Thursday, May 6, 2010

Let oneself live in awe!

"Life without wonder is not worth living", said Abraham Heschel. I take this as, life without living in the fascination and awe of something greater than oneself, lacks meaning, is boring and this is how people can get jaded. It is interesting that acknowledging there is something bigger than yourself, that there is something out there you will never have control over or understand, can provide meaning and contentment. Anytime I have felt down on myself or my life has been because I have not been allowing myself to see the bigger picture, a sense the wonder and fascination of the world around me. If everyone allowed themselves to be moved, or to accept that they do not know the answers and that it is okay, it would be world changing and wonderfully humbling. If everyone could put their egos aside, and expose themselves, they would see truth and the world would be more "flexible, experimental...boundary crossing,".

The author, Kirk Schneider mentions that magnificence, mystery, faith in the inscrutable and listening love provide glimpses of a "revitalized world". It is these moments of humanity and truth that we become happy, fulfilled and find solace. (Sounds familiar...Jacob Needleman, "Why Can't We Be Good") Just expanding ones view of the world and not being jaded could make an immense transformation. I believe several of the individuals at the Sea Turtle Restoration Project are not jaded nor afraid of exposing themselves and others to the truths/issues our environment and its creatures are facing. Therefore have allowed themselves to be moved. These individuals are dedicated to a cause that is greater than themselves, that is beneficial to all humanity and creatures because they were in awe of the mystery and magnificence of creation. I hope to someday work in Eco-therapy, and think that this idea that "our happiness lies in the understanding that life without wonder is not worth living" is central to making connections with ourselves, others and the natural world.

Saturday, May 1, 2010

The author starts the essay by asking “Who counts as human?”(20). Butler makes a point that we dehumanize people if we don’t know them or see them. She also says that mourning the death of a person does not accomplish a thing. It is simply a way for us to remember a person’s life and it is temporary. Our bodies are our own but when we commit violence it violates someone else’s body. It is our fear that makes us retaliate when others harm us. “When grieving is something to be feared, our fears can give rise to the impulse to resolve it quickly, to banish it in the name of an action invested with the power to restore the loss”(29) When we are afraid we react without thinking, we react irrationally. The war of terrorism is mostly seen through American eyes and our actions were irrational. We were attacked so we responded by fighting back. I think that we acted out of fear but I think that’s human nature. We could have reflected more after the attack but I think what we did was natural.

Part One

In the first reading the Judith Butler writes about the American reaction to 9/11. She thinks that the United States reacted too quickly to this horrific act. We did not wait and contemplate what our reaction should be. Butler believes that George Bush thought there were only two positions. "Either you're with us or your with the terrorists"(2). We responded with force and in my opinion violence only leads to more violence. It is like a circular pattern. In the middle east the United States has committed many violent acts killing thousands of innocent people. Many people believe that we "deserved" the attack. "No doubt there are forms of Left analysis that say simply that the United States has reaped what it has sown"(9). She makes a point that we don't see victims of war as people. Without seeing people face to face we cannot see them as real. We know that these atrocities are happening and we do nothing about it.

Friday, April 30, 2010

from Katherine

=

Explanation And Exonerated Or What We Can Hear

“Since the events of September 11, we have seen both a rise of anti intellectualism and growing acceptance of censorship within the media.” ( p1)

I agree with Judith Butler that after 9/11 the American public lost its voice because the media propagated the horrific event into the psyche of the Nation. The mass media for days filled the air - waves on every channel of the surreal images of the airplanes flying into the World Trade Center. Newspapers, magazines, talk shows, flooded the market with these images and that instilled fear into the public about their safety.

The media orchestrated and instilled fear into the incalculable majority of Americans, and that fear made them unconscious to have thought or ought, to react to the covert actions that the government was assembling. FEAR then triggered the loss of American intellectualism and the acceptance of media censorship.

Through the use of phrases such as, “We are at War” and “War on Terrorism,” the government gained the approval of both liberals and conservatives to abandon the importance and principles of an individuals’ right. Since the Bush administration had attained the approval of the public through fear, this then enabled them to lobby and acquire the necessary votes to pass the “Patriot Act.”

Fear opened the portal for the public to accept the invasion of these rights.

The phrase “We are at War” does not justify the government’s suspension of our civil liberties, or the development of interrogation programs that have used torture to extract information from detainees.

Fear has eroded the confidence of the American people, because fear manifests insecurity and results in the abandonment of our values and principles. After 9/11 the American Government declared war on Afghanistan, and then Iraq. The mass media have been extremely lax in it’s investigative reporting and our government lied to us about arms of mass destruction.

Fear erodes our humanity.

