Friday, April 30, 2010

from Katherine

=

Explanation And Exonerated Or What We Can Hear

“Since the events of September 11, we have seen both a rise of anti intellectualism and growing acceptance of censorship within the media.” ( p1)

I agree with Judith Butler that after 9/11 the American public lost its voice because the media propagated the horrific event into the psyche of the Nation. The mass media for days filled the air - waves on every channel of the surreal images of the airplanes flying into the World Trade Center. Newspapers, magazines, talk shows, flooded the market with these images and that instilled fear into the public about their safety.

The media orchestrated and instilled fear into the incalculable majority of Americans, and that fear made them unconscious to have thought or ought, to react to the covert actions that the government was assembling. FEAR then triggered the loss of American intellectualism and the acceptance of media censorship.

Through the use of phrases such as, “We are at War” and “War on Terrorism,” the government gained the approval of both liberals and conservatives to abandon the importance and principles of an individuals’ right. Since the Bush administration had attained the approval of the public through fear, this then enabled them to lobby and acquire the necessary votes to pass the “Patriot Act.”

Fear opened the portal for the public to accept the invasion of these rights.

The phrase “We are at War” does not justify the government’s suspension of our civil liberties, or the development of interrogation programs that have used torture to extract information from detainees.

Fear has eroded the confidence of the American people, because fear manifests insecurity and results in the abandonment of our values and principles. After 9/11 the American Government declared war on Afghanistan, and then Iraq. The mass media have been extremely lax in it’s investigative reporting and our government lied to us about arms of mass destruction.

Fear erodes our humanity.

The “public mockery of the peace movement” since the U.S. no longer has a draft system, nor any influential citizens whose sons or daughters been placed in harms way; as a result, their was no voice, that may have incited and supported anti war sentiment Fear is perpetuated in the American psyche, because we now use the explanation that if we allow ourselves to have anti war sentiment, then we will be dishonoring the soldiers like we did in the sixties and the seventies.

Franklin D. Roosevelt uplifted the spirit and the psyche of the American people in his inaugural speech in 1932 during the “Great Depression”. This particular phrase from his speech is just as relevant today as it was then.

“The only thing we have to fear, is fear itself.”

“Who is against us?’ As a result, we respond to the exposure of vulnerability with an assertion of U.S. “leadership” showing once again the contempt we have for international coalitions that are not built and led by The U.S..”(7)

American men and women, Afghanistan-Ian’s, and Iraqis are dying and being maimed every day, we may have a little more media coverage but the voices are silent and the war continues. What will we have gained after the war is over? Today

is April 30th and the 35th anniversary of the end of the War in Vietnam.

According to Political scientist, historian, and diplomat George R. Keenan describes the Vietnam War as “the most disastrous of all Americas’ undertaking over the whole two hundred years of its history.”

58,226 Americans died and 1.5million Vietnamese died.

Current wars 4,394 have died and 31,790 have been wounded.

Blessings and Peace on Earth

Thursday, April 29, 2010

Who Counts, Depends on Who’s Counting

There have been a number of times during my service with Phoenix where the question "who counts?" seems appropriate. Since the work that Phoenix does is with the fringe of the community, the ones which many in the community would rather see in jail and off the street than to lead productive lives within the community.

Butler asks the question, "Who counts as human?" (20) and describes the ways in which our American culture dissects itself from other countries on this principle. While Butler's focus seems to be focused almost exclusively on differences of race and ethnicity, my experience is that it can be applied to ANYONE at ANYTIME. There are areas in this country where blacks and whites were (are) not permitted to be buried in the same cemetery. There are criteria we place on human life in other ways like organ donation lists, and distribution of much needed pharmaceuticals to prevent the spread of AIDS and other devastating diseases.

I believe that the point that Butler is trying to make is that while we have progressed (mostly) beyond the need for Civil Rights the way it was just 50 years ago, that the problem of devaluing others' lives still continues, but in a more covert rather than overt way. Yet our collective devaluation of others is connected to our own. We are all connected through our shared vulnerability of our flesh and bones. This barrier of cells is the thin line that separates us from others, and we get stuck in the idea of our separateness until we are propelled by grief and loss.

Responding to the prompt: "The rise of anti-intellectualism--what does Butler mean by this/how does she illustrate this phenomenon/what are the implications?": On page 2 Butler wrote: "Although we have heard, lately, about the abusive treatment of prisoners, and war "mistakes" have been publicly exposed, it seems that neither the justification nor the cause of the war have been the focus of public intellectual attention." No, well of course not. Despite much public outcry at the time the Bush administration decided ousting Saddam Husein in Iraq was the right way to address preventing further acts of terror of the likes of 9/11, people were forced to shut up under the premise that to keep on arguing and protesting how misdirected the operation seemed (did we forget that Osama bin Laden was behind the twin towers attack?!!), it suddenly became politically incorrect to risk and offending the troops and their families that we just sent off to the war on terror in Iraq. All of a sudden, it was unpatriotic to object, no matter how insane the misdirected attack seemed to so many people. The repeated refrain "if you're not with us, you're against us" made any grey area in public discourse politically dangerous. Peoples right to privacy was being scaled back to the point even our library checkout activities became subject to review, and rules of spying loosened to increase law enforcement's advantages at potentially apprehending terrorists before they act. This is one way in which our intellectual instincts were beaten back.

