow-herd makes a genuinely noble character in his case.

At the beginning of Chapter 12 there is a great Burundian saying that Deo relates to the author. "When too much is too much or too is too bad, we laugh as if it was too good. You laugh instead of crying. Accidents of birth." Accidents of birth, is right. We don't choose who we are born to. Deo's story could have been mine or yours, the big "What if."

I could go on for pages with this book. I'm grateful that I, and you, are where we are at the time we occupy. Deo could be one of us.

Strength in What Remains

Throughout the book many people show kindness and generosity towards Deo, which is something that he did not see in Rwanda. Deo was greeted with kindness and generosity from many people that were willing to help him survive and further his education. He was not familiar with the lifestyles that many Americans take advantage of. “But then he thought of his parents trying to rebuild their burned house in Kigutu, of his widowed grandmother in Butanza, of his siblings hiding in the forest. And here he is living off Nancy and Charlie and going to an Ivy League school…The words that came into his mind were ‘useless,’ ‘selfish,’ ‘parasite (104).” Many times Deo thought that he was unworthy of his surroundings. We take advantage of the fact that we can go to school and further our educations because we think that it is “normal.” He had to face the challenges of just surviving and continuously thinking about his family. This is a constant struggle for him to understand his own self worth. I believe that many individuals are motivated to kindness in order to feel some sort of self worth, which is something Deo does not understand.

Deo’s questioning of the instructor’s lecture about animals’ and humans’ “rationality” shows a strong connection to the violence that he was surrounded by in Rwanda. The idea of animals being less that humans was unobtainable to him and he questioned what he didn’t agree with. “How could the instructor say that all animals were stupid, that they don’t think, that they had no free will? Maybe we human beings simply didn’t understand their languages. Maybe we hadn’t evolved that far. Maybe animals were laughing at us. If animals killed only for food-as they usually but not always did-then they were more rational than people. What about Rwanda? What did that say about human rationality (185)?” The “human rationality” that Deo is referring to is the violent acts that humans take part in, yet somehow we justify hurting and killing animals. He connects his experiences from his life in Rwanda involving acts of violence that he had been subjected to in order to show that the “rationality” of humans is not any different from animals. The “rationality” of human beings is as simple as nobody wanting violence, but having to do it because they think they have reason to.

Deo's Days

Deo's Days

Deo's childhood was filled with violence which gave him a perspective of almost fearless living as a student at Columbia. He had no idea what he had gotten himself into at the Ivy League University. Deo's life was characterized by the agony of post-trauma yet he had a simplicity about himself. He was able to appreciate the lessons that his elders (i.e. grandfather) had taught him. He was taught dignity from his grandfather at a young age where Lonjino (Deo's grandfather) gave the men back their money (p. 44) so that the old cow (Yaruyange) could die peacefully. I believe this message was important because all around Deo was violence and this fostered a more compassionate side of Burundi life.
Nancy and Charlie continued that human quality when he was in the States. "...Nancy and Charlie's money were paying his way" (p.99). Deo had several people that were interested in his well-being.
Deo's internal dialogue is interesting. Often we are unaware of ours and have no clue what others are thinking.The flashbacks that Deo endured as well as his socially constructed caste systems both here in America and back home. Deo continued to often wonder about other refugees, whether they were Hutus or Tutsis.
I think through Deo's pain and motivation, he was able to assimilate to American culture with a greater appreciation of The Dream. His reading of Infections and Inequalities (p.152) was a book he could resonate with because the stories from around the world, told his story of life in Burundi.