The “public mockery of the peace movement” since the U.S. no longer has a draft system, nor any influential citizens whose sons or daughters been placed in harms way; as a result, their was no voice, that may have incited and supported anti war sentiment Fear is perpetuated in the American psyche, because we now use the explanation that if we allow ourselves to have anti war sentiment, then we will be dishonoring the soldiers like we did in the sixties and the seventies.

Franklin D. Roosevelt uplifted the spirit and the psyche of the American people in his inaugural speech in 1932 during the “Great Depression”. This particular phrase from his speech is just as relevant today as it was then.

“The only thing we have to fear, is fear itself.”

“Who is against us?’ As a result, we respond to the exposure of vulnerability with an assertion of U.S. “leadership” showing once again the contempt we have for international coalitions that are not built and led by The U.S..”(7)

American men and women, Afghanistan-Ian’s, and Iraqis are dying and being maimed every day, we may have a little more media coverage but the voices are silent and the war continues. What will we have gained after the war is over? Today

is April 30th and the 35th anniversary of the end of the War in Vietnam.

According to Political scientist, historian, and diplomat George R. Keenan describes the Vietnam War as “the most disastrous of all Americas’ undertaking over the whole two hundred years of its history.”

58,226 Americans died and 1.5million Vietnamese died.

Current wars 4,394 have died and 31,790 have been wounded.

Blessings and Peace on Earth

Thursday, April 29, 2010

Who Counts, Depends on Who’s Counting

There have been a number of times during my service with Phoenix where the question "who counts?" seems appropriate. Since the work that Phoenix does is with the fringe of the community, the ones which many in the community would rather see in jail and off the street than to lead productive lives within the community.

Butler asks the question, "Who counts as human?" (20) and describes the ways in which our American culture dissects itself from other countries on this principle. While Butler's focus seems to be focused almost exclusively on differences of race and ethnicity, my experience is that it can be applied to ANYONE at ANYTIME. There are areas in this country where blacks and whites were (are) not permitted to be buried in the same cemetery. There are criteria we place on human life in other ways like organ donation lists, and distribution of much needed pharmaceuticals to prevent the spread of AIDS and other devastating diseases.

I believe that the point that Butler is trying to make is that while we have progressed (mostly) beyond the need for Civil Rights the way it was just 50 years ago, that the problem of devaluing others' lives still continues, but in a more covert rather than overt way. Yet our collective devaluation of others is connected to our own. We are all connected through our shared vulnerability of our flesh and bones. This barrier of cells is the thin line that separates us from others, and we get stuck in the idea of our separateness until we are propelled by grief and loss.

Responding to the prompt: "The rise of anti-intellectualism--what does Butler mean by this/how does she illustrate this phenomenon/what are the implications?": On page 2 Butler wrote: "Although we have heard, lately, about the abusive treatment of prisoners, and war "mistakes" have been publicly exposed, it seems that neither the justification nor the cause of the war have been the focus of public intellectual attention." No, well of course not. Despite much public outcry at the time the Bush administration decided ousting Saddam Husein in Iraq was the right way to address preventing further acts of terror of the likes of 9/11, people were forced to shut up under the premise that to keep on arguing and protesting how misdirected the operation seemed (did we forget that Osama bin Laden was behind the twin towers attack?!!), it suddenly became politically incorrect to risk and offending the troops and their families that we just sent off to the war on terror in Iraq. All of a sudden, it was unpatriotic to object, no matter how insane the misdirected attack seemed to so many people. The repeated refrain "if you're not with us, you're against us" made any grey area in public discourse politically dangerous. Peoples right to privacy was being scaled back to the point even our library checkout activities became subject to review, and rules of spying loosened to increase law enforcement's advantages at potentially apprehending terrorists before they act. This is one way in which our intellectual instincts were beaten back.

The discussion of Prince Alwaleed bin Talal's remaks on October 11 in New was a great example of how criticial discourse got completely lambasted during that time as well.

Regarding "Who counts as human?" The discussion of loss of Palestinian liberties and lives compared to Isreali lives in that ongoing conflict, hits home for me. I know many people who are afraid to voice their opinions too openly (like me right now--I admit to being apprehensive) that the Israeli methods of cracking down has gotten out of hand. There is great fear of offending those in powerful positions who put more emphasis and deem Israeli lives more important and worth defending than they do Palestinians lives. Both cultures are human and deserving of basic human dignities and both have a history in and claim on the area. Neither of them will win this fight to control or rid themselves of each other without continuing to incur such sever suffering themselves that the whole effort becomes pointless. It will never create peace or security. But the point Butler seems to be making is that people are afraid to speak their minds, due to the First Worldish "might makes right" attitude. I think this is also might be one of the factors of anti-intellectualism. People are made to be afraid of talking about things in a circumspect manner, because of fear of offending the powerful.