The discussion of Prince Alwaleed bin Talal's remaks on October 11 in New was a great example of how criticial discourse got completely lambasted during that time as well.

Regarding "Who counts as human?" The discussion of loss of Palestinian liberties and lives compared to Isreali lives in that ongoing conflict, hits home for me. I know many people who are afraid to voice their opinions too openly (like me right now--I admit to being apprehensive) that the Israeli methods of cracking down has gotten out of hand. There is great fear of offending those in powerful positions who put more emphasis and deem Israeli lives more important and worth defending than they do Palestinians lives. Both cultures are human and deserving of basic human dignities and both have a history in and claim on the area. Neither of them will win this fight to control or rid themselves of each other without continuing to incur such sever suffering themselves that the whole effort becomes pointless. It will never create peace or security. But the point Butler seems to be making is that people are afraid to speak their minds, due to the First Worldish "might makes right" attitude. I think this is also might be one of the factors of anti-intellectualism. People are made to be afraid of talking about things in a circumspect manner, because of fear of offending the powerful.

We are right and that is that!

“We do not need to ground ourselves in a single model of communication, a single model of reason, a single notion of the subject before we are able to act” (48). I realize a few other students have used this quote but I think it sums up a lot of the reading in Precarious Life. For some reason we are very focused on finding a "black or white" answer. For example the quote Judith Butler uses in the Precarious Life by former President George W. Bush, "Either you're with us or you're with the terrorists". Here Bush seems to be giving us two options, but of course there is only one option given. I cannot stand to hear things said like this. These kinds of statements do not allow anyone to think at all, let alone think critically. I believe these statements encourage close-mindedness, laziness and ignorance. Statements like this tell people they do not have to do any of their own research into the issue/situation at hand, that the solution is easy, "you're with us or the terrorists". And if you are "with us" you will do whatever it takes to obliterate these "terrorists". Unfortunately many people do not know the history behind the terrorists, or even who they are and where they come from. I also believe that often people do want to take the easier, lazier route and believe what they are told to believe. But any important decision in portion of life deserves a little more individual research.

I was floored after reading that Rudy Guiliani refused to take the $10 million donation from the Saudi Prince for the World Trade relief effort. What an insult, what disrespect! I agree with the author of Precarious Life in that the Prince only meant to express his thoughts on the issue and suggest that the US take a step back and think about how it is impacting the rest of the world. Clearly many of our leaders in the US are not thinking openly to the other countries of the world.

I think if this kind single-mindedness is encouraged by our governments then it will only lead to single-mindedness and a lack of critical thinking in all aspects of life. Working in the field with my community partner I realized that the main part of the work that they do has to do with education and encouraging people to look deeper into issues like the health of our oceans. Working with the Sea Turtle Restoration Project has opened my eyes to issues I would not have payed any attention to otherwise. I knew that our oceans were in trouble but didn't look any deeper for what the problems were and how I could possibly make a difference. Making educated, well-thought out decisions about every issue in our lives is of extreme importance for our country and for individuals.

no title

If we are not connected to others, we can be consumed by our own little world and our own problems. In everyday life, if we do not take others into consideration, their feelings of grief, accomplishment, pain and pleasure, then we live in a world that is lacking a full range of feeling. One cannot live in a community if they feel no sense of community. Starting at a local level, each individuals everyday life impacts others in a number of ways, as well as others impacting you and I. I think it is unfortunate that most people turn a blind eye to others. Truly an example of "out of sight, out of mind". Having done work in the community, I not only feel like a stronger and more personal attachment to the community, but I also marvel at the unwillingness of many to even lift a finger to make the world, our world, a better place. In most cases, if people just admit that there is an unmet need, or that other people are hurting or going without, then individuals will step up and take action. It certainly is nice to know that as a community and society, there are people that are passionate and care, although it can be a small minority.

From Marty

Connectivity!

Today I was filling out the “Student Final Self-Evaluation” form for my service learning, answering the question of, “In what way were you served by your community partner and the people/communities they serve?” I stated that the experience has expanded my awareness of the struggles of many people who live very near to me, in my own community. The extent of the needs that these people have is enormous and I was surprised by the fact that they are essentially discarded by society as a whole. Butler asks us to ask the question, “Who counts as a human? Whose lives counts as lives? What makes for a grievable life?” (20). It seems there are large sections of our population whose lives do not count and are left by the way side and never grieved for.

Julia, in your prompt you use the quote, “Let’s face it, we’re undone by each other. And if we’re not, we’re missing something” (23). We are missing something when we are not undone by our connection to the suffering of others. We are not undone when we segment our population, when we insulate ourselves from our fellow man and the issues they face and thusly feel no empathy for those who suffer. I finished my service learning several weeks ago, but not a day goes by that I don’t think about the people I interacted with at Vinnie’s. I have been undone by my short relationship to this community. I will go back to it, but my bigger question is how do I get other people to see and feel what I have felt? Can I pass along this “undoneness?” When I try to tell friends and colleagues about my experiences at Vinnie’s there are not many people, outside of my wife, who really care to listen. I have always felt that when people are fat and happy they will never get off their ass and do anything. It is this feeling of uneasiness, this undone instability that forces people to act. While Vinnie’s is doing an incredible service for these people in need, in a strange way, it to is segmenting these people out from the rest of the population. If these folks were allowed to be helped in restaurants that most people frequent, I believe more people would me “undone” by their plight. Can you imagine how people would react? On page 5, Butler states, “Isolating the individuals involved absolves us of the necessity of coming up with a broader explanation for the events.” Now Butler is speaking in regards to 9-11 and Al Qaeda but it is the same basic principal of isolation, blame, make excuses, rashly generalize and move on with our own agendas. Vinnie’s is doing everything it can to help those who have fallen below the poverty line and also continues to keep others from falling victim to the same fate, but the root causes need to be discovered and addressed to truly fix the situation.

Julia’s final quote also made me come undone. “We do not need to ground ourselves in a single model of communication, a single model of reason, a single notion of the subject before we are able to act” (48). Well I am the first to admit I was not grounded in any way shape or form with regards to Vinnie’s. I hate to say it, but if it had not been for Julia’s class, I never would have gone there to volunteer and expose myself to this community. The fact is that I just went there. I did not plan anything or worry about how I was going to fit in or how I was going to relate or communicate with the people there; I just went; I just acted. Hopefully I helped them in a small way and they certainly helped me. Can we force others to volunteer? Can we make everyone take Julia’s class? We can not gain from loss as Butler theorizes, unless we feel the loss first hand.

Failure at walking a very narrow line

Given that I am a former United States Marine, and served during the time when the primary focus of the United States military was in Iraq, which was one of the responses to the attack that occurred on September 11th, 2001, I do not feel that it is appropriate for me to respond to the subject matter discussed in this particular reading. However, I did find much of the questions posed, within the framework of the subject matter to be deeply interesting and worthy of reflection. As such, I will give my thoughts on a few of the questions asked in the text.


"Our fear of understanding a point of view belies a deeper fear that we shall be taken up by it, find it is contagious, become inflected in a morally perilous way by the thinking of the presumed enemy. But why do we assume this?" -- Precarious Life, p. 8

This is a basic fear of the unknown, of challenge to our own deeply held beliefs - ones that we may not actually feel to be on solid ground. We are afraid of the grey that exists in almost all situations - of the full story - as it may force us to adjust and find a complex answer to a question that we thought was simple. Worse, it may force us to examine our actual beliefs, and they may not hold up to support the person we thought that we were. And even more horrifying, we may find that contemplation of this sort will set us adrift - we will no longer have the certainty that we crave for the feeling of safety and self-righteousness that we depend on and that gives us such inner pleasure (that feeling of superiority).
We assume that they are wrong and we are right because to examine the unknown usually leads to understanding - the worst enemy of hate and superiority (or inferiority). The process of examination sends us, for a time, into uncertain waters ... waters that we fear may swallow us up and lead to our destruction. And it does - the destruction of our hate. What replaces this ignorance and these simple ideas is understanding and acceptance that the world is a much more complicated place, one that does not, in fact, much of the time, make much sense to us. This is partly due to the fact that we almost never have enough of the information necessary to truly make an informed decision. Not having all of the information can be maddening - to admit, even to ourselves, that we do not have all the pieces can lead to a feeling of being "out-of-the-loop" and that we are not as important as we like to sometimes think we are. It also can lead to a place of mistrust - which truly can be alarming.
Nevertheless, it is essential that we question ourselves and be willing to seek for other perspectives. There are always more than two. Open-mindedness is a critical tool towards avoiding violence and harm (both of others and ourselves). However, even violence requires an open mind - after all, if we are truly willing to look at different perspectives (especially those that we disagree with), then violence must sometimes be considered. David Webber once wrote that violence is a diplomatic even - it occurs if and when diplomats fail. I agree with this statement fully. I also believe that it is not the military that advocates war - after all, the military is the organization that will suffer the most in the event of such action. No, it is usually the politicians, special interest groups, and even the public that advocates such actions. But, if I am truly open-minded, I must be willing to look at the possibility that perhaps there are other forces (including the military) that encourages war.
All in all, though, it seems to me that the greatest reason for violence, lack of agreement, unity, and aggression, is not failure of diplomacy or anger - it is close-mindedness and willful ignorance.